I've pondered this subject for a while. People here seem to believe that just because a character is powerful that that makes them a good character. Often when a character gets a power up, or does well in a fight, that character automatically gets a fan base, leading me to believe that people only care about power (I.E. Kakashi, Sakura, Guy ect.). Ok, no more rambling, time to get to the point. Imagine your favorite characters, do you like them because of their relatable/likable personality or because they can handle themselves in a fight? I personally only require personality, I couldn't care less if they're fodder or not if I find them interesting (I.E. one of my favorites, Shikamaru).