[Predictions] The Next Straw Hat Member is...

[Tomato God]

1. She isn't Jinbei's student
2. The arc will end very soon after the fights end so that doesn't give him much time to get to know Koala.

1. She learned fish man Karate From Jimbe
2. There will be time for sabo and Luffy to talk before this arc ends.
3. She probably heard about luffy from robin.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

1. She learned fish man Karate From Jimbe
2. There will be time for sabo and Luffy to talk before this arc ends.
3. She probably heard about luffy from robin.

1. There are no scans that say she learned FK from Jinbe nor is it implied
2. They need to go help Sanjis team after they beat Dofla and hes going to be talking to Sabo most of the time. What do you thinks going to happen? "Hi Im Sabo's friend Koala" "Screw every other potential new nakama Im inviting you to join my crew"
3. Pretty much everyone in the world has heard of Luffy.

 

[Tomato God]

1. There are no scans that say she learned FK from Jinbe nor is it implied
2. They need to go help Sanjis team after they beat Dofla and hes going to be talking to Sabo most of the time. What do you thinks going to happen? "Hi Im Sabo's friend Koala" "Screw every other potential new nakama Im inviting you to join my crew"
3. Pretty much everyone in the world has heard of Luffy.

Yea But the world knows them as villainous scum Robin wouldnt hesitate to tell people about the real luffy and I am sure sabo has asked. Once koala Knows how much good they do (which she does) A flash back chapter or two and bam. New nakama.

Hell Oda is giving us a big suprise in the new specail 3Y2D and thats about them being seperated from eachother and luffy's training. The suprise might be new nakama.

TIs not out of the blue she might pull a robin and just join the crew. Plus she knows fish man karate and that makes her good in the water the only thing the straw hats dont have is a helmsman and she could do it with ease cause of her water manipulation and stuff,

And she had to learn it from someone. Jimbe Arlong or FisherTiger. One was dead and the other hates humans.

 

[ultraChalk]

There is 0 possibility that you know what oda is doing.

True, but it's far more likely that she doesn't join.

 

[Tomato God]

True, but it's far more likely that she doesn't join.

Yes infact. But If oda taught us anything its that anything could happen. But you are right. Its far more likely she doesn't. But there are patterns and things that say she will. Plus her dream is far greater than anyone elses on that list.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Yea But the world knows them as villainous scum Robin wouldnt hesitate to tell people about the real luffy and I am sure sabo has asked. Once koala Knows how much good they do (which she does) A flash back chapter or two and bam. New nakama.

Hell Oda is giving us a big suprise in the new specail 3Y2D and thats about them being seperated from eachother and luffy's training. The suprise might be new nakama.

TIs not out of the blue she might pull a robin and just join the crew. Plus she knows fish man karate and that makes her good in the water the only thing the straw hats dont have is a helmsman and she could do it with ease cause of her water manipulation and stuff,

And she had to learn it from someone. Jimbe Arlong or FisherTiger. One was dead and the other hates humans.

So the Revs are going to believe the WG when they say Sabo's brother is evil? She didn't learn FK when she was with the Sun Pirates and she never saw Jinbei after that. Hack probably tought her.

 

[Tomato God]

So the Revs are going to believe the WG when they say Sabo's brother is evil? She didn't learn FK when she was with the Sun Pirates and she never saw Jinbei after that. Hack probably tought her.

No But they have no information to say other wise, and they damn sure dont know how many Islands and dictators and doomsdays the straw hats prevented.
Hack may have taught her. You right. I forgot about them.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

No But they have no information to say other wise, and they damn sure dont know how many Islands and dictators and doomsdays the straw hats prevented.
Hack may have taught her. You right. I forgot about them.

All the info the WG provided about Luffy said that he rescued Robin from Enies Lobby and destroyed it. They also said he caused havoc at MF. None of these two actions would make Luffy look like a bad guy to the Revs. Sabo probably talked about his childhood with Luffy and Ace(unless he's like the SHs and doesn't share any important information about their past or connections with people)so they would have gotten the idea that Luffy is a good guy.

 

[Tomato God]

All the info the WG provided about Luffy said that he rescued Robin from Enies Lobby and destroyed it. They also said he caused havoc at MF. None of these two actions would make Luffy look like a bad guy to the Revs. Sabo probably talked about his childhood with Luffy and Ace(unless he's like the SHs and doesn't share any important information about their past or connections with people)so they would have gotten the idea that Luffy is a good guy.

1. Sabo Ace and Luffy never talk about the past. Cause they don't do it.
2. They may know that luffy isnt a bad guy. But I doubt they realize the extent of it. Every Island they one Do the impossible two they will destroy any form of evil on that island. (all on accident but hey they are like pirate jesus). And If koala's goal is the same as jimbe's and hack and robin told her about Pirate Jesus's Wonder Crew. She may want to go with them. Idk I would if I was her.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

1. Sabo Ace and Luffy never talk about the past. Cause they don't do it.
2. They may know that luffy isnt a bad guy. But I doubt they realize the extent of it. Every Island they one Do the impossible two they will destroy any form of evil on that island. (all on accident but hey they are like pirate jesus). And If koala's goal is the same as jimbe's and hack and robin told her about Pirate Jesus's Wonder Crew. She may want to go with them. Idk I would if I was her.

