[Discussion] What are your thoughts?

Good or Evil

  • Good

    Votes: 3 25.0%
  • Evil

    Votes: 9 75.0%

  • Total voters
    12

Uchiha Legacy

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,667
Reaction score
201
Do people really think Sasuke is a true villian? Is it me or has it been obvious from that start and till now that he is still a good guy? I get it Sasuke said he only spared Naruto on a whim, but come on we all know they get a hard-on for each other;).

Sasuke attacked and attempted to capture Bee? Why is it only a crime when Sasukes does it, Itachi captured at least one or two, yet he is still considered a good guy.

Sasuke attacked the Kages? No, Sasuke wanted Danzo(who should be considered a criminal). Not the other Kages or any Samuria. Why would they even protect Danzo who used a Jutsu on another Kage and also ran away, idk. I can understand why A came after Sasuke.

Sasuke tried to kill Karin? Sasuke is a Ninja, he did what he had to do to accomplish a goal. Sasuke did stab her, but not in a vital area, which freed her from Danzo, who would have attempted to murder her if Sasuke came for him, which we know Sasuke would not let Danzo get away no matter what. Danzo was mostly responsible for everything that happened to Sasuke, Itachi and the Uchiha Clan.

Sasuke tried to kill Sakura? To be fair she came with the intent to kill him first, and this is why Sasuke was testing her to kill Karin. Sasuke knew she would never find him all by herself, even though she did get away from the group how would Sasuke know that? So Sasuke went to chidori Sakura knowing it would draw any allies out from hiding.

Sasuke tried to kill Sakura twice? C'mon when has a kunai knife ever killed anyone, even if Sasuke some how knew it was posioned Sakura would obviously already had the antidote on her(which she did). Besides doesn't Sasuke know she is a medical-nin? Sasuke was just giving Sakura tough love<3xd.

Sasuke put Naruto before his life goal in the fight against Haku and was willing to die for his friend.

Sasuke wanted Naruto to take Sakura and run from Gaara, therefore sacrificing his own life for their's.

Sasuke refused to kill Naruto at VOTE even though it would have gave him the power he needed, take into consideration he also had the CM corrupting him, no matter what he says or how he acts he didn't kill Naruto because he loves him<3.

Sasuke spared all of Orochimaru's subjects, not killing a single one. Sasuke also made sure that his team did not kill anyone on their missions. Why would he do that? Simple, because he is not a murderer.

Sasuke also used his MS for the first time to save his team.

Sasuke has already reached his boiling point as you can see he is cooling back down after talking to Itachi.

Sasuke has confirmed to Tobi that he does indeed "front" or use's a fake personality.

What are your guys opinion, is Sasuke a good boy or bad boy?

Also what do you think will happen to all the Sasuke fanboys who only like Sasuke being evil, and all the Naruto fanboys who hate Sasuke leaving his friends, when he finally comes back?
 

-Carnage-

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 4, 2012
Messages
8,222
Reaction score
661
hes extremely bad at being a good boy....he has good motives...but terrible ways of fulfilling his goal
 

Waltz

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 6, 2011
Messages
9,979
Reaction score
1,256
If your asking this...then i guess you missed 90% of the manga.
 

Gooner4life

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Feb 21, 2012
Messages
2,491
Reaction score
229
He is a bad guy, Kishi has left the door open for his redemption, that is why you feel like that.
 

SQY

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 10, 2012
Messages
2,932
Reaction score
554
I agree. Sasuke in some matters is completely misunderstood U_U
 

Lucidus

Legendary
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
11,733
Reaction score
1,290
sasuke is neither gd nor bad but simply a person with his own ideals and his own path ..... he is misguided
 

Ldude

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 8, 2012
Messages
6,648
Reaction score
794
I thought he was cool both as a Konoha shinobi and as a psychotic bastard.... meh.
 

RockLee X Zabuza

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
531
Reaction score
39
I like this...it all makes sense I love Sasuke and I was mad cuz he betrayed the leaf but after reading this
im 100% sure he is good plus I hated him as a villan I like cool calm Sasuke +rep
 

~Dream~

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 13, 2012
Messages
3,324
Reaction score
398
Sasuke is living as life of regret, just like Obito. Sasuke truly isn't evil, he's just in darkness. He's been brainwashed and all he thinks is Uchiha and his brother, he lives in darkness but that really isn't what he wants.
 

HiddenSound

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
20,009
Reaction score
2,125
Danzo is more of a good guy than Sasuke... imo.

Itachi is considered a good guy because he never truly wanted to capture the Jinchurikki and he didn't. It was for his cover as an Akatsuki. So yeah, Sasuke following Tobi's orders and trying to capture Killer Bee is a crime.

If Sasuke would've thought about the situation at the 5 Kage Summit he would've waited for it to be over, then attack Danzo when it was just him and his bodyguards. Instead he rushed in, murdering numerous Samurai, attempted to murder A and Gaara, and then murdered Danzo, the Sixth Hokage (candidate).

"Sasuke is a ninja. He did what he had to do to accomplish a goal" Well then Danzo should be pardoned for using KA against Mifune because he did that to accomplish a goal. It's a poor excuse.

Danzo was responsible for saving millions of lives through the Uchiha Clan Massacre. It's Itachi's fault that Sasuke is where he is now. He let him live.

The reasons from Haku to the end were from when Sasuke wasn't "evil", but was darkening. Now he's evil.
 

Uchiha Legacy

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,667
Reaction score
201
Danzo is more of a good guy than Sasuke... imo.

Itachi is considered a good guy because he never truly wanted to capture the Jinchurikki and he didn't. It was for his cover as an Akatsuki. So yeah, Sasuke following Tobi's orders and trying to capture Killer Bee is a crime.

