[Theory] The Next Straw Hat Recruits(Jimbei and Smoker)

[WhistleBlower]

This...is an awesome thread

You must be registered for see images

Simply this. ^ Awesome read and exceptional story telling skills =D

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Simply this. ^ Awesome read and exceptional story telling skills =D

You must be registered for see images

 

[Vandenre1ch]

You must be registered for see images

Woah woah calm down. Don't wanna kill anybody now.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Woah woah calm down. Don't wanna kill anybody now.

You must be registered for see images

 

[beck26]

hello guys, the complete full theory of this is located here, just click the link:

You must be registered for see links

i also have other theories about one piece there which are all connected to one another, check it out if you guys have time.

thanks @thecloudsblacklightning for sharing my theory, i appreciate it.

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

Meh...I've read Becks theory before...personally I agree to some of it but other parts not so much as quite frankly I don't see Smoker leaving the Marines he loves his job despite hating the people he works for not to mention he and Luffy have a sort of similar relationship to the Roger and Garp had.

Now I'm not saying Smoker won't fight alongside Luffy but he'll always be a Marine since he values his men to much he's not going to abandon everyone at the G5 for Luffy. Smoker and Luffy will continue to fight until EoS while teaming up on occasions to defeat a more powerful enemy.

I get some people see Coby as Luffy's Garp but honestly their relationship is no where near the same nor does Coby have that same feeling around him Garp in his day was seen as a demon to the strongest of pirates...I just can't see Coby gaining enough strength to even possibly challenge Luffy until EoS while Smoker now has the power to fight Luffy to relatively even fight.

Same with Tashigi I can't see her joining since she has always been foreshadowed to try rival Zoro but becoming the strongest Swordswoman in the world and personally it wouldn't match well if Zoro and her where in the same crew.

Now in regards to Jimbe I believe he will join when Luffy, Zoro and Sanji have all gotten stronger than him but at the moment he won't join quite yet.

In conclusion the idea of all of these people joining the Straw hat crew to me is a little far fetched as if Smoker and Jimbe joined the crew would be far to overpowered. Not to mention as I stated Smoker has consistently been the one to chase Luffy throughout the Grand Line (Paradise & New World) and I don't see Oda changing that since he seems to be giving Smoker character development in order for him to get stronger to protect his men in the G5.

definitely this.


I'm not all too keen on Beck's theory.

I can't see Tashigi or Smoker leaving the marines.

hello guys, the complete full theory of this is located here, just click the link:

You must be registered for see links

i also have other theories about one piece there which are all connected to one another, check it out if you guys have time.

thanks @thecloudsblacklightning for sharing my theory, i appreciate it.

There you are Beck !!!!!!

 

[sravan]

great theory i don't mind them joining SH's but i want kuzan and batholomeo to join

 

[beck26]

There you are Beck !!!!!!

just spreading the word man, i just want people to read my theories now, that's all....i can't be bothered to argue my theories anymore since all i need to say, i think, is right there. i understand if someone disagree with my theories.

but yeah, if you guys have time, please check my "scaling the red line" series at orojackson.

 

[cryhwks]

just spreading the word man, i just want people to read my theories now, that's all....i can't be bothered to argue my theories anymore since all i need to say, i think, is right there. i understand if someone disagree with my theories.

but yeah, if you guys have time, please check my "scaling the red line" series at orojackson.

I really do like this theory a lot I disagree on some stuff like Sabo dyeing and on another Time Skip.

But as far as Smoker,Tashigi,Jinbei joining the crew I totally agree with you. Especially after seeing all the connections between how many members are recruited in each section. And seeing how they are connected like Zoro and Chopper.

And I agree that Coby is clearly Luffy's Garp not Smoker. Because you can probably safely say that Luffy is much stronger than Smoker at this point because Luffy is more than likely going to be the one that defeats Doflamingo. And Doflamingo ripped apart Smoker like it was nothing.

And so if Smoker isn't Luffy's Garp then what would have been the point of showing how much he and Tashigi have developed? Because Smoker and Tashigi are more developed and focused on more than any other Marine characters.

