Who would win? Sasuke v.s. Itachi

[Sharingdork]

Now, here are the conditions of the fight. It's Sasuke as he is now, with EMS, versus the reanimated Itachi, which would mean that he's exactly as he was... At his peak, or just before he died, I'm not sure. Anywho, I'm for Sasuke winning that fight, but what do you think?

 

[Revan]

i think that sasuke now is stronger than itachi was ever before, his amaterasu is further developed, same goes for his susano'o, only in tsukuyomi itachi seems to be still superior.

in his current state itachi would win, if he wasnt on the evil side and therefore braindead (for examples, watch the ambush vs ambush fight), he would win because you cant kill him.


anyways, I predict that tons of naruto/jiraya/minato/itachi-fanboys will show up soon here, with the obvious answer that itachi's far stronger, debatting that we never have seen him with full power and therefore he has to be the shinobi god, superior to anyone apart from minato and so6p and so6p is debatable.

 

[Sharingdork]

i think that sasuke now is stronger than itachi was ever before, his amaterasu is further developed, same goes for his susano'o, only in tsukuyomi itachi seems to be still superior.


anyways, I predict that tons of naruto/jiraya/minato/itachi-fanboys will show up soon here, with the obvious answer that itachi's far stronger, debatting that we never have seen him with full power and therefore he has to be the shinobi god, superior to anyone apart from minato and so6p and so6p is debatable.

in his current state itachi would win, if he wasnt on the evil side and therefore braindead (for examples, watch the ambush vs ambush fight), he would win because you cant kill him.

-_- i completely forgot about that. i guess he would win. unless he saw what he had wished for Sasuke, then he would disappear like Sasori or Shin. which in a way means that the only one who could win against Itachi is Sasuke.

 

[Hinato]

I think i don't know what to write about this thread

 

[SasukeXUchiha]

i think that sasuke now is stronger than itachi was ever before, his amaterasu is further developed, same goes for his susano'o, only in tsukuyomi itachi seems to be still superior.

in his current state itachi would win, if he wasnt on the evil side and therefore braindead (for examples, watch the ambush vs ambush fight), he would win because you cant kill him.


anyways, I predict that tons of naruto/jiraya/minato/itachi-fanboys will show up soon here, with the obvious answer that itachi's far stronger, debatting that we never have seen him with full power and therefore he has to be the shinobi god, superior to anyone apart from minato and so6p and so6p is debatable.

You're wrong on some details. Plus I can give you facts on Itachi being stronger EVEN at not full power. I'm rather a Sasuke fan than Itachi, before you tell me your little "Itachi-fanboy comment".

1.- Sasuke's Amaterasu is the same as Itachi. It is actually Itachi's Amaterasu Sasuke is using.

2.- Sasuke's Susano'o is just the third phase. There are 4 phases of Susano'o so far. First one is skeleton. Second one is muscle tissue. Third one is skin. And fourth one is armor. Itachi's Susano'o is fully developed PLUS has the spiritual item Yata's Mirror, and the Totsuka Blade. Sasuke almost awakened the 4th phase, but his Mangekyou lost it's light.

Itachi's Susano'o:

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke's Susano'o:

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

3.- As you said, Itachi's Tsukuyomi is much stronger. In Danzo and Sasuke's fight, Sasuke tried to use Tsukuyomi, but failed. His genjutsu was too weak.

In any way you see it, if Itachi was alive he would beat Sasuke. THOUGH, we are yet to see Sasuke's new form of his Mangekyou Sharingan, combined with Itachi's. Probably that'll make him as powerful as Itachi.

 

[LemunChan]

Itachi would smash Sasuke.

If not for the body-whittling disease that was taking over his body, I'm sure that Itachi would have given Sasuke something to be ashamed of (even though during that last battle, Itachi was not expecting to survive; even giving the fake "I TAKE YOUR EYES" genjutsu to give Sasuke more of a reason to survive the match).

For another matter, Itachi transferred his Sharingan abilities to Sasuke; therefore, Sasuke would be nowhere near as developed and eye-abusive as he as now. Otherwise, his Amaterasu would never have been obtained and/or as powerful.

Furthermore, Sasuke's eyes whittled away to the point of almost complete blindness and asked Madara to transplant Itachi's eyes into his skull so that he would never lose his sight.

Just sayin'.


~ Lemun.

 

[Allan Hoshigaki]

most likely sasuke cuz he implanted itachis eyes. but if they both justhad the mangekyou sharingan most likely itachi. itachi was the leader of an anbu squad at the age of 13 and mastered the sharingan at the age of 8. if it wasnt for itachi sasuke wouldnt have been half of what he is now. cuz it was itachi poking in him in his forehead implanting techniques in him since he was a kid

 

[Sharingdork]

You're wrong on some details. Plus I can give you facts on Itachi being stronger EVEN at not full power. I'm rather a Sasuke fan than Itachi, before you tell me your little "Itachi-fanboy comment".

1.- Sasuke's Amaterasu is the same as Itachi. It is actually Itachi's Amaterasu Sasuke is using.

2.- Sasuke's Susano'o is just the third phase. There are 4 phases of Susano'o so far. First one is skeleton. Second one is muscle tissue. Third one is skin. And fourth one is armor. Itachi's Susano'o is fully developed PLUS has the spiritual item Yata's Mirror, and the Totsuka Blade. Sasuke almost awakened the 4th phase, but his Mangekyou lost it's light.

Itachi's Susano'o:

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke's Susano'o:

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

3.- As you said, Itachi's Tsukuyomi is much stronger. In Danzo and Sasuke's fight, Sasuke tried to use Tsukuyomi, but failed. His genjutsu was too weak.

