Twist..truth about Madara/brother

[Amantius]

[ Hi guys... About Manga 490... try putiing this in your head.

What if the story tobi told Sasuke,(at the time he had him after the battle with itach) what if it was not a lie but an simple twist...what i am trying to say is what if madara brother was not the one who died.. i am saying that when Madara said he was "feeling pain and crying" what if his brother did not give his eye up.. but took madara eyes when he was weak and could not deffend himself.. because they both had MS my proof is" we kill our best friend to gain a greater power" this made the other uchiha scared of them.. so what if madara brother saw him in pain and fear having to be in madara situation... what if his brother kill madara and took his eye ( cuting his hair and stuff to look like him so others wont know a thing" because like history says.. uchihas are curse clan with alot of hate and wants power and stuff.
so tell me what do you guys thing?:ghehe:

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

They're not that bad.You have a point,but it's almost impossible chance.

 

[Duncan Steel]

very likely possible yes but im sorry to say, there is no proof

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

Yeah I agree,there is no proof.But nice theory.

 

[jane347]

Sounds great.

 

[Christyan]

wow nice ideea i really like it ..... That means tobi is not madara , but his brother .... but then who fighted the first ?
Maybe madara fighted the first hokage , he died , and then his brother appeared and took his eyes , pretending from there on that he is madara . But this means Tobi lied to sasuke when saying he had EMS while fighting the first .... only kishi knows . But after all that happen in this manga , i expect at least 1 lie in tobi's story ...

 

[squiremarcus]

but why would it matter if it wasn't madara who got ems but rather his brother? The story would still be the same except his name would be different becuase all of the cool stuff we've seen madara do was after he got ems anyways? and then at that point how would he lie about being madara back before he even got a mask? it's not like they only identified people based on their hairstyles

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

Well it won't really matter but it would be quite cool.I don't really see a reason why Madara would lie and why Izuna might lie about being Madara.

 

[Honord Sage]

There is one thing You should all remember, Kabuto said He wanted the last young living Uchiha. Living Uchiha, Is this an indication? Of who may be a Uchiha? I know He said Young. But living Uchiha seems to me to say that Madara may not be an Uchiha. Maybe someone like Kakashi, someone who gain a Sharingan on only one eye, that may explain a one eye mask.

 

[a thousand years of death]

[ Hi guys... About Manga 490... try putiing this in your head.

What if the story tobi told Sasuke,(at the time he had him after the battle with itach) what if it was not a lie but an simple twist...what i am trying to say is what if madara brother was not the one who died.. i am saying that when Madara said he was "feeling pain and crying" what if his brother did not give his eye up.. but took madara eyes when he was weak and could not deffend himself.. because they both had MS my proof is" we kill our best friend to gain a greater power" this made the other uchiha scared of them.. so what if madara brother saw him in pain and fear having to be in madara situation... what if his brother kill madara and took his eye ( cuting his hair and stuff to look like him so others wont know a thing" because like history says.. uchihas are curse clan with alot of hate and wants power and stuff.
so tell me what do you guys thing?:ghehe:

it is posible. i will not rule that out.

There is one thing You should all remember, Kabuto said He wanted the last young living Uchiha. Living Uchiha, Is this an indication? Of who may be a Uchiha? I know He said Young. But living Uchiha seems to me to say that Madara may not be an Uchiha. Maybe someone like Kakashi, someone who gain a Sharingan on only one eye, that may explain a one eye mask.

hmm seems you called yourself honored sage for a reason.
that does also seem possible.

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

Could you all stop doubting Madara as an Uchiha.There's no way Madara would have gotten eternal magenkyou sharingan if he wasn't an Uchiha.And tell me why you guys think Madara is Obito.there's not much proof.Finally got that out of my system.