Actually Ace does, at MF when Luffy showed up Marco said that that is the person that Ace is always talking about.

 

[Tomato God]

Actually Ace does, at MF when Luffy showed up Marco said that that is the person that Ace is always talking about.

Oh.. Well then Yea. She probably double knows about pirate jesus. All the more reason for her to join. If she wants to tear down the slave system. Join Pirate Jesus. Make Fishmen Known as not a threat. Join Pirate jesus. Beat up world nobles. Join Pirate Jesus.
Cause I guarantee that luffy will end up accidentally saving the world. Again.

 

[Skylar Knight]

Surprised people are so concerned with Rebecca, Kyros Law, Bellamy and Voila, but not upset with the possibility of Sugar joining.

The single most dumbest, worst prediction to ever hit my ear drums. If she joins I would drop OP, easily.
Even the thought makes me mad. No offense to the people who want her to join, it's the idea I hate.

Then I'll ask you, did you hate the idea of Robin joining the crew?

Sugar is in many ways similar to Robin - they both fought on the enemy's side, their abilities seemed somewhat unstoppable at first, and their personalities aren't even far from different. Just like Sugar, Robin seemed cold, as if she didn't care about the people around her. She smiled as the rebellion in Alabasta clashed with the royal army. Basically, she was the ideal partner for Crocodile, up to the last chapters of the Alabasta arc.

Now, what's so different about Sugar? We barely know anything about her; not her past, her train of thoughts, nothing. No one knew anything about Robin when she first joined, some even hated the idea of her being a Strawhat, just like you with Sugar. Then her struggles, past, and true personality were revealed, and before we knew it, she was many people's favorite crew member.

Sugar even started to act off when the dwarves cried out for the people, as if she felt sorry for them. It was around here when people started to think of her as a possible candidate, and I don't blame them for it. She looked at them with perhaps the most depressing face I've seen in the series. You can interpret it the way you want, but she's definitely not day dreaming about grapes.

Regardless of my personal opinion about the matter, I am in no way saying she'll join the crew. I have no idea if she will. However, denying the slighest possibility of her joining is ridiculous. From what I've seen and read, I believe her chances are higher than most others. I even find it weird how people consider someone like Rebecca or Kyros the next member.

 

[edward newgate]

Then I'll ask you, did you hate the idea of Robin joining the crew?

Sugar is in many ways similar to Robin - they both fought on the enemy's side, their abilities seemed somewhat unstoppable at first, and their personalities aren't even far from different. Just like Sugar, Robin seemed cold, as if she didn't care about the people around her. She smiled as the rebellion in Alabasta clashed with the royal army. Basically, she was the ideal partner for Crocodile, up to the last chapters of the Alabasta arc.

Now, what's so different about Sugar? We barely know anything about her; not her past, her train of thoughts, nothing. No one knew anything about Robin when she first joined, some even hated the idea of her being a Strawhat, just like you with Sugar. Then her struggles, past, and true personality were revealed, and before we knew it, she was many people's favorite crew member.

Sugar even started to act off when the dwarves cried out for the people, as if she felt sorry for them. It was around here when people started to think of her as a possible candidate, and I don't blame them for it. She looked at them with perhaps the most depressing face I've seen in the series. You can interpret it the way you want, but she's definitely not day dreaming about grapes.

Regardless of my personal opinion about the matter, I am in no way saying she'll join the crew. I have no idea if she will. However, denying the slighest possibility of her joining is ridiculous. From what I've seen and read, I believe her chances are higher than most others. I even find it weird how people consider someone like Rebecca or Kyros the next member.

Not sure what scene you're talking about. Link, please?

Anyhow, one glaring difference between Robin and Sugar is that Robin saved Luffy's life, then he returned it later following Crocodile's defeat.
Sugar did nothing of that sort. She's furious at Ussop to the point of randomly turning her own men into toys.

She is not joining.

 

[Skylar Knight]

Not sure what scene you're talking about. Link, please?

Anyhow, one glaring difference between Robin and Sugar is that Robin saved Luffy's life, then he returned it later following Crocodile's defeat.
Sugar did nothing of that sort. She's furious at Ussop to the point of randomly turning her own men into toys.

She is not joining.

Again, you interpret it the way you want:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I really don't see your point here. Robin was an exemplary villain up to the final chapters of the Alabasta arc. She smiled as the rebellion and the royal army attacked each other, she, if I remember correctly, put huge spikes through king Cobra's hands, and she attacked Tashigi and the marines out of glaring anger. Sugar can easily go through such a change as well. After Doflamingo defeat and possible arrest, there's a chance that she and a couple of others will be able to escape.

Even someone like Franky was hated at first. He beat up Usopp and stole the crew's money, resulting in a personal conflict among the Strawhats. Then, obviously, he had a change of heart, or perhaps people just started to see him differently from chapter to chapter. The point is that you don't have to be the ideal Strawhat to be able to join the crew, and, if you ask me, Sugar is a good example of someone who could change her ways, but perhaps that's just me.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Bartolomeo is my number one favourite atm.

Kyros and Law won't join, they would mess up the monster trio.

Where did you get that part about Sugar being loyal to Viola? O____o