[Discussion] Who do you want to Join vs not want to join the straw hats

MickNerks

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
6,585
Kin
77💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No his fruit if fixed could be haxxxed as hell He is an eastern japanese dragon based off of the looks. A dragon that controls storms on the sea.
A DF that controls water based storms.
Plus its immortal.
So yea....
Thats cool, and i believe he should be able to control stroms after seeing him create clouds. But what I am saying is that he is far from being able to control his devil fruit. He currently cant even control his transformation properly, I think it would be better for him to go train with it more and then come back to the straw hats. I feel as thought training with them would in some way burden them as they would always have to protect him when things got intense.

But maybe by the end of this arc he will have better control after dealing with Big Mom, so who knows maybe he will be able to handle his own.
 

Tomato God

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
How do you know Sabo, but not know the Going Merry was destroyed? Lol

OT:
Vivi, Viola, or Jimbei

The rest are annoying
He doesnt know about sabo... And try not to spoil it for him.
He was referring to child sabo.
Thats cool, and i believe he should be able to control stroms after seeing him create clouds. But what I am saying is that he is far from being able to control his devil fruit. He currently cant even control his transformation properly, I think it would be better for him to go train with it more and then come back to the straw hats. I feel as thought training with them would in some way burden them as they would always have to protect him when things got intense.

But maybe by the end of this arc he will have better control after dealing with Big Mom, so who knows maybe he will be able to handle his own.
But don't forget he must have something special thats why Doffy wanted him so much. And thats BEFORE he had his fruit. And as weak as he is we always could chalk it up to his fruit being broken... All the months he had it he could have been training it but because its broken it wasnt helpful. Chopper is qualified to fix it. He does experiments with his own fruit plus rumble ball could help him.
 

ZoroXTashigi

Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
331
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I do...
1. Jinbei, just because.
2. Girl with logia fruit.
3. Man with stick weapon.
4. Giant with zoan fruit.

I don't ...
1. Momonosuke, because he will become future Shogun of Wano Kuni ... and future ally with Pirate King in order to defeat World Government.
2. Kin'emon, because he is swordsman.
3. Bellamy, just because.
4. Kuzan, he rather become Rev than Pirate.
5. Trafalgar D. Water Law, because he is swordsman, doctor, stronger than Zoro, and pirate captain.
6. Kyros and Viola, just because.
7. .....
 

Tomato God

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I do...
1. Jinbei, just because.
2. Girl with logia fruit.
3. Man with stick weapon.
4. Giant with zoan fruit.

I don't ...
1. Momonosuke, because he will become future Shogun of Wano Kuni ... and future ally with Pirate King in order to defeat World Government.
2. Kin'emon, because he is swordsman.
3. Bellamy, just because.
4. Kuzan, he rather become Rev than Pirate.
5. Trafalgar D. Water Law, because he is swordsman, doctor, stronger than Zoro, and pirate captain.
6. Kyros and Viola, just because.
7. .....
Gaint with a mythical zoan that makes him bigger would be rape.
 

sage1999

Active member
Regular
Joined
Apr 6, 2012
Messages
1,623
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
even the roger pirates had some1 weak like buggy. Usopp is now not so weak since he awakened a badass haki and nami is stronger than buggy due to her weather manipulation. However, I would like Bartolomeo to join the revolutionaries and bellamy to join the Strawhats.

Another person who should join straw hats is jinbei obviously .Momonusuke and Kinemon should deco join imo, and it would add more variation to the Straw hats. Rebecca shouldn't cos while she is strong she need to spend time with her dad. Viola is 2 old imo
 

Beyonce

Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2014
Messages
104
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
He doesnt know about sabo... And try not to spoil it for him.
He was referring to child sabo.
You realize child Sabo was introduced after the Going Merry was destroyed as well.
Not even a spoiler anymore because it's been shown in the anime
why would he say Sabo to join if he was presumably dead at the time?
 

Tomato God

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You realize child Sabo was introduced after the Going Merry was destroyed as well.
Not even a spoiler anymore because it's been shown in the anime
why would he say Sabo to join if he was presumably dead at the time?
Oh wait... he was probably trolling us or mixed up the sunny and the merry.
 

KGB Kakuzu

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
12,448
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Do

Jinbei- simply because he's been asked to join.

Not

Anyone else



If we add a female character, given Oda's God awful track record she just becomes another stack of titted sticks that serves 90% fan service and 10% other stuff.

Honestly at this point I'd prefer Oda to focus and further develop the people he has.

So far his ability to balance development with 9 protagonists has been poor to say the least. Why bother adding another two or three when what we've got already gets poorly developed.

Zoro is virtually nothing more than a guy who says nothing until a fight. Then snaps a cheesy as hell one liner and shots on his enemy.

Sanji has been stuck either womanizing or running into virtually the worst situations possible match ups.

Nami can't find a shirt to save her life. At least she's one of the only SH consistently developing post skip.

Robin: Ussop has probably done more in two arcs than she's done the entire story. Oh and she can't seem to find A pair of pants.

Franky: only really shined during PH and a moment on Dressrosa.

Chopper: other than Punk Hazard Chopper hasn't done much.

Brook: Has done nothing much.



The SH's hardly interact like they used to. Zoro virtually only interacts with is Luffy...and that was to tell him to get serious. Well and his bickering with Sanji. Remember when he'd constantly get bosses around by Nami and was the manly man of Chopper's inspiration?

