[Predictions] The Next Straw Hat Member is...

[Chubby Sage]

I'm aware there is already a thread about which'll be the next Nakama for the straw hats but I found it essential to make another thread, since i will be going in depth of the matter. Please read, I took my time on this thread :T_T:

Now we all know whats needed for someone to be considered "Straw hat Material"

1. Emotional Background : we all know that each character in the crew has their own emotional story.

2. Ambition : All the straw hats have a goal in life in which they want to achieve.

3. Character/Design : all the strawhats have their own unique character ranging from hair color to mentality.

Note: the strawhat crew is balanced, so we need a character that is on par with a crew mate and has their own specialty below the captain to avoid power level strikes.

now the available options of possibilities

Rebecca :certainly she may seem like the next strawhat but she validates some point but not all. at first she has sort of an emotional background, her mother was killed in front of her and struggled to survive being hated upon by everyone, her theme can be "outcast" like chopper's was "loneliness" Sanji's was "Survival" etc. Now for her ambition, her ambition is short lived due to the fact that hers is only to take down Doffy which i can see happening in the arc itself. as for character/design she is unique; she is a gladiator with pink hair, only downside is (for now) is that she doesn't have the will to fight/kill (which is unique in a way (her fighting style).

Note: Luffy loves unique people, talking skeletons, a cyborg etc I can see her joining for being a Gladiator + she has pink hair, Sanji: Blond. Zoro: Green. Nami: Orange. Franky: Blue. Chopper: Brown. Robin?Luffy/Usopp/Brooke: Black but with distinct hairstyles (Afro, frizzy, puffy, and Ash Ketchum Style).

Bartolomeo : alright now Bartolomeo is pretty cool but also pretty hax with his devil fruit but nonetheless he has a limit on how many barriers he could make, he can play out as the defense of the straw hat crew. His personality is fanboyish but moral, he plays as a troll but at the same time brings conformity and comedy he would be a nice addition. He doesn't seem to have a emotional background (possibly not yet shown) and does not yet have a theme. his appearance is pretty unique being all punk rockish with lime green hair, we still need a bit more info on him to make him a big possibility though.

Kyros : a small possibility, he lost a leg and would be cool to have a one legged gladiator on the crew he has sort of a story linked to Rebecca but i can see him being the king of dressrosa after so I doubt he'd be coming.

Ucy: the bull will be pretty unique, a demon bull which is an full animal, can be chopper's friend a luffy's little pet on the crew, but then again it lacks character and appearance, I can only see it as an Ally.

Trafalgar Law I can see this guy returning to Zou only to see his crew murdered by Kaido oor something (possibility) or allying to Luffy to the extent he feels comfortable in the crew (would be cool if he was 1st Division Commander) he has an amazing Devil Fruit (My Favorite) he also has a cool design with tattoos and a fuzzy hat, he has a background story (that has yet to be seen) and a personality different from the crew. But his ambition is short lived as he wants to find the One Piece as well and primarily wants to get revenge on Doffy.

Bellamy Don't hate me for this, but I would love to have this guy in the crew, it would bring a balance in power in the crew since his ability isn't too haxxed, but he's constantly been betrayed by Doffy and I can see him joining Luffy and Praising him instead. I can just imagine him being very Loyal to Luffy and the crew after they show Doffy who's boss. Once Doffy's crew is defeated, Bellamy will have no one to follow and will most likely be accepted by Luffy
he looks ripped and pretty cool, out of all the possibilities I find him joining

Sugar I honestly don't know why people are considering her to join, I don't think she'll ever join but it's still a possibility (According to NB) her power is too OP but she's unique since she's a young old lady (ya i doesn't make sense but you know what I mean" she seems to be held hostage by Doffy but still remains loyal similar to Viola.

Viola/Violet I dunno if she'll join but it would be nice, Sanji will find true love, and the strawhats will have brains on their side, she's not exactly an offensive type though she has some skills worth noting. Her Background is linked to Kyros and Rebecca so idk.

yeah my hands are hurting from writing this so I'll stop here, I'll put up a Poll on what you guys think. I appreciate it if you read.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Eliminate Rebecca, Ucy, Kyros, and Law. Rebecca is a pacifist and she just met her dad again after 10 years I doubt she would just leave him, same for Kyros. Ucy is just a bull. Law already has a crew.

