Re: Official Tobi ID thread:All Tobi theories go here:-
Why do people feel the need to pin the known uchihas as Tobi? It started off with obito, I feel making the argument that it is kagami or izuna is really the same as saying tobi is obito.
I personally think Tobi is someone we do not know, he is far too skilled and has been around for a very long time. He knows an incredible amount of information about Madara, he is not just anyone.
One could make the argument of, "Well who knows Madara better then his brother?" At first, this sounds accurate. Upon closer examination, one will realise once Naruto mentionned to tobi that the REAL madara was revived, Tobi took it rather harsh, infact it was pretty obvious that he did not want the REAL madara around.
For Kagami, I mean this compares to obito. We do not know much about him, but we know he was a higher up in Konoha, we know this because he was there right before Tobirama's death, WITH sarutobi and danzo. I doubt he would want to cast infinite tsukuyomi. Again we don't know much about him.
In conclusion, I feel tobi is someone we do not know, but has some sort of connection with this all. He apparently gave pain the rinnegan, and has the sharingan. He isn't just a chump.