Tobi vs Itachi

[Bogard]

We're talking about pre-rinnengan Tobi. Himself without help against Itachi alive and healthy.
So who do you think will win?

 

[Darth Wignus]

It's hard to beat a guy you can't actually touch. I give it to Tobi mid diff.

 

[~MC117~]

I'd go with tobi, he could just stay intangible and avoid every attack itachi has, then throw itachi to his dimension and let him there until he dies

 

[Cpt Long Schlong]

Let's not forget that with the greatest perception abilities in the manga Kabuto didn't see Itachi make a clone in front of his eyes. Itachi is smart enough to work out when Tobi will materialize, and he will use his clone as fodder and probably strike.

I give it to Itachi medium diff - high diff

 

[The Necromancer]

Pre rinnegan Itachi wins. With the rinnegan, Tobi wins.

 

[partha420]

I'd go with tobi, he could just stay intangible and avoid every attack itachi has, then throw itachi to his dimension and let him there until he dies

this xd xd

 

[Bogard]

Let's not forget that with the greatest perception abilities in the manga Kabuto didn't see Itachi make a clone in front of his eyes. Itachi is smart enough to work out when Tobi will materialize, and he will use his clone as fodder and probably strike.

I give it to Itachi medium diff - high diff

Yes but how can he know when to strike? That's the problem, and Tobi is smart too.

 

[Cpt Long Schlong]

Yes but how can he know when to strike? That's the problem, and Tobi is smart too.

He will work out that Tobi materializes when he strikes, much as Minato did. Thought that was obvious

 

[Bogard]

He will work out that Tobi materializes when he strikes, much as Minato did. Thought that was obvious

Minato did it cuz of his reflexes who helped him to avoid at the last second. So far we know, Itachi doesn't have reflexes like Minato..

 

[Cpt Long Schlong]

Minato did it cuz of his reflexes who helped him to avoid at the last second. So far we know, Itachi doesn't have reflexes like Minato..

Sigh. At least read the argument before you "counter it"

"He'd probably create a clone as fodder"

 

[Kakashi Fang]

Tobi will abduct his ass like he's a child!

 

[FloriGlori]

Tobi can basicly evade each and every of Itachi's moves. Until we know Izanami's effects, this goes to Tobi.

 

[Ghostofthewind]

Heathy Itachi, yes. Sick Itachi, no.

Itachi is a 35.5 according to the data book, his biggest weakness is stamina (2.5)
Part 3 Sasuke is a 31.5 with a stamina of 3.5. I think it is safe to say that Itachi would at least have Sasuke's Stamina if healthy. Itachi exceeds all of Sasuke's other stats without beeing healthy giving evidence that Itachi's Stamina would too. So if Itachi was healthy Itachi would at least be 36.5. If his sickness impacted any of Itachi's other stats, Itachi's stats would exceed the maximum.

Tobi's points are uncharted. Tobi said Itachi would have killed Tobi if Tobi didn't have secrets.

It depends on how quickly Itachi can figure out Tobi.

This was my 600th post!!!

You must be registered for see images

 

[Ghostofthewind]

Minato did it cuz of his reflexes who helped him to avoid at the last second. So far we know, Itachi doesn't have reflexes like Minato..

Itachi is a master of the body flicker. I don't know if that makes much of a difference.

I've never see Tobi use the MS, I'm not sure he has one. That opens up the door for Itachi's Tsukuyomi. I know this is a stretch. If someone can show me Tobi use the MS, please do.

 

[Ryuu..]

Still Tobi would be the victor. Itachi can't counter Tobi's S/T Ninjutsu.

 

[WarriorStormMan]

Going off of everything and where both of them are now in the manga. Its a hard decision because Tobi has the rinnegan now coupled with his space/time jutsu, but Itachi is very intelligent, only one able to break Kabuto's edo tensei control over him, and he's no longer sickly because he's technically already dead.

I might have to give the edge to Tobi, I really don't want to cause Itachi is a beast, but the rinnegan paired with space/time jutsu is looking godly.

Oh yeah Tobi still has the sharingan as well......almost forgot.

 

[Prince Charles]

tobi easily. he can simply warp behind itachi and warp him. its that simple tbh.

 

[Ghostofthewind]

Going off of everything and where both of them are now in the manga. Its a hard decision because Tobi has the rinnegan now coupled with his space/time jutsu, but Itachi is very intelligent, only one able to break Kabuto's edo tensei control over him, and he's no longer sickly because he's technically already dead.

I might have to give the edge to Tobi, I really don't want to cause Itachi is a beast, but the rinnegan paired with space/time jutsu is looking godly.

Oh yeah Tobi still has the sharingan as well......almost forgot.

Read the first post.

 

[Kakashi Hatakeo]

Id say itachi, i mean there was a reason why tobi kick started his plans once itachi died and that was because he feared itachi to a certain extent and knew it was possible for itachi to kill him if itachi knew his secrets. So itachi ftw

 

[xodzeh]

I'd go with tobi, he could just stay intangible and avoid every attack itachi has, then throw itachi to his dimension and let him there until he dies

Only one thing tho..

You must be registered for see links