The Uchiha with Rinnegan are no longer Uchiha

[Namar]

what kind of logic is this. so they are no longer uchiha because a power they have didnt come from them naturally?

First of all from where is your sig. Looks badass.

Second, their fighting style when they have rinnegan is totally different from their style when they have sharingan. It changes them completely not to mention that the Rinnegan is not affected by emotions and this is the main trait of the Uchiha.. their emotions.

Plus as some people have mentioned the Rinnegan is not really theirs. Since they need different DNA added to theirs.

 

[King Of Pop]

First of all from where is your sig. Looks badass.

Second, their fighting style when they have rinnegan is totally different from their style when they have sharingan. It changes them completely not to mention that the Rinnegan is not affected by emotions and this is the main trait of the Uchiha.. their emotions.

Plus as some people have mentioned the Rinnegan is not really theirs. Since they need different DNA added to theirs.

Thanks, shes Lexa from a Tv series, The 100. you should watch it, pretty cool show

not really, addressed the fighting style in my previous post which i edited. i get what you are trying to say, that the rinnegan is not an uchiha power. that doesnt mean the ones using it are no longer part of the clan because it didnt change their genetic makeup.

 

[Pyro NB]

So if Sasuke started using the Gates, he'd no longer be an Uchiha?

So we're talking genetics. If I take a blood transfusion from you, am I now a part of your family instead of mine? Or am I now the part of a whole new family that's the combination of our genes because your blood is flowing in my veins?

Also, did you miss where Sasuke and Madara used Sharingan techniques while using the Rinnegan?

The argument still stands.



So what? It doesn't change that they're still Uchiha by any means. What, is Sasuke now a part of Juugo's clan because his chest is made of Juugo's flesh?

You can argue that Rinnegan isn't an ability of the Uchiha Clan, sure, but that doesn't mean the person is no longer an Uchiha.

pretty much my view point genetic wise. Now for fighting style they don't lose their sharingan or its abilities they just gain more to add to their arsenal. Whether or not they want to use their old ones is up to them but never the less they are still Uchiha. Random point Rinnegan isn't a Uchiha/Senju thing as it can only be achieved by combining Indra/Ashura chakra. This means that theres potentially only one/two people in every 70 or so years who can achieve this.

 

[V h o]

Well they are still uchiha, although rinnegan is not a genetic uchiha trait nor evolution of an uchihas ability, but a combination of Indra and ashura chakra.

 

[Jiren]

last name still Uchiha dumbasses.

 

[Demonic.]

KingHashirama made a very similar thread not too long ago :hmm:

 

[UnknownJin]

Let's start with what an Uchiha is:

Uchiha is a clan that represents a group of people whose power lie in their emotions.

They can achieve their ocular changes through emotions that hold a heavy impact for them. Example: loss, sacrifice, etc.

The base powers of the Uchiha:
1. Read the motion of the person they are focusing on;
2. Genjutsu;
3. Body - Eye perfect coordination;
4. Perfect Visual Memory;

These are the base powers of an Uchiha. These are the powers that make an Uchiha, Uchiha.

As time passed by and the manga progressed Kishi slowly started to fade away from all these fundamental characteristics.

Now, let's cut the chase a little bit and get to cake faster.

The Rinnegan.

The Rinnegan powers:
1. 6 Paths
2. Limbo
3. Share vision
4. See Limbo world
5. Probably more, but I don't remember any more at this point.

There is nothing in the Rinnegan similar to the Sharingan power. No power whatsoever.
There is nothing of the powers that make an Uchiha, Uchiha within the Rinnegan.

Therefor I believe that calling an Uchiha with rinnegan, an Uchiha is a complete hurdle of donkeys because the fighting style is changed at an 180 degree angle.

Many people and I've read this a lot, treat a rinnegan user as a sharingan user. Why would they do this ? Rinnegan has absolutely no power connection with the demon eyes.

These three guys explain it better than me. I actually lacked the skill to express what i wanted to share with this thread and they helped me a lot. If you don't understand my words. Read their words and you will.

How can u not be an Uchiha if ur an Uchiha and got Rinnengan? .. pfff

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Good to know, Sasuke isn't an Uchiha anymore. Look, if you want to be technical then, Rinnegan users are either Ootutsuki or Uchiha and senju.

 

[Namar]

Good to know, Sasuke isn't an Uchiha anymore. Look, if you want to be technical then, Rinnegan users are either Ootutsuki or Uchiha and senju.

Exactly.