The Reason Behind the Mask

[Colonel Armstrong]

this be one of them cool threads by the legend, saaaaaadpanda-sama...lol

 

[Maderator]

Well done man, really well thought out. Finally a Tobi thread that actually has a point.

 

[ChidoriChimp]

I agree, but I kinda think most people couldve figured that out

 

[SilverSlick]

he put a mask cuz he can't keep a straight face when doing that funny shi*!

You sayin, that he thinks everything is funny. God damn it I could post a meme right now describing his reaction to everything but I'm on my mobile.

 

[naruttebayo]

You must be registered for see images

can he be the guy in the left

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

can he be the guy in the left

Anything's possible. However, this is not an identity thread.

 

[Simplified]

Why did he wear a mask? To hide his identity Genius :sy:

You must be registered for see images

Lol, this. You're overthinking this one chief.

 

[Maunten]

You must be registered for see images

The Reason Behind the Mask​

Note: This is not a Tobi identity thread. I will not provide support for any specific Tobi candidates. Also, if this has been done before, please forgive me. Finally, this thread is long. If you want a concise summary without justification, see the end of the thread.

The hottest topic since Tobi's introduction has been what's behind the mask. Instead, I'm going to ask why wear the mask in the first place? The straightforward answer is to conceal his identity, but I believe we can dig a little deeper than that.

First, let's examine a close analog of Tobi, another masked villain from the Avatar series, Amon:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Much like Tobi, Amon was a masked villain who incited a lot of intrigue and debate as to who he actually was. Fortunately, his identity was revealed in a single season.

Upon revealing his identity, it became clear why he had hid it in the first place. Had he revealed himself as Noatak, brother to councilman Tarrlok, he would've been exposed as a water bender, which would have dissolved his anti bending support base, pun intended. Additionally his methods for removing benders' powers would have no longer been an intimidating mystery.

Understanding this analogue, we can come to the conclusion that:
1. Tobi does not want his enemies to know his identity.
2. Tobi does not want his allies to know his identity.

But why?

It seems to me that Tobi must be a known figure in the Naruto world. That's not to say he is necessarily someone known to the readers, but he could be a legendary figure known in the Narutoverse. For example, the Gold and Silver Bros and their abilities were known around the world prior to their introduction in the story. Either way, Tobi is indeed a figure known of by living characters, and certainly by all the past members of Akatsuki.

More importantly, it seems reasonable to assume that knowledge of Tobi's identity will put him at a disadvantage, perhaps revealing some weakness. Otherwise he has little reason to conceal himself, unless he's planning on returning to a normal life working at a ramen stand if things don't work out...

Or I could be wrong and Kishi could just be a huge troll.

Concise Summary:

• There must be a reason Tobi wears a mask
• He is known personally or via legend by living characters in the Naruto world (but not necessarily known by us, the readers).
• Knowledge of Tobi's Identity will put him at some sort of disadvantage.

If I am full of shit, please let me know.

Edit:


That's a good question. There's been a lot of speculation about that. Some people have suggested that Kisame may have been put under genjutsu or some other means of concealing his true identity; considering Kisame thought Tobi was Madara, when Tobi's clearly not Madara. Otherwise, why would he be an edo right now?

Nice thread, though I barely dodged that spoiler about amon....

It is obvious for those who can use deductive reasoning. However based on many of the threads I've read on the base, most people cannot. So, meh.

So if I say nice thread, and not this was obvious I am one of those guys?