[Discussion] Whitebeard vs Golden Lion Shiki

[aashish1996]

We all know that whitebeard was the strongest in the world but his old age said otherwise. Whitebeard controls the ground and the sea while Shiki controls the sky.

Spoiler

If you read one piece manga chapter 0 than you also know that, at the time, shiki couldn't beat whitebeard as he was 20 years younger.

You must be registered for see images

So, who do you think would win if whitebeard ang golden lion shiki fought after those 20 years? Do you still think Whitebeard would win? or Do you think that Shiki would win?

Anyway, that would be an epic battle to see.

 

[aniwth0z]

whitbeard No matter how far shiki can fly whitebeards power will reach him

 

[sexyprep1]

honestly yes i think shiki was strong but just for some reason i put Gold roger and White beard in a whole nother lvl of stregth so no shiki would lose shiki wouldnt have a avantaage in the air and couldnt keep up long with wb on the ground this is just my opinion though

 

[Love Cook]

Well it depends where they fight. If they are on open water and Shiki touches WB's ship and drops it from great height in the ocean. Whitebeard is pretty much screwed.

In all other situations: Whitebeard

 

[Mercy]

Well it depends where they fight. If they are on open water and Shiki touches WB's ship and drops it from great height in the ocean. Whitebeard is pretty much screwed.

In all other situations: Whitebeard

Exactly, I totally agree with this.

 

[Davor97]

A tough situation.
But i think whitebeard. But whitebeard cannot use his fullest attack because he will get hurt too
The problem is we dont really know much about shiki.
And whitebeard woudnt loose to sengoku and garp. NO WAY

 

[Hyperion]

A tough situation.
But i think whitebeard. But whitebeard cannot use his fullest attack because he will get hurt too
The problem is we dont really know much about shiki.
And whitebeard woudnt loose to sengoku and garp. NO WAY

Your Sig is too big.
Re-size it before it gets modified by a staff member and possible infraction.

OT: I'd say Whitebeard.

 

[s0ulja]

whitebeard...he snapped aokiji while he was in the sky
n if shiki drops he wont be able to freeze the water to save himself

 

[Love Cook]

whitebeard...he snapped aokiji while he was in the sky
n if shiki drops he wont be able to freeze the water to save himself

Why would he drop ?

He can fly >.>

 

[Lord Snow]

Whitebeard is on a whole other level, you saw what the old man did at marineford.

 

[~Yubel~]

Shiki took on both Sengoku and Garp in an all out battle, it took both of them to beat him.
Garp was said to have cornered Roger many times, Sengoku is on Garps lvl if not higher since he threatened he would show no mercy if he betrayed them at marineford.
Whitebeard is the only man known to have fought on equal terms with Roger but he was still stronger.
Out of these five men, they are all incredibly strong and the difference in their strength is very blurry but if i had to rank them, i´d put roger at top as nr 1, garp at the bottom as nr 5 and sengoku at number 4.

Whitebeard has his tremor tremor power but shiki can just fly and avoid it while using his lion heads to corner whitebeard but he can use his quake powers to destroy them and shiki can´t restrain a quake-man either.

It would be a really close fight but whitebeard would probably come out the winner and please people when you think of golden lion shiki, don´t think of that damn movie where he gets beaten by freaking Luffy!!!

THAT WAS A MOVIE!!! WHETHER OR NOT ODA PRESENTED IT, LUFFY HAD TO WIN SOMEHOW AND SHIKI COULD´VE EASILY AVOIDED THAT KICK IF HE WANTED TO!
IT WAS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE FOR LUFFY TO STAY IN AIR FOR THAT LONG SINCE HE CAN´T FLY!!

 

[aashish1996]

Shiki took on both Sengoku and Garp in an all out battle, it took both of them to beat him.
Garp was said to have cornered Roger many times, Sengoku is on Garps lvl if not higher since he threatened he would show no mercy if he betrayed them at marineford.
Whitebeard is the only man known to have fought on equal terms with Roger but he was still stronger.
Out of these five men, they are all incredibly strong and the difference in their strength is very blurry but if i had to rank them, i´d put roger at top as nr 1, garp at the bottom as nr 5 and sengoku at number 4.

Whitebeard has his tremor tremor power but shiki can just fly and avoid it while using his lion heads to corner whitebeard but he can use his quake powers to destroy them and shiki can´t restrain a quake-man either.

It would be a really close fight but whitebeard would probably come out the winner and please people when you think of golden lion shiki, don´t think of that damn movie where he gets beaten by freaking Luffy!!!

THAT WAS A MOVIE!!! WHETHER OR NOT ODA PRESENTED IT, LUFFY HAD TO WIN SOMEHOW AND SHIKI COULD´VE EASILY AVOIDED THAT KICK IF HE WANTED TO!
IT WAS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE FOR LUFFY TO STAY IN AIR FOR THAT LONG SINCE HE CAN´T FLY!!

Good point. I agree with with you because before in the movie, shiki owned the straw hat pirates even though luffy wasn't at his best.

 

[s0ulja]

Why would he drop ?

He can fly >.>

yeah and?

 

[Love Cook]

yeah and?

... and he won't fall into the sea

 

[s0ulja]

... and he won't fall into the sea

once he feels one of WB's attacks i dont think he'l have too much choice

 

[Love Cook]

once he feels one of WB's attacks i dont think he'l have too much choice

Shiki isn't just some low life pirate, he is on roger's and Whitebeard's level.

 

[FlashySmosRinnegan]

Whitebeard, in his old age with some difficulties for sure but still the winner. He is able to use his power very effectively in any way,we have seen it. Though I´d love to seem them in their best. Pre-timeskip Luffy wouldn´t defeat Shiki that easily as seen in the movie but I´m not complaining,it was good.

 

[s0ulja]

Shiki isn't just some low life pirate, he is on roger's and Whitebeard's level.

his strong but not on roger or WB's level
and aokiji isnt a life life navy..his admiral level yet he dropped with one measly attack, the only thing that saved him was that he froze the water.
not to mention shiki got taken out by luffy

 

[Love Cook]

his strong but not on roger or WB's level
and aokiji isnt a life life navy..his admiral level yet he dropped with one measly attack, the only thing that saved him was that he froze the water.
not to mention shiki got taken out by luffy

You're hopeless man..

you already said this on which I replied Shiki can fly. AOKIJI CAN'T FLY !!!! That is why he fell down >.< after the attack.

If you don't think Shiki is on that level go read chapter 0: Strong World.

 

[Jupiter]

Well it depends where they fight. If they are on open water and Shiki touches WB's ship and drops it from great height in the ocean. Whitebeard is pretty much screwed.

In all other situations: Whitebeard

Well said