Tobi Kirigakure

[saaaaaadpanda]

Note: If this is the wrong forum, please send me to bed without dessert.

I was looking at Narutopedia earlier and came across Tobi's page. Under his affiliations, it lists Akatsuki (understandably). It also lists Kirigakure, which makes me go:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I understand Tobi was manipulating the kage, but that doesn't mean he's affiliated with that village. It's like saying Orochimaru was affiliated with Sunagakure.

Does anyone else feel this is a grievous error?

 

[FlareBlitz]

well if he was manipulating the village kage then he is somewhat connected to it am i wrong??

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

well if he was manipulating the village kage then he is somewhat connected to it am i wrong??

Yes. Yes you are. Again, by this logic, Orochimaru should be affiliated with the Hidden Sand. However, when you go to his page, he's not.

 

[bobonosis]

tobi is kirigakures mizukge

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

tobi is kirigakures mizukge

No, that's Mei.

 

[Master Troll]

Maybe the random people who come across the site put that? It's free to change.

 

[GreenV]

Tobi lived in Kirigakure.

And maybe the Third Mizukage was Tobi.

 

[FlareBlitz]

Yes. Yes you are. Again, by this logic, Orochimaru should be affiliated with the Hidden Sand. However, when you go to his page, he's not.

I see what ur sayin now...hmm..probably just a typo someone missed

 

[Dead Ninja]

Yes. Yes you are. Again, by this logic, Orochimaru should be affiliated with the Hidden Sand. However, when you go to his page, he's not.

As well as most (if not all) the other villages too, from the many ninja he has controlled, minipulated, captured ect ect.

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

What's wrong with that? He was manipulating the 4. Mizukage in years, something that makes him secret leader. I don't see what's wrong at all. 'Secret Leader of Kirigakure' it stands

Zlad here by the way

Glad I could be your first thread post with your new account. Anyway, look again at my Orochimaru parallel. He's not affiliated with the Sand.

As well as most (if not all) the other villages too, from the many ninja he has controlled, minipulated, capture ect ect.

Word.

Maybe the random people who come across the site put that? It's free to change.

Yes, this is the danger of a wiki

Tobi lived in Kirigakure.

And maybe the Third Mizukage was Tobi.

Controlling the Mizukage and being the Mizukage are not the same thing.

 

[Tsuki]

Maybe because Tobi lived long enough in that village or something like that :shrug: since he was controling their kage

Edit: When it comes to orochimaru he was just allied with the sand, he didnt live there and he wasnt the sand's leader

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Meh, made this acc just now to answer you, really.

Orochimaru didnt control the 4. Kazekage in years like Tobi did to Mizukage, that's a big difference

I'm flattered. I don't think it is a big difference. We don't know that Tobi stayed there for any considerable length of time.

Maybe because Tobi lived long enough in that village or something like that :shrug: since he was controling their kage

Edit:When it comes to orochimaru he was just allied with the sand, he didnt live there and he wasnt the sand's leader

We don't know that Tobi lived there. He had the Mizukage under genjutsu. That doesn't necessarily require his presence. Oro was the Sand's leader. Remember, he killed the Kazekage and played dress up as him?

 

[Legendary Broly]

the site isnt very accurate

 

[Alcapone]

he probably there a WHILE

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

And I remember that was stated in the manga/anime as well, when Kisame died. But I think that's enough, and Kishi is the boss. Now I have to leave, see ya

Kishi doesn't run Narutopedia...

 

[ShishaMastah420]

I'm flattered. I don't think it is a big difference. We don't know that Tobi stayed there for any considerable length of time.




We don't know that Tobi lived there. He had the Mizukage under genjutsu. That doesn't necessarily require his presence. Oro was the Sand's leader. Remember, he killed the Kazekage and played dress up as him?

You must be registered for see images

This picture shows a Tobi from back before the Uchiha Massacre...So i think he did reside in Kirigakure for an extended period of time...

Also note the quote below...

Tobi took control of the Fourth Mizukage, in effect making him the "real" Mizukage, leading Kirigakure into the years of the "Bloody Mist"

 

[SashaUchiha]

Tobi lived in Kirigakure.

And maybe the Third Mizukage was Tobi.

Maybe, that is a possibility. But if he was, why did he give up being 3rd Mizukage and start controlling the 4th?

Controlling the Mizukage and being the Mizukage are not the same thing.

that guy was saying Tobi = 3rd Mizukage dude...

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

This picture shows a Tobi from back before the Uchiha Massacre...So i think he did reside in Kirigakure for an extended period of time...

Also note the quote below...

The photo shows that Tobi was there once. That's like me showing you my vacation photos and claiming that I lived in London. As far as his control and rule, we can assume that Tobi had the Mizukage under some pretty heavy genjutsu which would not necessarily require his ongoing presence. All the evidence for Tobi being a resident of the Hidden Mist is circumstantial and should be stricken.

 

[Stark]

Tobi was addressed as Mizukage by Kisame out of respect. During the times of the bloody mist era everyone knew that Yagura was being controlled.

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Naruto wikia is made my people not kishi.