you say it can, I say it can't, but given that it's never happened and we have no reason to believe it can, common practice dictates that we assume it can't. also we assume it acts like fire until proven otherwise
I have to agree with the last part. Fanbase=/=Character and it never. Btw, love that Hei sig.
Again, Amaterasu is not normal fire.
In manga it was said that it is as hot as the sun, so it can pretty much be of a composition like the sun.
Logic doesn't apply to this manga, if Amaterasu was as hot as the sun, everything it touched or even came close to would immidietly melt and parrish right away, but the samurai didn't neither did the raikage's arm or sausage, eh just got som burn marks.
If you go by logic does not apply, then I can also use it to say that it can burn on the moon. After all logic does not apply, as you said.
You gave me LOGICAL reasons for Amaterasu to not be able to burn on the moon.
I never said it can. I asked him why would it not burn since he said it can't.
Just because it was not shown it does not mean that there are no chances. It is like Madara using Susanoo without eyes. If asked, not too much of us would probably think that it was possible.
Assumptions are just assumption, just because "X" was not proven, does not mean that "Y" is automatically proven.
This guy has basicly answered it.
Lord Sasuke can burn the moon with Amaterasu, he can also cut the planet in half''

When they started to call him "Lord". Obviously he should be called a "God". The reason I've started to hate him, is because everyone undermines his true title.