[Discussion] Whitebeards crew vs Rogers Crew

[jr tyrael24]

I do not understand the age difference of whitebeads and rogers crew. Roger was the same age as whitebeard i think, but it seems to me that the avg age of whitebeards crew, and more specifically his commanders, is alot younger than that of rogers crew. Rayleigh is an old man, crocus is an old man, i do not know what other roger pirates look like, but did whitebeard replace his old crew or just not form one untill he found marco who is now 40 years old at most!. and 25 at youngest

 

[Narutohokage7]

WB seems to adopt crews and crewmates, it is possible not all are titans as he is so they might retire/take less demanding roles in the crew.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

MFW crew< Roger pirates
They would be equal in terms of strength in the past ; but in terms of achievements the Roger pirates stomp. So the Roger pirates>WBP

 

[Fireplay]

Whitebeard commands divisions. I think he has older people in his crew but they probably just haven't been worth mentioning. The fact that he recruited Ace proves that he still recruits young pirates.

 

[jr tyrael24]

true. i just wish a random x whitebeard pirate would show up and he would b like rayleigh, old and powerful unlike how underwhelming whitebeards entire crew was.

 

[MythicDonut]

I think that Whitebeard had a bigger crew then Roger but Roger had a stronger crew, well at least from what we've seen and what I can say. Haven't seen much of Rogers crew but he Buggy and Shanks were on there when they were just kids/teens, maybe Roger did have younger commanders (If he did have that kind of setup) in his crew. Following hype and Roger being King of the Pirates I'd think that he has the stronger crew.

 

[YellowFang]

Rayleigh is alone a massive problem for WB crew...

Roger's crew consisted of few dozen men and yet they were toe-to-toe with Shiki's pirate army consisting of few dozen galleons...

That's enough evidence of their supremacy...

 

[Hijey]

MFW crew< Roger pirates
They would be equal in terms of strength in the past ; but in terms of achievements the Roger pirates stomp. So the Roger pirates>WBP

Marineford WB pirates? Yeah, they would be good deal weaker compared to Roger pirates that are in their prime.

Roger pirates were a overall a bit stronger than Whitebeard pirates. This is excluding the captains since those two were equals.

 

[Netferarri]

I think Roger's crew > WB crew just because Roger is so legendary XD