[Game] Valentine's day better late than never Game #22

[Thestatusquo]

AH i misclicked

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Luk or Elmage for today? Which one?

Are you letting him decide who you should vote? vote who you think, and state your reasons please, so that we'll know what to do next DP

 

[Elmage G Ace]

I mean, you seem to be posting a lot rig

Go look for my second and third post like I said, except you're not putting any effort to confirm I'm scum/town, in which case you become sus to me

 

[Ansatsuken]

Tbh Elmage when you took so long to say something it really makes me questioned your actual position inside this game. Its understandable in the 1DP why you don't talk much but we're in the 2DP and you started to say something in this last 2 hours. If you can't play you can ask for sub but I think you hold a big role.

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Tbh Elmage when you took so long to say something it really makes me questioned your actual position inside this game. Its understandable in the 1DP why you don't talk much but we're in the 2DP and you started to say something in this last 2 hours. If you can't play you can ask for sub but I think you hold a big role.

I'm a busy person irl, I work 10-12 hrs per day, I thought I mentioned this... Anyways, I can only be active at day time when I have breaks, or at night, after I'm done working

 

[Michelle]

Sorry I'm late Eod lynch asap

 

[Michelle]

Vote count:
2.5 Elmage - Ansa, TSQ
1 Luke - Elmage
1 TSQ - Luke
1 Ansa - Red

@Elmage G Ace was lynched. They were vanilla townie

 

[Michelle]

Flavour post.


Night 2 will last 24 hours, until 1st of March at 11 PM GMT +2

 

[Michelle]

I am late again.

Love is just not lucky.

TSQ has died, they were town tree stump

 

[Michelle]

Mafia reached parity with town, mafia won

Congrats

4. Raunix
7. TheLukundo

Thanks for playing @everyone

 

[Thestatusquo]

I should’ve ended Luk instead but elmage’s shift was scummy as all hell, my bad yo

I also heavily underestimated Raunix here and that turned out to be a bite in the ass

I also didn’t realise we were at LyLo which is why I treated it half-assedly and I’m sorry about that, it was an actual derp of mine

I had a lot more points to you scum Elmage, it wasn’t just that. I don’t think I would’ve caught Raunix, in all honesty.

I had some angle shooty reasons to scum read you as well which I shouldn’t have taken into account but you were PoE anyway and I thought there would be no harm if we lynched in PoE given i thought we had one more phase before LyLo.

The angle shooting was that when Alice got timed out instead of you, I thought you were active in mafia chat and that’s why you weren’t replaced. Your immediate 180 on Luk also didn’t help, because I was considering me being wrong on someone and when you 180’d on Luk it looked like a desperate attempt at surviving when you were still technically trying to sort him out, y’know. Which made me not want to vote Luk in case he was the town I was wrongly scum reading and your vote was more indicative of you scum and it just made him look better although it shouldn’t have.

I will totally take this loss as maybe my worst performance this year and will bear the responsibility lol

 

[Thestatusquo]

This goes to show you shouldn’t multi table while also being stressed by exams / mock trials period, I will probably take another break so I can enjoy this game without having to worry about irl stuff and hopefully it will stop feeling like a chore

 

[Just_Red]

Well played everyone.

Spoiler: Why I think Town Lost

Mafia didn't need to be too active. They had a town core who was mainly just Ansa, TSQ, and me. The rest of the players where very quiet. So the town core had only a few reactions to go on. Resulting in cases often very narrow minded due to how little the pool to pick from was. In other words inactivity was the ideal strategy this game for mafia. The maf team played it well.

Ansa was right and I was wrong, so I apologize, only to him though, due to the fact that I am only apologizing for my suspicion of him and not because I lynched him(cause that didn't happen).

Lastly, Thank you @Michelle for hosting a good game. What was you mentality when
1) I Picked Boi and TSQ as lovers
2) making the flavor for this game?
3) the result of the game
4) my play

​

 

[Ansatsuken]

When TSQ subbed in at first I think its a hope but turned out its actually a tragedy. Well I'm not actually want to put a blame on TSQ here but that substitution shouldn't be allowed to happen tbh. Yes the blame should be on me. I have done a big mistake that leads to town failure. I should have trust myself, my own ability, my thinking first before anyone else. But that doesn't mean I should be close minded, selfish and uncooperative. I always open to accept different idea. Actually I really don't like how TSQ started his second term in this game. Asking me one stupid question and then put me in his scum list. But somehow I still trust/believe him and follow him. I mean he's not scum but I believe he must be right. Maybe because I respect to highly player like him. Don't get me wrong, TSQ is very good and capable player. And yes Raunix is scum TSQ and its easy to know why. I'm very sorry Elmage for lynching you. I should trust myself more. I'm sorry town. It's all my fault.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Well played everyone.

Spoiler: Why I think Town Lost

Mafia didn't need to be too active. They had a town core who was mainly just Ansa, TSQ, and me. The rest of the players where very quiet. So the town core had only a few reactions to go on. Resulting in cases often very narrow minded due to how little the pool to pick from was. In other words inactivity was the ideal strategy this game for mafia. The maf team played it well.

Ansa was right and I was wrong, so I apologize, only to him though, due to the fact that I am only apologizing for my suspicion of him and not because I lynched him(cause that didn't happen).

Lastly, Thank you @Michelle for hosting a good game. What was you mentality when
1) I Picked Boi and TSQ as lovers
2) making the flavor for this game?
3) the result of the game
4) my play

​

You forgot to mention voting system of this game. It contribute a part in town lost

 

[Ansatsuken]

@Michelle can you comment on player's performance in this game.

 

[Michelle]

I wanted to bring something new on forum by the voting system. It was also easier for me, instead making an one hour search for votes i dig up the PMs and finish it in 10 mins. Maybe a separate thread with votes would work too.
If someone have to talk about players and playstyle, I am not quite the best to criticise but I have to mention I am sad at inactivity and low voting from town. I mean my queen Alice didn't even vote in day 1. This is a bad thing
Overall the game showed preconceptions from townies, like inactivity being certainly AI, regarding Elmage who was lynched too easy.
Thinking at Raunix who as mafia didn't vote you can see how they didn't really acted like a pack. Luck was there for them again.
My lovers were pretty well self defendable if Boi as doctor would use his night ability to protect TSQ which he didn't, more to say here he protected no one
To asnwer at Red, she was Cupidon and made blindly the choice of the pair of lovers, coincidentally picking up 2 townies, a more experienced player with a new one. That would become a deadly weapon for mafia if they would use their chat more and rely on each other more than just using the simple hunch they are both villagers.
If they were a mixed couple, their wincon would change, they would win as the last players standing.

For any other questions, AMA.

 

[Michelle]

What was you mentality when
1) I Picked Boi and TSQ as lovers
2) making the flavor for this game?
3) the result of the game
4) my play

1. it was an unexpected good choice considering the fact that Boi as new player could learn from TSQ some things and that one of them as doctor could protect the other one.
2. i didn't make it. It is a setup I played last year. We should have 13 players, one more town PR and 3 wolves.
3. the result was expected when I saw Raunix posting so genuine. I know you could and should lynch Luke but i doubt you would lynch Raunix over the tinfoiled inactive townies.
4. much improved, keep it up.

 

[Raunix]

Yeah, I actually forgot who mafia killed, ansa was right to not believe my excuse haha

 

[Raunix]

Thank for the game Michelle \o/
Ansa, you did really well finding us in such a short amount of time