In any way you see it, if Itachi was alive he would beat Sasuke. THOUGH, we are yet to see Sasuke's new form of his Mangekyou Sharingan, combined with Itachi's. Probably that'll make him as powerful as Itachi.

though it's Itachi's Amaterasu Sasuke's using, he can manipulate it into shapes, Itachi has never been shown to do that (and, anyways, that's an ability Sasuke has now, and his abilities now are the conditions of the fight). And while Sasuke's Susano-o is weaker in comparison (or so it's said by nearly everyone. I myself don't believe that), Sasuke now has Itachi's eyes, and therefore, Itachi's Susano-o. and with the tsukuyomi, Sasuke MUST be able to use Tsukuyomi, because he can use Susano-o, and it was said that Susano-o can only be used when you unlock Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi (by Itachi! don't fight it).

 

[SasukeXUchiha]

though it's Itachi's Amaterasu Sasuke's using, he can manipulate it into shapes, Itachi has never been shown to do that (and, anyways, that's an ability Sasuke has now, and his abilities now are the conditions of the fight). And while Sasuke's Susano-o is weaker in comparison (or so it's said by nearly everyone. I myself don't believe that), Sasuke now has Itachi's eyes, and therefore, Itachi's Susano-o. and with the tsukuyomi, Sasuke MUST be able to use Tsukuyomi, because he can use Susano-o, and it was said that Susano-o can only be used when you unlock Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi (by Itachi! don't fight it).

You're wrong. If the conditions are "now". We stay to Sasuke's last fight against Kakashi, as we haven't seen Sasuke fight with his new abilities. So Sasuke's sealed at his normal Mangekyou.

 

[Sharingdork]

Now, here are the conditions of the fight. It's Sasuke as he is now, with EMS, versus the reanimated Itachi, which would mean that he's exactly as he was... At his peak, or just before he died, I'm not sure. Anywho, I'm for Sasuke winning that fight, but what do you think?

We're speaking I believe about independent Sasuke, let's leave it on his normal Mangekyou Sharingan. Otherwise Itachi can't fight since he doesn't have eyes. And it's a fact Sasuke's Susano'o right now is weaker than Itachi's. By far.

Sasuke has EMS, and Itachi has his eyes. And i know that reanimated Itachi can't be killed, unless whatever he wished for Sasuke is fufilled, in which case it would be like Shin or Sasori disappearing. but assuming that Itachi could be killed by normal means, Sasuke would win due to him having Itachi's eyes and abilities, and even more due to his EMS. assuming that Itachi couldn't be killed by normal means (as would be the case) the only one capable of killing Itachi would be Sasuke. in either scenario that was produced by my battle conditions, Sasuke is the victor

 

[DeathPulse16]

This is a pretty simple case. If we judge by now, then we can assume sasuke has his EMS. Just because we haven't seen him use it doesn't change the fact that he DOES have it. Also, his sharingan is stronger than itachi's. Plenty of characters have made this observation, mostly orochimaru, who stated that exact fact at least 4 times along with madara and i believe kisame. He is using itachis amaterasu, yes but, he's also gone beyond what itachi could do with it, making the amaterasu his own in his own right. I believe sasuke's susano'o is stronger than itachis. It's possible that since he has itachis eyes that his susano'o now possesses the rare sword and shield itachis had. Also, i never recall itachis susano'o using arrow like projectiles and he has some skill at tsukuyomi, he witnessed him using this to get the information on where to find killer bee, we can't say how good he was at using it but, as i recall, he got his information in a matter of seconds.

 

[Amaterasuice]

If it was non edo Itachi, Sasuke would win.

Itachi has the weapos+susanoo, tsukyomi, amaterasu, and izanami.

Sasuke has ems susanoo, tsukyomi, amaterasu/blaze release, and kirin.

The weapons should+susanoo should give even ems susanoo a problem, but really, Sasuke has more charka reserves and won't run out long before Itachi.

Tsukyomi is prob equal, but that's speculation (he hasn't used tsukyomi since before ems). Itachi has been shown to be better at it..But a 3 tamoe sharingan can get out of both anyway.

Amaterasu/blaze release will pawn a regular amaterasu with ease.

Kirin alone could destroy Itachi's susanoo, so that's another problem for Itachi.

Izanami will be the only true problem for Sasuke. But like Izanagi, Itachi's eyes will close forever. And well, Sasuke's already beaten a multiple use guy with Izanagi, so....

Sasuke wins, unless it's edo itachi. Sasuke doesn't have sealing jutsu.

 

[iMicLykTyson]

If it was non edo Itachi, Sasuke would win.

Itachi has the weapos+susanoo, tsukyomi, amaterasu, and izanami.

Sasuke has ems susanoo, tsukyomi, amaterasu/blaze release, and kirin.

The weapons should+susanoo should give even ems susanoo a problem, but really, Sasuke has more charka reserves and won't run out long before Itachi.

Tsukyomi is prob equal, but that's speculation (he hasn't used tsukyomi since before ems). Itachi has been shown to be better at it..But a 3 tamoe sharingan can get out of both anyway.

Amaterasu/blaze release will pawn a regular amaterasu with ease.

Kirin alone could destroy Itachi's susanoo, so that's another problem for Itachi.

Izanami will be the only true problem for Sasuke. But like Izanagi, Itachi's eyes will close forever. And well, Sasuke's already beaten a multiple use guy with Izanagi, so....

Sasuke wins, unless it's edo itachi. Sasuke doesn't have sealing jutsu.

if sasuke is caught in izanami he is done for.

 

[partha420]

Sasuke>itachi U_U