[Discussion] Top ten saddest moments in One Piece

[Bogard]

Mine

1- Going Merry will never sail again
2- Luffy when losing Ace
3- Robin's "want to live"
4- Chopper's flashback with Dr. Hiliuk
5- Robin's emotional moment with Vice-admiral Jaguar D Saul, her mother and entire Ohara being destroyed by buster call
6- Franky's emotional moment when he thought his entire family died from the buster call
7- Vivi's "stop fighting" in Alabasta
8- Luffy's "i couldn't save anyone"
9- Fisher Tiger's emotional struggle between Humans and Fishmen
10- Nami's "help me" in Arlong Park

 

[Madarauchiwa]

robins want to live wasn't sad it was awesome. that speech luffy gave her and the whole crew being there and then luffy basically declaring war on the world itself for one of his nakama :T_T: oh such an amazing moment! luffy is truly the best MC out of the big 3

 

[LuckyMan]

When Shanks lost his arm. They had to nerf him because he would have broken the plot from being too powerful. That was sad for me. I hate when they do that to characters

 

[Bogard]

robins want to live wasn't sad it was awesome. that speech luffy gave her and the whole crew being there and then luffy basically declaring war on the world itself for one of his nakama :T_T: oh such an amazing moment! luffy is truly the best MC out of the big 3

Well i personally found it sad because she was struggling between 2 feelings. Guess it depends on opinions though

When Shanks lost his arm. They had to nerf him because he would have broken the plot from being too powerful. That was sad for me. I hate when they do that to characters

They had to nerf him so bad that even with both his arms he was weaker than Mihawk? Okay :|

 

[Ryuma720]

Ace's death is the saddest
I hope Luffy kicks Akainu's ass !!!!

 

[David1996]

#1 is not really sad IMO, Luffy's reaction after Ace death was the saddest.

 

[scorezor]

wtf , franky's entire family died duo to the buster call? did we saw his family at all? bc i don't remember _@:

 

[LuckyMan]

They had to nerf him so bad that even with both his arms he was weaker than Mihawk? Okay :|

Mihawk is inferior to Shanks. He became one of the Yonko with only one arm and he rarely uses a sword. Mihawk might be a better swordsman but overall Shanks is stronger than he is.

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

3, 4, 5, and 8 are the saddest to me. Mainly 5.

 

[Madarauchiwa]

Mihawk is inferior to Shanks. He became one of the Yonko with only one arm and he rarely uses a sword. Mihawk might be a better swordsman but overall Shanks is stronger than he is.

wasn't he a yonko before? when he met with whitebeard, whitebeard commented on how he had lost his arm and asked what opponent he let have it. so doesn't this mean that he had already met and sat with whitebeard as equals before losing his arm? why else would whitebeard bring that up if shanks had achieved yonko status after losing it?

i really think mihawk and shanks are equal in strength. yes mihawk is a better swordsman but then shanks probably makes up for it with whatever it is that shanks uses to fight