Tobi is Shisui Uchiha

[medal32]

Too many plotholes

 

[Maunten]

Now I regret that I read it, because you didn't get me. Well I'll explain:

If Tobi is Shisui, why the heck would he say ''I'll take Shisui's eye'' instead of ''I'll take my eye''. It doesn't make ANY sense.

If he went through the trouble of putting danzo into his genjutsu why would he then slip up like that.

 

[Prince Charles]

Now I regret that I read it, because you didn't get me. Well I'll explain:

If Tobi is Shisui, why the heck would he say ''I'll take Shisui's eye'' instead of ''I'll take my eye''. It doesn't make ANY sense.

this also.

 

[Frikid]

just tell me why tobi didn't used KA against minato ?

and many plot holes in your theory really

 

[Maunten]

Damn, ok it's overwhelming that itachi either had Shisui's eye or they planned it this way

Since I want to reduce assumptions as much as possible let's say for 100% then that itachi had shisuis eye, would still have one more, and could easily replace it by killing any uchiha member, the theory is only fataly flawed if it is proven that he gave up both.

 

[Maunten]

just tell me why tobi didn't used KA against minato ?

and many plot holes in your theory really

10 year wait.

 

[kaka96]

Damn, ok it's overwhelming that itachi either had Shisui's eye or they planned it this way

Since I want to reduce assumptions as much as possible let's say for 100% then that itachi had shisuis eye, would still have one more, and could easily replace it by killing any uchiha member, the theory is only fataly flawed if it is proven that he gave up both.

Danzo had the other eye, he used it on Mifune, and it was the one Tobi was trying to recover...

 

[Prince Charles]

Damn, ok it's overwhelming that itachi either had Shisui's eye or they planned it this way

Since I want to reduce assumptions as much as possible let's say for 100% then that itachi had shisuis eye, would still have one more, and could easily replace it by killing any uchiha member, the theory is only fataly flawed if it is proven that he gave up both.

omg... just stop your theory has too much holes...

1. its a known FACT itachi had shuisi eye he placed it in naruto and used it to escape from edo tensei

2. danzo had the other eye

if your going to make a theory atleast bring solid facts to the table.

 

[Maunten]

Danzo had the other eye, he used it on Mifune, and it was the one Tobi was trying to recover...

-sigh- damn you.

 

[julio10ification]

lmfao didnt itachi implant one of Shisui's eye into his crow and danzo had the other and as far im concerned Shisui was the same age as itachi they were best friends tobi couldn't be Shisui because itachi was like a little child when the kyuubi attacked so this is a failed thread

 

[Frikid]

we know,tobi's age is equal to or more than minato 's age.

when tobi attacked konoha,
at that time, itachi was like 5 years old.
so , shisui will also be of same age.

and so shisui is not tobi. ok

 

[Maunten]

lmfao didnt itachi implant one of Shisui's eye into his crow and danzo had the other and as far im concerned Shisui was the same age as itachi they were best friends tobi couldn't be Shisui because itachi was like a little child when the kyuubi attacked so this is a failed thread

They were not the same age, but the theory is disproven by the fact that both of his eyes are used by two different people..

 

[kaka96]

-sigh- damn you.

Lol, not the first time I hear that xD

 

[Maunten]

Lol, not the first time I hear that xD

I really thought I had it, I guess I didn't do anywhere near enough digging but his eyes just blew my theory apart it would have been so cool if he was, his genjutsu probably surpassed madaras.

 

[julio10ification]

all i now is tobi is not Shisui for the decades of knowledge he holds through out history. and also during the kyuubi attack was about to start he stated hes been waiting for this for a long time witch tells you this dude is a decade old and had seen his share

 

[Maunten]

Yeah I guess your right can't be Shisui real shame.

This theory by another poster is a lot more likely

You must be registered for see links

 

[SasukexNeji]

This raises a new question...who are Shisui's parents? Or least his father?

 

[YourMom]

So Itachi was a kid holding his baby brother during the nine tails attack with Tobi, and Tobi was already skilled, older and had a deep voice so like... either Itachi was best friends with some old creeper or your theory is bullshit.

This made me lmao

 

[julio10ification]

Yeah I guess your right can't be Shisui real shame.

This theory by another poster is a lot more likely

You must be registered for see links

good try thou at this point ive given up trying to figure out who tobi is each time you've think you got his identity sorted out it just fails and backfires im just gonna be patient and wait for kishi to reveal who he is cause its killing every naruto fans curiosity

 

[Maunten]

good try thou at this point ive given up trying to figure out who tobi is each time you've think you got his identity sorted out it just fails and backfires im just gonna be patient and wait for kishi to reveal who he is cause its killing every naruto fans curiosity

Well I can't stop thinking about it, I think I'm gona break from naruto, I tend to do that when I'm up to date, then I wate for like 10 - 15 more chapters to come out.

If I don't each chapter I read will be with the hope of tobi's identity being revealed.