[Game] Town of Salem Game # 12 Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

AL_sama

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jan 17, 2019
Messages
1,100
Reaction score
678
congrats to the winners well played guys

@All_Red really well played I was rooting for you but sadly in the end you couldn't pull it off

I'll just say this that inactivity and lack of TOS knowledge hurt the game badly which was sad to see tbh

@Oreki_Houtarou as first time host you did a great job just remember the things I pointed out to you

thank you all for playing xD
 
Last edited:

Houtarou

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2019
Messages
2,617
Reaction score
1,057
@All_Red - It's supposed to be her second ToS game, yet she played really well, she got quite unlucky by Mafia Invest role who invested her NP1. She was even active in day phase, asking for reads or giving her own reads, trying to find scum. I think she's played Serial Killer role as it should be, if anything she needs to work on, it's her way of reading. She should avoid making wall level post filled with quotes, cuz it becomes hard to make a judgment or it can even consider distraction if someone wants to point out. I can say one thing that she has the potential to become a good player

@Michelle - As for her first ToS game, I think she did pretty well. Michelle first, as a jailer, the first thing you ask your prisoner is their role and then questions. Beware, never give prisoner your identity or hint who you are, they can be scum who's fake claiming. Some of her mistakes wouldn't have happened if she was more aware of game mechanics. I think she asked her prisoner right question beside the role part in Alice case

@Poison chan - You should have not abstained as an escort, I know you were scared that you might hit the SK and die but always remember that you have a role and duty to carry out. You can't abstain due to fear and all. And Please try to take more part in DP

@yurkin - You played well, your actions were all good. But you had the Vigilante for you and you decide to not use it in last NP was kinda let down. Overall I think you played really well, I have seen no major flaws in you plays in the thread either.

@XDDDDD - I don't even need to give a review to this guys, he seems like a really good player. The only mistake he did during the game that he was slacking off on purpose and I believe he could he evaded his lynched if he were just active

@Rej - Witch chooses the same target as you did in NP1, though you hit the jackpot NP1 and it could have turning point for the town if it isn't for a witch. Though he is very familiar with the game and he is a really good player. So I'm not planning to review him

@Alice in Noodleland - My favorite player of the game, she's always funny and tries to create a happy or cheerful atmosphere around the game, so having her in-game is something I consider lucky. She also played her role as a medium quite nicely, even though she's new to the concept

@MechanicalGuitarist - His reads were strong, I think he should be more aggressive when he plays. He had the headstrong post and quite helpful to town if one tries to catch it. Poison did point out but didn't carry it all the way, though his play is really good

@Sagebee - He got unlucky in this game but, had the good post in Day phase. I think he should try to put more force in his reads but he still manages to appear town in that situation which was good.

@Conspirator. - He was quite obviously townie, I mean have you guys ever seen a player who gives up or slacking off too much in DP, no. Scum hardly have time to slack off during DP's only town do that. He should be more active during games and should try to give his opinions too

@Hot_Ice - You disappointed me, why didn't you created a death note? lol

@Udell - :score:

Others also did well even though they barely knew about the game mechanics


Just like Al sama said, it was inactivity that killed the game.
 

Hot_Ice

Member
Joined
May 20, 2019
Messages
27
Reaction score
10
Yes... We won... I think I was ninja'd because of Naomi's reaction from the onset. So I decided to post less to avoid town getting info from my lynch
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej

Michelle

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
12,444
Reaction score
3,766
You won because town had an inexperienced jailor in me -_-
I only jailed town.

And i killed Conspirator because i was sure he is scum, i am really sorry for this.

About All Red i had her as suspicious since day 1. That's why i voted her. Her play was forced.

Rej was an awesome convinving townie.

Alice i had as suspect from first post. I jailed her and gave her town credit. Oreki said i didn't play well about her but i knew she is town. When you play with Alice several months you kinda feel her in few words. Ofc i was right ;-)

The majority lynch at this amount of scum was another problem for town, maybe this is a ToS rule, idk..
 

Michelle

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
12,444
Reaction score
3,766
Also, i was busy D3 and didn't jail in N3 no one. RL was good to me and bad for the game
 

Rej

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
1,280
@All_Red - It's supposed to be her second ToS game, yet she played really well, she got quite unlucky by Mafia Invest role who invested her NP1. She was even active in day phase, asking for reads or giving her own reads, trying to find scum. I think she's played Serial Killer role as it should be, if anything she needs to work on, it's her way of reading. She should avoid making wall level post filled with quotes, cuz it becomes hard to make a judgment or it can even consider distraction if someone wants to point out. I can say one thing that she has the potential to become a good player

@Michelle - As for her first ToS game, I think she did pretty well. Michelle first, as a jailer, the first thing you ask your prisoner is their role and then questions. Beware, never give prisoner your identity or hint who you are, they can be scum who's fake claiming. Some of her mistakes wouldn't have happened if she was more aware of game mechanics. I think she asked her prisoner right question beside the role part in Alice case

@Poison chan - You should have not abstained as an escort, I know you were scared that you might hit the SK and die but always remember that you have a role and duty to carry out. You can't abstain due to fear and all. And Please try to take more part in DP

@yurkin - You played well, your actions were all good. But you had the Vigilante for you and you decide to not use it in last NP was kinda let down. Overall I think you played really well, I have seen no major flaws in you plays in the thread either.

