[Predictions] The SH's already have the 4th Rio poneglyph

[Portgas D Xatch]

What if...a copy of the last Rio poneglyph is in luffys straw hat!
Look at some facts:1. It was Rogers hat originally, we all know the former PK had to find all four to get to raftel, so maybe he kept something more important In the band,in the straw itself, and maybe why he entrusted the hat to shanks .
2. Shanks gave the hat to luffy because he believes he will become the next PK, and tasks luffy with returning the hat to shanks..in order for luffy to even be able to accomplish this he would have to get strong, a crew, a ship, and knowledge of the new world. By the time luffy makes it to shanks he should be strong enough to start his run for OP. also knowing luffy, shanks may have surmised that luffy will save him for last on his road to defeating the yonko, which means he would probably have to make it past big mom and kaido who also have map pieces.

This is one of a few theories I would like to see play out, the others being;enel has the 4th on the moon(just want to see him again), dragons face tattoo is it, or there is only three and the 4th is a lie too keep ppl from becoming pk

Sorry if this theory has been done before, tell me what you think?

 

[Passerby]

I think the Gorrosei have the 4th one.

 

[chopstickchakra]

I think the Gorrosei have the 4th one.

Me too, it would be the best way to prevent another pirate from finding Raftel. Also idk if others have said Dragon's face tat is a map to Raftel but I was joking when I said it.

 

[YellowFang]

As others said, most probable option is WG...

 

[scorezor]

youtube , bye bye.

 

[Caliburn]

What if...a copy of the last Rio poneglyph is in luffys straw hat!
Look at some facts:1. It was Rogers hat originally, we all know the former PK had to find all four to get to raftel, so maybe he kept something more important In the band,in the straw itself, and maybe why he entrusted the hat to shanks .
2. Shanks gave the hat to luffy because he believes he will become the next PK, and tasks luffy with returning the hat to shanks..in order for luffy to even be able to accomplish this he would have to get strong, a crew, a ship, and knowledge of the new world. By the time luffy makes it to shanks he should be strong enough to start his run for OP. also knowing luffy, shanks may have surmised that luffy will save him for last on his road to defeating the yonko, which means he would probably have to make it past big mom and kaido who also have map pieces.

This is one of a few theories I would like to see play out, the others being;enel has the 4th on the moon(just want to see him again), dragons face tattoo is it, or there is only three and the 4th is a lie too keep ppl from becoming pk

Sorry if this theory has been done before, tell me what you think?

This has really no grounds, it's baseless on all aspects.

The poneglyph are huge, we are talking about something that's almost 4 meters by 4 meters. So having a copy of something that huge and to hide it inside a straw hat would require to shrink it tremendously, which would make it impossible to read. That's one problem.

The second problem is that we are talking about an old, battered straw hat that barely has any room to hide anything in other than very tiny objects and that has been damaged numerous times and restored. If there was actually anything hiding in there, they would have found it by now. The chance that the straw hat/the poneglyph copy would be lost/destroyed was also incredibly high.

The third problem is that for Roger there wasn't a single, special unknown poneglyph, that only counts for us. We know the whereabouts of three poneglyph, so the 4th is still a mystery, but that wasn't the case for Roger. Big Mum and Kaidou are after Roger's time, so for him it would be completely non-sensical to randomly chose only one poneglyph and stick it into his hat.

Lastly this goes completely against the personalities of either Roger, Rayleigh and Shanks. Rayleigh even proposed to say everything, but everyone refused. They are the type of people to give a little push, but they will let them choose and follow their own path. Giving an important map is the complete opposite of that, even more because there was a huge risk that the map would be discovered long before they even could realize what it exactly is. It also doesn't make any sense that the straw hat, which is the most important symbolic object in the entire series, has only one random poneglyph copy in it.

 

[chopstickchakra]

This has really no grounds, it's baseless on all aspects.

The poneglyph are huge, we are talking about something that's almost 4 meters by 4 meters. So having a copy of something that huge and to hide it inside a straw hat would require to shrink it tremendously, which would make it impossible to read. That's one problem.

The second problem is that we are talking about an old, battered straw hat that barely has any room to hide anything in other than very tiny objects and that has been damaged numerous times and restored. If there was actually anything hiding in there, they would have found it by now. The chance that the straw hat/the poneglyph copy would be lost/destroyed was also incredibly high.

The third problem is that for Roger there wasn't a single, special unknown poneglyph, that only counts for us. We know the whereabouts of three poneglyph, so the 4th is still a mystery, but that wasn't the case for Roger. Big Mum and Kaidou are after Roger's time, so for him it would be completely non-sensical to randomly chose only one poneglyph and stick it into his hat.

Lastly this goes completely against the personalities of either Roger, Rayleigh and Shanks. Rayleigh even proposed to say everything, but everyone refused. They are the type of people to give a little push, but they will let them choose and follow their own path. Giving an important map is the complete opposite of that, even more because there was a huge risk that the map would be discovered long before they even could realize what it exactly is. It also doesn't make any sense that the straw hat, which is the most important symbolic object in the entire series, has only one random poneglyph copy in it.

A copy not a duplicate stone. As in someone wrote it down and hid the paper in the hat, or it's written on the straw that makes up the hat and somehow hidden(admittedly that one's a dumb example but it's fiction anything can happen maybe you'd need a super high level of ob haki to see it?)

We don't know that the 4th wasn't a mystery during Rogers time as well. We don't know if Roger moved the 4th after finding Raftel and left clues for the next generations. It wouldn't be non sensical, if he wanted to hide Raftels location until a worthy pirate could find it he would try to hide some information and since it's easier to hide just one piece(no pun intended) he would logically pick one of the 4 marker stones and hide it and leave a hint for the worthy pirate to follow.

I don't disagree with you that it's not in the hat but those reasons are not good reasons. The last reason about the personality is a more reasonable argument, especially with the Rayleigh point.

 

[loj]

Just imagine that it's Buggy XD

You must be registered for see images

Just who would lug those big things around with them anyways?

Buggy.Who is stupid enough to find or steal one and not know what it is...Buggy.

OT: Buggy has the 4th one :bdpf: