Theory:Sage And His Sons

[Sirius Black]

I was wondering what happened to Hagoromo's brother. One theory I read is that

He is Ancestor of UZUMAKI and HYUGA clans

But if that's true why has history not got anything about him.

My Theory

Hagoromo and his brother fought Juubi and sealed the Chakra within themselves. When HAGOROMO realized that after thier death the Juubi will ruin the peace in attempt to get it's chakra back which people had, he removed the chakra from him and his brother which made his brother Angry(supposing that he was power hungry)and he turned bad.

Now next part

When Hagoromo made ASHURA take his place INDRA had hatred as he was older and it was his right to get the power.That brother of Hagoromo used that hatred and turned him against Ashura which started war

I think That
Naruto=Ashura
Sasuke=Indra
Madara=Brother of Hagoromo(reincarnation or simply Madara carrying his will)

Points:

• It doesn't seem right that Indra to be reincarnated so early in Madara and Ashura so late in Naruto.
• Indra and Asuhra were close to each other which can only point to Sasuke And Naruto being friends.
• Age difference in Sasuke and Naruto is almost similar to the Indra and Ashura
• About hagoromo's brother not being ancestor of Hyuga and Uzumaki clan, I refuse that theory because If he had been their Ancestor history would have something about him.
• A person as Important as Kyuga's son cannot be just erased out of history unless he is bad or evil.

Above written material is just theory it may or may not be close to reality of manga. So please don't get too much serious about this,though Your ideas and criticism is acceptable

 

[Skull Knight]

I still think Sage's bro is Jashin.
the god who is still waiting for his entrance.

 

[a banned cartoon]

This is the most logical theory so far. Agreed.

 

[AShinyPlatypus]

You make some good points, but the brother of Rikudou being the Uzumaki and Hyuga ancestor is more plausible than you suggest. We're talking a minimum of centuries between Rikudou's time and Naruto's, easily enough time for something like that to be forgotten. No one knew that Senju and Uchiha were descendants of the S06P either.

 

[Sirius Black]

You make some good points, but the brother of Rikudou being the Uzumaki and Hyuga ancestor is more plausible than you suggest. We're talking a minimum of centuries between Rikudou's time and Naruto's, easily enough time for something like that to be forgotten. No one knew that Senju and Uchiha were descendants of the S06P either.

As I said earlier that He was A God's(supposedly GOD Hagoromo) Brother. No matter how much time passes you cannot simply forget a person like him even if he is Hyuga And Uzumaki clan's ancestor.

I believe that Uzumaki and Hyuga's are simply mutations caused by marriage of some senju and uchiha out of their clans respectively.

 

[AShinyPlatypus]

As I said earlier that He was A God's(supposedly GOD Hagoromo) Brother. No matter how much time passes you cannot simply forget a person like him even if he is Hyuga And Uzumaki clan's ancestor.

I believe that Uzumaki and Hyuga's are simply mutations caused by marriage of some senju and uchiha out of their clans respectively.

Nobody remembered Kaguya, did they? Or the Juubi.
Look at Ohnoki's reaction on this page

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Enough time has passed for Rikudou to be considered a myth, why on earth would anyone have details of when he was around?

 

[Tobi98]

Naruto = Ashura
Sasuke = Indra
Madara = Rikudou's brother
Obito = Rikudou

I'm calling it

 

[Sirius Black]

Nobody remembered Kaguya, did they? Or the Juubi.
Look at Ohnoki's reaction on this page

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Enough time has passed for Rikudou to be considered a myth, why on earth would anyone have details of when he was around?

I didn't say that Everyone should remember about it But atleast madara Should know about this even he didn't mention that but it simply means we have different views so lets just leave it at that