@XDDDDD - I don't even need to give a review to this guys, he seems like a really good player. The only mistake he did during the game that he was slacking off on purpose and I believe he could he evaded his lynched if he were just active

@Rej - Witch chooses the same target as you did in NP1, though you hit the jackpot NP1 and it could have turning point for the town if it isn't for a witch. Though he is very familiar with the game and he is a really good player. So I'm not planning to review him

@Alice in Noodleland - My favorite player of the game, she's always funny and tries to create a happy or cheerful atmosphere around the game, so having her in-game is something I consider lucky. She also played her role as a medium quite nicely, even though she's new to the concept

@MechanicalGuitarist - His reads were strong, I think he should be more aggressive when he plays. He had the headstrong post and quite helpful to town if one tries to catch it. Poison did point out but didn't carry it all the way, though his play is really good

@Sagebee - He got unlucky in this game but, had the good post in Day phase. I think he should try to put more force in his reads but he still manages to appear town in that situation which was good.

@Conspirator. - He was quite obviously townie, I mean have you guys ever seen a player who gives up or slacking off too much in DP, no. Scum hardly have time to slack off during DP's only town do that. He should be more active during games and should try to give his opinions too

@Hot_Ice - You disappointed me, why didn't you created a death note? lol

@Udell - :score:

Others also did well even though they barely knew about the game mechanics


Just like Al sama said, it was inactivity that killed the game.
Thank you man I agree with everything! You did rly good for your first hostgame!
 

LanMisa

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Mar 10, 2019
Messages
563
Reaction score
340
Wait, this game had a 5v1v9 setup, no D1 (thus starting with a wolf kill), and STILL requires majority to lynch?

Looking at those setups I'm kinda surprised if there has ever been a town win game on this site so far.
 

AL_sama

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jan 17, 2019
Messages
1,100
Reaction score
678
Wait, this game had a 5v1v9 setup, no D1 (thus starting with a wolf kill), and STILL requires majority to lynch?

Looking at those setups I'm kinda surprised if there has ever been a town win game on this site so far.
I can show you many town wins if you want on another site tho

this is town of salem not normal mafia

I guess you never played this so I can understand why you said that
 

Shanks

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 19, 2014
Messages
6,015
Reaction score
1,962
Give them 1 scum town will **** the game. Scumreading is core part of the game most peopleonly look for claims thats why town lose so badly.
 

XDDDDD

Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2019
Messages
276
Reaction score
110
Sorry, I lose interest in the games if there are early claims. I suck at mechanics

WP though and gg.
 

Michelle

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
12,444
Reaction score
3,766
Give them 1 scum town will **** the game. Scumreading is core part of the game most peopleonly look for claims thats why town lose so badly.
We never had here a ToS how-to -play thread or so. But i get what you say. Still is dissapointing to not know how to swim and be thrown into the water. That was me. I succesfully drowned :t-t:
One more try and i think ToS adios.
 

ghostBlue

Member
Joined
May 9, 2019
Messages
53
Reaction score
32
Managed to play the whole game without claiming

:wes:
> is witch
> wins with mafia
> accidentally try to kill them the whole game :lol1-onion-head-emoticon:

We never had here a ToS how-to -play thread or so. But i get what you say. Still is dissapointing to not know how to swim and be thrown into the water. That was me. I succesfully drowned :t-t:
One more try and i think ToS adios.
Is not your fault. There is nth wrong with following up on your instinct. In fact, I'ld say town lost because most townies played too passive and afraid to take any action. They kept pushing out ideas but not following up.
Don't stop playing.
 

Alice in Noodleland

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
4,914
Reaction score
2,160
So I was Jailed, targeted, and attacked all at once during NP 1. :ROFLMAO: Thank you for the love people. Michelle protected me by jailing me and I asked for a clue to know her identity and I did. So when she said that she trusted REJ after jailing him.. I put my trust on REJ immediately.


We committed a mistake by executing Conspirator. I'm sorry @Conspirator. During NP we are weighing the odds or the possibility of having 2 doctors in this game.

@Sagebee do you only have 1 shot killing ability or even and odd.?
 

Houtarou

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2019
Messages
2,617
Reaction score
1,057
So I was Jailed, targeted, and attacked all at once during NP 1. :ROFLMAO: Thank you for the love people. Michelle protected me by jailing me and I asked for a clue to know her identity and I did. So when she said that she trusted REJ after jailing him.. I put my trust on REJ immediately.


We committed a mistake by executing Conspirator. I'm sorry @Conspirator. During NP we are weighing the odds or the possibility of having 2 doctors in this game.

@Sagebee do you only have 1 shot killing ability or even and odd.?
I knew it two doctors could create the confusion but you guys had to take reads in account too lol
 

Houtarou

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2019
Messages
2,617
Reaction score
1,057
Alice i had as suspect from first post. I jailed her and gave her town credit. Oreki said i didn't play well about her but i knew she is town. When you play with Alice several months you kinda feel her in few words. Ofc i was right ;-)
It's not about that, in a game you can't always believe in your instincts or your trust as a friend. Yes, you might have reading Alice town in your chat but do not forget that mafia is a game of deception, so you just can not reveal your identity regardless of your trust in your prisoner
 

Alice in Noodleland

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
4,914
Reaction score
2,160
It's not about that, in a game you can't always believe in your instincts or your trust as a friend. Yes, you might have reading Alice town in your chat but do not forget that mafia is a game of deception, so you just can not reveal your identity regardless of your trust in your prisoner

Michelle know my playstyle very well. Besides who will suspect me as a bad guy with this kind of letter



"
To: Jailor


Hello. Its me. I was wondering after all this time of playing Mafia I'm still the most suspicious player for you. Hello can you hear me.?


Spoiler: Send nudes
I'm Town Support... You Pleb!
"
 

Houtarou

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2019
Messages
2,617
Reaction score
1,057
It was a fun game generally, hopefully there are more games like this in the future.
I was planning to host another town of Salem with a bigger setup. But 'm just afraid that lack of activity not might kill my game lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top