If Sasuke would've thought about the situation at the 5 Kage Summit he would've waited for it to be over, then attack Danzo when it was just him and his bodyguards. Instead he rushed in, murdering numerous Samurai, attempted to murder A and Gaara, and then murdered Danzo, the Sixth Hokage (candidate).

"Sasuke is a ninja. He did what he had to do to accomplish a goal" Well then Danzo should be pardoned for using KA against Mifune because he did that to accomplish a goal. It's a poor excuse.

Danzo was responsible for saving millions of lives through the Uchiha Clan Massacre. It's Itachi's fault that Sasuke is where he is now. He let him live.

The reasons from Haku to the end were from when Sasuke wasn't "evil", but was darkening. Now he's evil.

I don't consider Danzo evil neither, he was just a fool as is Sasuke. I'm sure the Haku fight had significance also as Sasuke's character and role should have been already been developed since the start. Who knows what Sasuke was going to do at the Kage summit if Zetsu had not interfered. Maybe he was going to spy on Danzo and tail him as they left? With the Itachi thing I was just showing that some good guys do bad things.


I like this...it all makes sense I love Sasuke and I was mad cuz he betrayed the leaf but after reading this
im 100% sure he is good plus I hated him as a villan I like cool calm Sasuke +rep

Thanks.
 
Last edited:

Sunstorm

Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
112
Reaction score
8
Well...you are right about many things....Though I absolutely refuse to believe sasuke is going to become good guy out of nowhere, something must occur to break through his hatred wall.

It's all true, Kishi hinted us that he isn't that much of a cold-hearted guy with all those facts the OP listed. But he cannot just come back can he? He still has to settle things with Naruto.

I imagine, that after Naruto defeats Tobi...and Madara ( somehow o_O )

Sasuke could show up, he would attack Sakura when she decides to interrupt their battle. Later on, Sasuke might push Naruto to the ground, and as you all know, those are the moments when Naruto makes a comeback. He can somehow make Sasuke realise that he just killed his lover he would hesitate not knowing what to do. I don't know how exactly Naruto can persuade Sasuke, but if he does, then I would imagine Sakura surviving just like Sasuke did when he fought Haku ( something similiar to how Haku had "mercy" ). And then Naruto can talk the crap out of the Raikage to let Sasuke go, just like the time he wanted to join the battle.

This is just my fantasy though. I could as well imagine Sasuke "killing" Sakura then Tobi would let him fight Naruto, Sasuke can get a change of heart in the last moment and decide to sacrifice himself and stop Tobi/Madara but still dying. Something like this I guess ?

Anyway, Idk if you don't like my view of Naruto Manga's end but I would really love...a sad ending...I really want one...
 

Uchiha Legacy

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,667
Reaction score
201
Well...you are right about many things....Though I absolutely refuse to believe sasuke is going to become good guy out of nowhere, something must occur to break through his hatred wall.

It's all true, Kishi hinted us that he isn't that much of a cold-hearted guy with all those facts the OP listed. But he cannot just come back can he? He still has to settle things with Naruto.

I imagine, that after Naruto defeats Tobi...and Madara ( somehow o_O )

Sasuke could show up, he would attack Sakura when she decides to interrupt their battle. Later on, Sasuke might push Naruto to the ground, and as you all know, those are the moments when Naruto makes a comeback. He can somehow make Sasuke realise that he just killed his lover he would hesitate not knowing what to do. I don't know how exactly Naruto can persuade Sasuke, but if he does, then I would imagine Sakura surviving just like Sasuke did when he fought Haku ( something similiar to how Haku had "mercy" ). And then Naruto can talk the crap out of the Raikage to let Sasuke go, just like the time he wanted to join the battle.

This is just my fantasy though. I could as well imagine Sasuke "killing" Sakura then Tobi would let him fight Naruto, Sasuke can get a change of heart in the last moment and decide to sacrifice himself and stop Tobi/Madara but still dying. Something like this I guess ?

Anyway, Idk if you don't like my view of Naruto Manga's end but I would really love...a sad ending...I really want one...

I agree, but Naruto said if Sasuke dies, he will also die.
 

Sunstorm

Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
112
Reaction score
8
Naruto does say lots of things doesnt he....Naruto dying won't be a proper ending, believe it not, even if we want a sad moment, we will then live a life of regret knowing that our favourite character died, forever.
 

asdeiro

Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
185
Reaction score
3
he is not good but i think kishi will turn him good again
 

MissShakra

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 7, 2011
Messages
896
Reaction score
73
i honestly dont think sasuke is that bad either. kishi has left room for his redemption, but hes hasnt taken the opportunity yet because before now, he hadnt talked to itachi and before now hes been hellbent on revenge. of course his decisions arent good and they are quite dramatic...even given his awful situation...but he isnt completely evil. every individual, it doesnt matter what anyone says, has a different idea of right vs wrong, good vs evil etc and sasuke's is a little ****ed right now given his situation. now that he has talked to itachi and seeing how he has reacted just in the last 50 chapters or so, you can see sasuke coming around but ultimately, somehow, naruto will be the one to bring him back regardless of what he does between now and the end of the manga. this is only what i think though, i can see both sides (why both parties would think sasuke is still ok/evil)

the theme of naruto is the whole "never give up" thing....having sasuke just turn out "good" or just die off or live still as a rogue ninja wouldn't really make an appropriate ending given the context of the morals....i personally think sasuke will either die protecting naruto or orochimaru is going to find a way to take over sasuke's body and thats how the naruto vs sasuke fight will happen (im suggesting this alternative in case sasuke really is good all along, this would still require naruto to still at least save sasuke then make room for his talk no jutsu to get sasuke to admit hes still a good guy lol )
 
Top