 

[NarutoWA]

It was nice reading this long written theory. Thanks to beck26 for writing this and you too for sharing over here.

But I believe one will be Momonosuke and I would hate Tashigi joining SHs because she has no distinct qualities, she is just a normal swords-woman who is way weaker than Zoro. Jimbei is almost sure though.

 

[cryhwks]

It was nice reading this long written theory. Thanks to beck26 for writing this and you too for sharing over here.

But I believe one will be Momonosuke and I would hate Tashigi joining SHs because she has no distinct qualities, she is just a normal swords-woman who is way weaker than Zoro. Jimbei is almost sure though.

Why would Momonosuke join and not Kinemon?

 

[beck26]

I really do like this theory a lot I disagree on some stuff like Sabo dyeing and on another Time Skip.

But as far as Smoker,Tashigi,Jinbei joining the crew I totally agree with you. Especially after seeing all the connections between how many members are recruited in each section. And seeing how they are connected like Zoro and Chopper.

And I agree that Coby is clearly Luffy's Garp not Smoker. Because you can probably safely say that Luffy is much stronger than Smoker at this point because Luffy is more than likely going to be the one that defeats Doflamingo. And Doflamingo ripped apart Smoker like it was nothing.

And so if Smoker isn't Luffy's Garp then what would have been the point of showing how much he and Tashigi have developed? Because Smoker and Tashigi are more developed and focused on more than any other Marine characters.

thanks man, i appreciate it.

 

[TheHokage]

I really do like this theory a lot I disagree on some stuff like Sabo dyeing and on another Time Skip.

But as far as Smoker,Tashigi,Jinbei joining the crew I totally agree with you. Especially after seeing all the connections between how many members are recruited in each section. And seeing how they are connected like Zoro and Chopper.

And I agree that Coby is clearly Luffy's Garp not Smoker. Because you can probably safely say that Luffy is much stronger than Smoker at this point because Luffy is more than likely going to be the one that defeats Doflamingo. And Doflamingo ripped apart Smoker like it was nothing.

And so if Smoker isn't Luffy's Garp then what would have been the point of showing how much he and Tashigi have developed? Because Smoker and Tashigi are more developed and focused on more than any other Marine characters.

In fairness Smoker was injured from his fight with Vergo and we've seen Doflamingo school Luffy when they clashed. I think Doflamingo will only get beat by Luffy combined with the help of Law somehow.

 

[Bimbonium]

This was an interesting read.

 

[beck26]

please check my prediction thread at orojackson guys, its the complete version and its not hard to find coz its one of the sticky threads there. thanks

 

[Vandenre1ch]

hello guys, the complete full theory of this is located here, just click the link:

You must be registered for see links

i also have other theories about one piece there which are all connected to one another, check it out if you guys have time.

thanks @thecloudsblacklightning for sharing my theory, i appreciate it.

No problem beck. Any person who calls themselves a OP fan should read your theories.

Btw, I'm Buddha Sengoku on OPB.

 

[beck26]

No problem beck. Any person who calls themselves a OP fan should read your theories.

Btw, I'm Buddha Sengoku on OPB.

oh! thanks Buddha Sengoku!

 

[Vandenre1ch]

oh! thanks Buddha Sengoku!

One more thing. I've sent a couple of messages to KingofLighting and Sawyer7mage on YouTube about your theories hoping they'll reply. So far, only KOL replied saying that he'll read it if he gets the chance but he has alot of stuff on his plate right now. Lets cross our fingers.

 

[beck26]

One more thing. I've sent a couple of messages to KingofLighting and Sawyer7mage on YouTube about your theories hoping they'll reply. So far, only KOL replied saying that he'll read it if he gets the chance but he has alot of stuff on his plate right now. Lets cross our fingers.

oh, thanks man...everythingonepiece also promised me he would do a video of my theories, but thats months away, also, i would like to note that im staying in orojackson now and i dont plan on updating my theories in OPB anytime soon.

the most recent theories and updated ones are ones in orojackson, i love that site coz the mods stickied my thread there and helps me anything in regards to my theories.

(im a very big fan of KoL and ranmyaku jouten, and everythingonepiece)