[Discussion] Up to the thriller bark arc, how would you rank straw hat crew?

[ShiroT]

i've been wondering how the crew is in terms of ranking. How would you rank them? Is sanji (as of this arc) > zoro? Is brooks a better swordsmen then zoro? Is brooks stronger then sanji? How does chooper play into this?

and couldnt robin restrict everyone in that crew in a 1v1? Can someone overpower her?

forgot about the franky Lol

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

imo it goes like this:

1."Straw Hat" Monkey D. Luffy
2."Pirate Hunter" Roronoa Zoro
3. "Black Leg" Sanji
4. "Cyborg" Franky
5."Devil's Child" Nico Robin
6. "Humming" Brook
7. "Cotton Candy Lover" Tony Tony Chopper
8. Sogeking(Ussop)
9. "Cat Burglar" Nami

 

[ShiroT]

imo it goes like this:

1."Straw Hat" Monkey D. Luffy
2."Pirate Hunter" Roronoa Zoro
3. "Black Leg" Sanji
4. "Cyborg" Franky
5."Devil's Child" Nico Robin
6. "Humming" Brook
7. "Cotton Candy Lover" Tony Tony Chopper
8. Sogeking(Ussop)
9. "Cat Burglar" Nami

so your doing it mostly based on their bounty?

And couldnt robin take down zoro or sanji? No one has stopped her powers yet

 

[Mugiwara kun]

Luffy
Zoro
Sanji
Franky
Chopper
Brook
Robin
Usopp
Nami

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Luffy > Zoro > Sanji
The rest of the crew strength doesn't matter >__>

 

[ShiroT]

Luffy > Zoro > Sanji
The rest of the crew strength doesn't matter >__>

Luffy
Zoro
Sanji
Franky
Chopper
Brook
Robin
Usopp
Nami

none of you answered my question about robin

 

[Meee]

Luffy > Zoro > Sanji
The rest of the crew strength doesn't matter >__>

Yeah basically this, its too hard to rate the rest anyway.

Monster Chopper and Franky in his big ass suit probably come next, Robin has a pretty OP DF but it feels fodder like half the time, The rest are whatevs.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

so your doing it mostly based on their bounty?

And couldnt robin take down zoro or sanji? No one has stopped her powers yet

No that list is based off of strength not bounties. Luffy in G2 could just outspeed Robin and beat her. Zoro can just use 108 pound cannon on her. In an actual fight RObin would beat Snaji because he doesn't hit women, but in terms of strength he is still stronger since he would perform better to other opponents than Robin would(unless it was a woman). For Franky I think he can beat her high diff since if you tries to break his back he can just burn her arms on him.

 

[ShiroT]

No that list is based off of strength not bounties. Luffy in G2 could just outspeed Robin and beat her. Zoro can just use 108 pound cannon on her. In an actual fight RObin would beat Snaji because he doesn't hit women, but in terms of strength he is still stronger since he would perform better to other opponents than Robin would(unless it was a woman). For Franky I think he can beat her high diff since if you tries to break his back he can just burn her arms on him.

so . . .you can out speed her powers ... what about before luffy goes g2 or if she grabs zoro before he swings

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

so . . .you can out speed her powers ... what about before luffy goes g2 or if she grabs zoro before he swings

Zorro cuts off her arm or since Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji are physically stronger than her they can overpower her and prevent her from using clutch.

 

[ShiroT]

Zorro cuts off her arm or since Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji are physically stronger than her they can overpower her and prevent her from using clutch.

oh, so she can in fact be over powered?

 

[Dr Strangelove]

none of you answered my question about robin

Use your brain, Zoro can cut stuff so...no.
That's one example.

Yeah basically this, its too hard to rate the rest anyway.

Monster Chopper and Franky in his big ass suit probably come next, Robin has a pretty OP DF but it feels fodder like half the time, The rest are whatevs.

You must be registered for see images

 

[ShiroT]

Use your brain, Zoro can cut stuff so...no.
That's one example.

You must be registered for see images

if i used my brain, nobody but the zombies survived after getting grabbed by robin . .. nobody has over powered robins powers either . .

but macho said they can overpower her

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

if i used my brain, nobody but the zombies survived after getting grabbed by robin . .. nobody has over powered robins powers either . .

but macho said they can overpower her

Well for her to be able to bend them over enough to break their back she would have to be strong enough to overpower them otherwise they will resist, and Luffy is made of rubber so I don't think bending him will hurt him

 

[Dr Strangelove]

if i used my brain, nobody but the zombies survived after getting grabbed by robin . .. nobody has over powered robins powers either . .

but macho said they can overpower her

...what? if you used your brain?...

Yes...but the Straw Hat crew aren't fodder (arguably xD) Zoro can obviously cut her arms/other appendages in two.

 

[ShiroT]

...what? if you used your brain?...

Yes...but the Straw Hat crew aren't fodder (arguably xD) Zoro can obviously cut her arms/other appendages in two.

i know the answer now but its seems you didnt understand the , but its not important

 

[Dr Strangelove]

i know the answer now but its seems you didnt understand the , but its not important

...well I answered the question, just not your tiny paragraph at the end...so...

You must be registered for see images

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

Luffy

Zoro

Sanji

Robin

Franky

Brook

Chopper

Nami

Ussop


In terms of One v One, only the M3 can over power her physically.

...what? if you used your brain?...

Yes...but the Straw Hat crew aren't fodder (arguably xD) Zoro can obviously cut her arms/other appendages in two.

Cutting is useless here. She blooms limbs on Zoro. The minute he's trying to cut her, the minute he's cutting himself.


The only person who's over powered her clutch is Jieogou of the Wind who had his own body's strength PLUS Zoro's strength.





Regardless, for the sake of Shonen simplicity, its easily going to be that the M3 can over power her physically....just becsuse of how much attention Oda gives them, and how little Oda gives Robin.

But other than them or the people whom are on their level, Robin should clutch them unless they have some DF ability that renders a clutch useless or impossible.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Luffy > Zoro > Sanji > Robin > Franky > Brook > Usopp > Sanji > Nami

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Cutting is useless here. She blooms limbs on Zoro. The minute he's trying to cut her, the minute he's cutting himself.


The only person who's over powered her clutch is Jieogou of the Wind who had his own body's strength PLUS Zoro's strength.





Regardless, for the sake of Shonen simplicity, its easily going to be that the M3 can over power her physically....just becsuse of how much attention Oda gives them, and how little Oda gives Robin.

But other than them or the people whom are on their level, Robin should clutch them unless they have some DF ability that renders a clutch useless or impossible.

...even though we have seen Robin suffer physically when one of her sprouted limbs get damaged...