You again lol
1. Tobi beats him now and he never said that about nagato. You always said tobi said that but never show the manga proof. Tobi has rinnegan+sharingan powers he can avoid any jutsu nagato throws at him with s/t jutsu and he can attack back with rinnegan powers. His rinnegan powers are superior to nagato he can use the gedo mazo better as well as use the outer path much better than nagato so no nagato is not better tobi just plain outclasses him.
2. That was naruto with no clones or summons u really think it was 100% naruto. hell no BM naruto can with stand shinra tensei, bansho tenin, destroy CT and nagato's summons would be owned by ma and pa and his toad army. Not too mention naruto has a bunch of clones to help him plus kuruma doesnt take his chakra away. And naruto just has to use frog katas to kill him with a bunch of clones that he has all of whom are faster than nagato. Again nagato would very likely lose the fight to naruto
3. Madara wins he has rinnegan+ems+mokuton and who told u that he does not have stamina dude, he has senju hashi's dna for a reason not to mention he got the rinnegan naturally not transplanted meaning chakra use is more efficient similar to kakashi with MS. And dont argue with kishi he is the TRUMP CARD for a reason not nagato, tobi was scared of him not the others and like i said he is the trump card for a reason lol. U clearly just forget clear manga facts dont u.
If you ask me Tobi without rinnegan would be a bad matchup for Nagato.