They should of kept madara, like DragonBall kept buu and frieza.

[rinnegan human puppet]

Right or wrong? Even broly is back now. Bring my guy madz back.

 

[Calpal]

Couldnt madara be edo'd again though?

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

Why not? I would like to see Madara killed an additional 4 times in humiliating ways.

 

[rinnegan human puppet]

Couldnt madara be edo'd again though?

Yea pretty sure orochimaru could do it easily.

 

[Light up the Darkness]

the Build Up for Uchiha Madara Character and how he established Konoha and he was the strongest and most legendary Uchiha

is one of many Reasons why he should ended as the Final Villain

as you mentioned Frieza to DBZ was a great villain

but the final Guy in DBZ ( boo ) was lame comparing to Frieza
also the final villain in GT was lame

so Good Villains needed a lot of build up

Madara and Tobi were the Greatest Villains in Naruto ​

 

[uhmusddy]

Only reason I agree is he deserves to whoop ootsusuki ass

Other than that I could only see them bringing kaguya back but that’s not likely still either

Atleast we got Toneri lol maybe

 

[Reboryushon]

Wrong. Madara without his ideals loses part of his charm.

 

[InfiniteMugen]

Oh god no, I don’t think the team in charge is capable of bringing back a character like that without completely ruining their character and making them some kind of martyr for someone.

I’m not a big Frieza fan, but the way they actually keep him a villain and yet still relevant to our mains is dope

 

[Animegoin]

I only want Madara to return if he is isn’t nerfed and has the opportunity to go ape-shit on a powerful enemy. With that being said though, from what I can see, there won’t be a ‘powerful enemy’ worthy of Madara going full force on. Therefore, let him rest.

 

[uhmusddy]

Madara needs to be new leader of Ootsusuki

 

[ThelUchiha]

Madara is still around if only new writers can write a story

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Tobidara is still out there...

 

[AllKnowingShinobi]

shouldve keep obito.... now hear me out if obito was still alive sarada would have a proper teacher , and obito who is the kinda villain to turn a new leaf. if you thought kakashi was cool, well thats only becuase he stole obitos swag, like running late , lame excuses, friendship, op sharingan ability, and chill attitude. if obito stayed alive.... he wouldve became the new jiraya to sarada at least.

 

[itachifan7]

I think doing that would cheapen Naruto. Don't get me wrong I like Madara, but he has already been brought back once.

 

[Light up the Darkness]

I think doing that would cheapen Naruto. Don't get me wrong I like Madara, but he has already been brought back once.

totally agree

let the legend rest in peace along with the legends ( Itachi , Obito )

i miss all of them
these 4 ( with Sasuke ) shook the whole ninja world
and made every clan shit on themselves ​

 

[salamander uchiha]

Madara is around there's too much tecnology and he can easily be cloned from the JJ legs. Madara eould possess Rokufo chakra and his MS would be never blinding. I personally think a cloned Madara, younger with his own personality and ideas would've made the best MC for a new gen. He wouldn't be overly powerful either and would have the mpst potential for plot exploration.

 

[Megax Rocker7]

If things go south, Sasuke can make Oro bring back Madara and the rest of the Hokages for back up, Madara would only be in it for a good fight though so he won't cooperate easily.

 

[Pappasaur]

Tbh it would have been kind of cool if Madara pulled a semi frieza and actually achieved immortality as a regular person but lost the Juubi and rinnegan, and after the events of the war arc he becomes a reclusive and peaceful warrior/monk type shinobi who just wanders the world and occasionally offers help/advice to naruto/sasuke

 

[chaos control]

As much as I like Madara, I have to ask: What would be the point in keeping him around?

Madara is quite a different case from both Frieza and Buu. Frieza was pure evil from day one and he is evil today. He was brought back in Resurrection F (and associated DBS saga) because he made for a powerful adversary to contest Goku and Vegeta's (at the time) newly acquired Super Saiyan Blue form. Plus, Frieza actually had an in universe reason (that actually related to his character) as to why it would be good for him to come back. Even if it was just for the sake of pure revenge on Goku, that is still actually a legit reason the (that fits Frieza's character) as to why the writers would bring him back.

Then, the tournament of power was also the perfect setup for Frieza to come back again. Buu fell asleep, and universe 7 urgently needed a strong last team member. That is why, for the fate of the universe, they decided to call a temporary truce with the ultimate evil! It was absolutely necessary, and this return of Frieza actually perfectly made sense with what was going on in the plot.

Buu is a bit of a different case, but it still makes sense. The fat Buu becoming good was actually apart of the plot of that arc, and he ultimately helped in and survived the fight with Kid Buu, so it makes sense that he just chills at Hercule's place afterwards. The writers didn't even use him that much afterwards, but the reason why he is a remains still makes sense.


Madara is different though. Upon Black Zetsu's betrayal, Madara realized that all his effort was lost and for naught, and upon his death, he actually came to accept Hashirama's viewpoint. At that point, everything that made him an effective antagonist pretty much got resolved and disappeared. If he were to be edo'd or revived again, he most likely wouldn't actually be making any big revolutionary moves anymore (like the eye of the moon plan), or attacking Konoha. Furthermore, he didn't split into any "Good Madara" and "Bad Madara" like Buu did, so there was no reason for a part of him to survive or anything like that.

