Who would you label as the 'truest Shinobi' out of these five?

[TheEvilOne]

Kisame for obvious reasons.

Itachi = failure, traitor
Danzo = let Pain to destroy Konoha. Let Orochimaru to kill Hiruzen. Etc.
Tobirama = creator of the Edo Tensei, Uchiha hater
Shisui = a random hyped-up fodder.

 

[Klad]

Kisame all the way .

 

[Naijakid]

And the winner is:
Tobirama

 

[Transcendence]

I'd say a tie between Tobirama and Itachi. The rest of the list is purely opinionated.

 

[Crossroads]

Kisame for obvious reasons.

Itachi = failure, traitor
Danzo = let Pain to destroy Konoha. Let Orochimaru to kill Hiruzen. Etc.
Tobirama = creator of the Edo Tensei, Uchiha hater
Shisui = a random hyped-up fodder.

1. Was doing what he was told by the Hokage and Elder's, not a traitor. He also prevented civil war, which would have let Konoha open and crippled for any village to come and finish them off. Doesn't sound like a failure to me. Also the reason Sasuke is so overpowered now.

2. Without this "Hyped up fodder", Itachi would have never been able to escape Edo Tensei's grasp, and Kabuto would still be on the loose.

GG

#LG

 

[Raekwon26]

Kisame. Not even debating it.

 

[HiddenSound]

Kisame for obvious reasons.

Itachi = failure, traitor
Danzo = let Pain to destroy Konoha. Let Orochimaru to kill Hiruzen. Etc.
Tobirama = creator of the Edo Tensei, Uchiha hater
Shisui = a random hyped-up fodder.

Huh. Didn't know failures and traitors stop wars.
And in regards to Danzō and Hiruzen, what could Danzō have possibly done? He couldn't break that barrier.
Oh and Tobirama. He doesn't hate the Uchiha. Anyone who thinks that doesn't read the manga. And Edo Tensei, so what? The Sage discovered/invented Ninjutsu, is he responsible for every death caused by a Katon or a Raiton? Didn't think so.

 

[H a n]

All of them but I think Danzo just wanted power.

 

[Dantee]

Hashirama is the god of shinobi and admits Itachi was a better shinobi than him.

 

[hearteaterx]

Kisame for certain. He killed everyone he was told to kill, no exceptions, unlike Itachi, who spared 1 person. Tobirama < Itachi/Kisame, he had no *real* shinobi missions like the akatsuki had to put up with. The akatsuki really seemed to have miserable pasts, worse than good ninja. Except Deidara.

 

[Xāvî1]

Itachi who else did you think off

 

[General Lex]

Danzo. He worked from the shadows and got his hands dirty. His methods may sometimes be questionable but he is truly a example of what I believe a shinobi is like. Shadows and deception.

 

[Bad Touch Yakushi]

Tobirama gets my vote. But sadly according to the poll results thiswasjustanotherpopularitycontest.