[Discussion] Who do you want to Join vs not want to join the straw hats

[Tomato God]

Who do you really dislike enough to nnot want them to join the straw hats​

My list of Do

• Koala
  
  She is a fishman karate master plus her backstory makes me sad beyond jimbei's... Its like she is jimbe with a sadder back story and with boobs. Plus this
  

  Spoiler

  You must be registered for see images
• Vivi
  
  she is like rebbeca only braver and way better. Like Rebbeca but not a cheap knock off. Plus seeing her in every strawhats and animal cover without seeing her in the actual chapter annoys me.​
• Bellamy
  
  HE IS THE REAL MVP​

My list of Do nots

• Rebecca
  
  Another great character but her personality as a cry baby is offsetting​
• Barto
  
  He is a great character it just seems like everyweek seeing him would be too much​
• Kuzan
  
  IMO his personality is like a male robin... super serious super secertive and a trained killer.​

 

[Olorin]

I like Jinbe

I don't want Bellamy

 

[ahmo]

I just don't want the straws taking any new crew mate from this arc

 

[Ridoku X]

Do's:

Jimbei
Bellamy
Bartolomeo
Marco
Kinemon
Momonosuke
Law

Don't(s)

Violet
Rebecca
Kuzan


I am not talking about them being allies or whatever v_v

 

[MickNerks]

Do's

Jimbei
Bartolomeo ( Dream is to Sail with the Straw Hats)
Crocodile (Perfect Logia User)


Don't

Momonosuke (Too Weak)
Violet
Rebecca
Law (Shichibukai, and has a cool crew that I would like to see develope, mostly the bear)
Bellamy (His DF seems to be redundant to luffys)
Kinemon (SH already have 2 swordsman)
Kuzan (Rather have him join the Revolutionaries)

 

[Tomato God]

Do's:

Jimbei
Bellamy
Bartolomeo
Marco
Kinemon
Momonosuke
Law

Don't(s)

Violet
Rebecca
Kuzan


I am not talking about them being allies or whatever v_v

Do's

Jimbei
Bartolomeo ( Dream is to Sail with the Straw Hats)
Crocodile (Perfect Logia User)


Don't

Momonosuke (Too Weak)
Violet
Rebecca
Law (Shichibukai, and has a cool crew that I would like to see develope, mostly the bear)
Bellamy (His DF seems to be redundant to luffys)
Kinemon (SH already have 2 swordsman)
Kuzan (Rather have him join the Revolutionaries)

Forgot momo and Kinemon.


They get thrown on my DO list
Kinemon

Beast swordsman. Zoro Can Create tornados and his pound cannons of air and Brook can create ice so having a fire swordsman just fits.
Fire Ice and wind. A perfect Swordsman Trio
Momonsuke
His devil fruit seems beast if it could be fixed and the only people that could fix it seem like Chopper or Vegapunk so I hope he stays with the straw hats and gets his zoan fixed.

Plus if he became the apprentice of the strawhats and Mimiced each of thier fighting styles and mixed it (Choppers transforms Zoros's swords Sanjis Kicks luffys Gorrila warfare fight style and with his zoan he could create storms and get a sling shot plus Franky tenka and robins clutches. And Quick kill to boot)
Would be very beast when he grew up.

 

[ultraChalk]

REALLY want Voila or Kinemon.

Want Momo.

Don't want anybody else.

 

[jiraiya lives]

Aokiji, Kyros, Bellamy (if he gets the SH's level of progression then he'll be a badass in no time U_U), crocodile (they need a senior member since everyone in the crew is under 30)

 

[ChrisWolf]

SABO SABO SABO SABO SABO

no bartolomeo and I really wish they'd get rid of kinemon they already have two swordsmen and kinemon is a really annoying character

 

[ChrisWolf]

DO:
1.Sabo
2.Aokiji
3.bring back vivi! with a possible upgrade since the time skip

DON'T:
1.crocodile, he needs a reappearance and an upgrade since the time skip but he is better as a villain/side villain with his own path
2.jimbie, he's better off doing his own thing he's not the type to serve under luffy
3.kinemon, they've already got two swordsmen and he's really annoying and totally uninteresting as a character he needs to disappear
4.Bartolomeow, very very annoying and just doesn't have cool powers or anything
5.Bellamy, too weak and we don't need anymore fodder on the going merry plus I just don't like his character much either

 

[Tomato God]

DO:
1.Sabo
2.Aokiji
3.bring back vivi! with a possible upgrade since the time skip

DON'T:
1.crocodile, he needs a reappearance and an upgrade since the time skip but he is better as a villain/side villain with his own path
2.jimbie, he's better off doing his own thing he's not the type to serve under luffy
3.kinemon, they've already got two swordsmen and he's really annoying and totally uninteresting as a character he needs to disappear
4.Bartolomeow, very very annoying and just doesn't have cool powers or anything
5.Bellamy, too weak and we don't need anymore fodder on the going merry plus I just don't like his character much either

....
The going merry.