Basically, Madara's story and overall relevance ended when he died at the end of the war. There's no revenge plot with Madara like there was with Frieza (since Madara died in peace), and thus far there hasn't been any situation like the tournament of power that would actually require our heroes to consult the dead and old enemies in order to deal with some grave situation.

Even with Salamander's "Madara clone" plot, I still don't get what the point of cloning him would be. Who would clone him and why? Like, even Orochimaru had his own reasons for creating Mitsuki, but this Madara cloning just sounds random (especially if the scientist or whoever clones him just lets the kid Madara go live in Konoha). Salamander once said that the purpose would be harvesting a rinnegan, but then what would even be the point of that? What are they using this rinnegan for? Madara (the original) sought to awaken the rinnegan because it was actually necessary for summoning and controlling the mazou and carrying out the eye of the moon plan. Obito later sought to obtain it from Nagato for essentially the same reason. In other words, their pursuit of the rinnegan had an actual purpose at the time. What would be this random scientist's purpose though?

Also, even if he had a purpose for the rinnegan, why go through the trouble of cloning Madara and sending him to Konoha in hopes that he eventually awakens a rinnegan for you to subsequently take, when you can either just seek a chakara fruit to awaken one, or steal Sasuke's?

I know you may say that it would be too hard to steal Sasuke's, but if this clone Madara gets to the point where he actually awakens the rinnegan, then it would most likely be just as hard to steal it from him as well! Rinnegan users aren't just some pushovers whose eyes you can just casually steal like taking candy from a baby. Therefore, if you're going to try and fight a rinnegan Madara, you might as well just save yourself the cloning effort and just go for Sasuke's since his already exists, and either way, you're in for an intense battle.

Really, the chakara fruit idea would be best if you want a rinnegan, either that, or find Rikudou Madara's lower half, and instead of cloning Madara with it, find a way to extract the rikudou chakara from it either into your own body, or into some kind of drug, so that you can just awaken the rinnegan for yourself instead of trying to somehow survive a fight with a rinnegan Madara.

 

[salamander uchiha]

Even with Salamander's "Madara clone" plot, I still don't get what the point of cloning him would be. Who would clone him and why? Like, even Orochimaru had his own reasons for creating Mitsuki, but this Madara cloning just sounds random (especially if the scientist or whoever clones him just lets the kid Madara go live in Konoha). Salamander once said that the purpose would be harvesting a rinnegan, but then what would even be the point of that? What are they using this rinnegan for? Madara (the original) sought to awaken the rinnegan because it was actually necessary for summoning and controlling the mazou and carrying out the eye of the moon plan. Obito later sought to obtain it from Nagato for essentially the same reason. In other words, their pursuit of the rinnegan had an actual purpose at the time. What would be this random scientist's purpose though?

The reason for cloning would be to harvest a rinnegan and gain power. The Rinnegan was never necessary for controlling the mezo as Madara made it clear Obito would be able to summon and control it.

Also, even if he had a purpose for the rinnegan, why go through the trouble of cloning Madara and sending him to Konoha in hopes that he eventually awakens a rinnegan for you to subsequently take, when you can either just seek a chakara fruit to awaken one, or steal Sasuke's?

Who said they would clone him and send him to Konoha? Let's say the remnants of Root cloned him to gain control of a Rinnegan to enact Danzo's will(Konoha's supremeacy). Naruto and Sasuke found him while trying to close down Root. And Naruto decides to take him to Konoha but Sasuke wants to end him. That is where the rift between the two begins. As for taking Sasuke's Rinnegan that's just not possible and a chakra fruit requires trans dimensional travel a rinnegan or the mezo to contain which requires a rinnegan.

I know you may say that it would be too hard to steal Sasuke's, but if this clone Madara gets to the point where he actually awakens the rinnegan, then it would most likely be just as hard to steal it from him as well! Rinnegan users aren't just some pushovers whose eyes you can just casually steal like taking candy from a baby. Therefore, if you're going to try and fight a rinnegan Madara, you might as well just save yourself the cloning effort and just go for Sasuke's since his already exists, and either way, you're in for an intense battle.

No not necessarily if you're cloning somebody to control him you'd have fail safes in place to make him controllable. Clone Madara would never awaken the Rinnegan since his genes aren't Ashura genes they're still Madara genes. However he would possess Rokudo chakra and be able to achieve an EMS level power like Indra due to being cloned from JJ Madara's remains. He would also have limited chakra since he's not actually Madara(Indra soul), maybe cloning being imperfect caused another defect so he won't be whipping out Super huge PS. Rather he'd be similar to the one who fought the alliance in the anime CQC + form and used Yin weapons.

Having all of this, having a conflict of existence. Naruto trying to guide him and give him purpose, Sasuke wanting to kill him. He would be dealing with his own existence, the stigma of Madara's actions while facing challenges and saving the world. It would allow for far better character depth and story development. This is just scratching the surface of the plot potential that is possible for him and the story as a whole.

It would practically shit on anything the current story has to offer as it stands it's a Borutrash fapfest. It would make the new series as popular if not more popular than Naruto as long as Koshiti doesn't write it. And the most important thing is he wouldn't require ass pulls and handouts or be overly powerful so we could have some entertainment.