Quality is better than quantity. I'd prefer we stick with what we have and better develops them and have them interact with each other forming unique bonds than to watch a couple get solid development while the rest look like clowns.
 

Tomato God

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Do

Jinbei- simply because he's been asked to join.

Not

Anyone else



If we add a female character, given Oda's God awful track record she just becomes another stack of titted sticks that serves 90% fan service and 10% other stuff.

Honestly at this point I'd prefer Oda to focus and further develop the people he has.

So far his ability to balance development with 9 protagonists has been poor to say the least. Why bother adding another two or three when what we've got already gets poorly developed.

Zoro is virtually nothing more than a guy who says nothing until a fight. Then snaps a cheesy as hell one liner and shots on his enemy.

Sanji has been stuck either womanizing or running into virtually the worst situations possible match ups.

Nami can't find a shirt to save her life. At least she's one of the only SH consistently developing post skip.

Robin: Ussop has probably done more in two arcs than she's done the entire story. Oh and she can't seem to find A pair of pants.

Franky: only really shined during PH and a moment on Dressrosa.

Chopper: other than Punk Hazard Chopper hasn't done much.

Brook: Has done nothing much.



The SH's hardly interact like they used to. Zoro virtually only interacts with is Luffy...and that was to tell him to get serious. Well and his bickering with Sanji. Remember when he'd constantly get bosses around by Nami and was the manly man of Chopper's inspiration?

Quality is better than quantity. I'd prefer we stick with what we have and better develops them and have them interact with each other forming unique bonds than to watch a couple get solid development while the rest look like clowns.
Before I say what I am gonna say please please PLEASE know that i do not disagree with your opininon or think its wrong i just do not share it to be my own.

Nami/Robin dressing differently than she used to is because the art style is different than it used to be and even then we had fanservice. In a shonen manga its to be expected.

And Sanji has not only shown more development (all be it in a wrong direction) first off he showed a side of him never seen before with kinemon and it was an intense responsiblity to follow through with things. Meets a guy and saves his life but will go out of his way to make sure he is 110% after that. And even with Viola as much as he is a pervert this arc showed he genuinely cares about women even enough to not lie to them ever.

Sanji has went from perverted bad ass to warm hearted yet stoic Cook in a matter of 3 arcs.

Fanky has just been upping his manliness and Zoro hasn't been sleeping more or less he has been sleeping the same remember when he slept through the entire trip to alabasta and then only got up to fight. Plus even in 2 seconds of dialog with his line to pika he shown ambition to not only beat Mihawk but to be recognized and not walk in luffy's shadow.

Chopper has shown his limits healing the kids before Law walked in. He has shown his bravery and show that he still holds his intesnse need for someone to protect him exclaiming that aslong as sanji is on the boat with them they should be safe. YET still fought with out heasitation in the fight agaist crazy toy lady. He is coping with his fear better than before.

Usops is the man.

And for brook i agree completely but how can you develop an 80 + year old man who is already who he is gonna be.
 

Rikud0 Sennin

Active member
Regular
Joined
Nov 16, 2012
Messages
645
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Do's
1. Someone who knows Fishman Karate. = Jimbei, but I want him to die... Doesn't he have a massive hole in his chest now?
2. Girl with logia fruit. =Monet
3. Violet cuz shes cool.
4. Momonusuke or a Dwarf.

I don't ...
1. Kin'emon, because we dont need another swordsman.
3. Bellamy, because I want Luffy to kill him right now.
4. Kuzan, he rather become Rev than Pirate.
5. Trafalgar D. Water Law. Ally, not nakama
6. Kyros or Rebecca. Nope.
7. Bartolomeu. I like him, but him fangasming to the point where he is incapable of speech isn't cool. He would die happy tho. He does have a boss DF. So, same boat as Law. Ally, not nakama.
 
Last edited:

Dęvîa Puęrî

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
8,478
Kin
515💸
Kumi
7💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I'm for kinnimon or barto (I can see why u think he would be annoying every episode but his abilities can b very useful espcially with escaping marines for the sunny)
Or violet since her and sanji love one another and her abilities R also very useful

Who I don't want

Rebecca -.- dnt need to explain why

Kazan to strong will throw power scaling off maybe as an ally like law

Law has his own crew also too strong (well he's a little bit stronger then luffy) will throw main 3 out of wack left better as an ally

I really dnt want ****ing Bellamy either


I'm iffy on jinbe as well but his abilities can b greatly used when against df users ..
 

Ryuma720

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 20, 2014
Messages
1,941
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
What I want to join:
Viola
Jinbei
Ucy
Logia DF user
ex Kaido's crew member

(But the StrawHats need at least 2 more females)


Who I'm unsure but be ok with:
Koala
Kuzan
Bellamy
Leo
Baby 5
Canvendish
Bartolomeo
Bonney
Boa Hancock


Who I don't want to join:
Rebecca
Momosuke
Kin'emon
 
Last edited:

Tomato God

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
What I want to join:
Viola
Jinbei
Ucy
Logia DF user
ex Kaido's crew member

(But the StrawHats need at least 2 more females)


Who I'm unsure but be ok with:
Koala
Kuzan
Bellamy
Leo
Baby 5
Canvendish
Bartolomeo
Bonney
Boa Hancock


Who I don't want to join:
Rebecca
Momosuke
Kin'emon
Can you please explain your disdain for kinemon and momo?!!?
 
Top