Awww you is gonna cry...
I hope you get to that chapter and just break.

 

[ChrisWolf]

....
The going merry.

Awww you is gonna cry...
I hope you get to that chapter and just break.

I am caught up in the anime but not the manga, something happens to the going merry? I don't care about spoilers telling me some of the things that are going to happen makes me look forward to it more

 

[Tomato God]

I am caught up in the anime but not the manga, something happens to the going merry? I don't care about spoilers telling me some of the things that are going to happen makes me look forward to it more

You couldnt handle it kid.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Azu]

NO to
1. Croco- Boy, I want him on bad side
2. Rebecca- Just let her live with her dad
3. Jinbei- I somehow know that he will eventually end up in their crew and he is strong, kind-hearted man, or, man-fish but I don't really like him from some reason

YES to

1. Bartolomeo- Simply cool and sweet and nice and everything positive, tho I don't think that will happen
2. Viola- He ability would be awesome for the crew and ye female member in the crew- yay to that
3. Kinemon- Just because he's so awesome, but that ain't happen

 

[ChrisWolf]

You couldnt handle it kid.

You must be registered for see images

thank you for sparing me then I guess I will remain in this blissful ignorance for as long as I can

 

[MickNerks]

Forgot momo and Kinemon.


They get thrown on my DO list
Kinemon

Beast swordsman. Zoro Can Create tornados and his pound cannons of air and Brook can create ice so having a fire swordsman just fits.
Fire Ice and wind. A perfect Swordsman Trio
Momonsuke
His devil fruit seems beast if it could be fixed and the only people that could fix it seem like Chopper or Vegapunk so I hope he stays with the straw hats and gets his zoan fixed.

Plus if he became the apprentice of the strawhats and Mimiced each of thier fighting styles and mixed it (Choppers transforms Zoros's swords Sanjis Kicks luffys Gorrila warfare fight style and with his zoan he could create storms and get a sling shot plus Franky tenka and robins clutches. And Quick kill to boot)
Would be very beast when he grew up.

I understand that Momonsuke, could join sometime in the future after he has trained but currently he seems like he would be a burden to the StrawHats. He is not strong enought to survive in the new world, so I think he should go and train first and then come back to join them in 4 or 5 years. Especially since we still have 10 to 12 years left of the manga.

 

[Anduril]

Who I'd like to join,

Bartolomeo- This guy would seriously push the strawhats powerlevel and would be incredibly awesome to see how he behaves on the ship with all the people he admires around him.

Koala: I would love it if she joins the strawhat instead of Jinbei, that would be just amazing.

Who I don't want to join:
Anyone who is currently stronger than zoro or sanji. And also a no to bellamy.

 

[Zeta42]

Kyros (but he most likely won't join), Kin'emon. Don't want anyone else.

 

[Beyonce]

DO:
1.Sabo
2.Aokiji
3.bring back vivi! with a possible upgrade since the time skip

DON'T:
1.crocodile, he needs a reappearance and an upgrade since the time skip but he is better as a villain/side villain with his own path
2.jimbie, he's better off doing his own thing he's not the type to serve under luffy
3.kinemon, they've already got two swordsmen and he's really annoying and totally uninteresting as a character he needs to disappear
4.Bartolomeow, very very annoying and just doesn't have cool powers or anything
5.Bellamy, too weak and we don't need anymore fodder on the going merry plus I just don't like his character much either

How do you know Sabo, but not know the Going Merry was destroyed? Lol

OT:
Vivi, Viola, or Jimbei

The rest are annoying

 

[Tomato God]

I understand that Momonsuke, could join sometime in the future after he has trained but currently he seems like he would be a burden to the StrawHats. He is not strong enought to survive in the new world, so I think he should go and train first and then come back to join them in 4 or 5 years. Especially since we still have 10 to 12 years left of the manga.

No his fruit if fixed could be haxxxed as hell He is an eastern japanese dragon based off of the looks. A dragon that controls storms on the sea.
A DF that controls water based storms.
Plus its immortal.
So yea....