 

[ShiroShonen]

You must be registered for see images

 

[silmarill]

some unknown person aside from Jinbei

 

[U mAd]

barto will give balance and power.
rebecca:they don't need her.
bellamy:he sucks
and where is jinbei on the poll
law:alredy has a crew
violet:her power can be usefull but sanji and robin have enough brain power and knowledge.

 

[edward newgate]

I don't understand how people can even contemplate the idea of Rebbeca/Kyros/Law/Viola joining the crew.

Rebbeca has just reunited with her father, grandfather and aunt after 10 years of suffering. Do you really think she will leave them to join the crew, especially when Luffy hasn't even shown any interest in her joining? Do you really think Kyors will leave his duty to his family and country to join a crew of pirates he just met? WHY? Same for Viola. Do you honestly think Oda will ****ing kill Law's crew just to have him join the Strawhats? They were established as rivals.

Now, I like Bellamy, but I don't see him joining the Strawhats. Rather, I'd like him to join Law's crew along with Caesar. They have nowhere to go, and I can't see Caesar just taken away to prison after this. Bellamy is similar to Law, so I'd love it if we see him in Law's flashback and establish their connection.

I like Bart, but he has his own crew as well.

 

[ultraChalk]

Surprised people are so concerned with Rebecca, Kyros Law, Bellamy and Voila, but not upset with the possibility of Sugar joining.

The single most dumbest, worst prediction to ever hit my ear drums. If she joins I would drop OP, easily.
Even the thought makes me mad. No offense to the people who want her to join, it's the idea I hate.

 

[Love Cook]

I think Rebecca doesn't have any more depth to her character and fighting style to be part of the Sh's for 10 more years. I think Violet/Kyros/Barto can all make interesting additions to the crew.

And I hope Franky or Usopp will make Kyros a cool leg.

 

[Jimmy page]

None
/10char

 

[Mephew D Kensei]

None of those pple r joining, I wld put Momo as a better candidate than all of these pple but even for him I still have my doubts.

Rebecca n Kyros r auto out of the running for me with their reunion thing going on I doubt either wld just wanna get up and take leave after just being reunited(its no diff from putting Riku Dold in the running for me).

Viola might have the maybe pple wont understand her joining Doffy so she may just as well continue being a pirate but she just isnt that unique to me to b a strawhat(though in the Tijuana family she is the better candidate), while her power isnt something I want to have to b an issue coz id she becomes an on ship spoiler the it wld b boring and if she doesnt warn the crew of stuff we wld start with the arse-pull comments.

Barto wld b more usefull as an ally.

I just dont see Bellamy being the kinda guy who wld worry ober Nami, Robin or Ussop when the SH r in trouble coz remember him from his introduction(i know pple change and all but franky is enough for me) and remember sh operate like a close nit family. Him and Barto have bounties that wld complicate things in the group dynamic.

Sugar just has a far too convinient power so much so that i wld prefer Perona over her of either had a chanve as an SH.

Ucy isnt even worth mentioning.

Law is too high profile to b under Luffy, Zoro is enough to support Luffy(and make it possible for all those whose the first mate chaos threads and rhe sh line up L≥Z>>S≤Z<L threads.

#Momo4apprentice.

 

[Olorin]

I wanted to just write Big Mom and Fuji as a joke again as I do on many of this clone threads but at least some effort has been put in this time

 

[Tomato God]

I demand to know why koala isnt on that list!

 

[ultraChalk]

I demand to know why koala isnt on that list!

There is 0 possibility of her joining

 

[Tomato God]

There is 0 possibility of her joining

There is 0 possibility that you know what oda is doing.

 

[TRE MERCER]

Bart might just join imo.

 

[MugiwaraBoy]

Didn't read any posts, but Koala will most likely be a new member. (that is if Jimbei isn't coming to Luffy right now).

All we need right now is a Fishman Karate user, (Koala, Jimbei) a Logia & there has been theories on a giant from Elbaf.

 

[Tomato God]

Didn't read any posts, but Koala will most likely be a new member. (that is if Jimbei isn't coming to Luffy right now).

This guy gets it!

 

[silmarill]

This guy gets it!

No he doesn't lol
There is a good reason why koala is with the revs and not in a Pirate crew.
She was a victim first hand of some of the dark aspects of the WG
She was a slave in Mariejois and knows all to well of the discrimination of the fishman to give some example
She obviously joined the Revs because she believes they can change those things, she aint just going to abandon all that and go on some adventure

 

[Tomato God]

No he doesn't lol
There is a good reason why koala is with the revs and not in a Pirate crew.
She was a victim first hand of some of the dark aspects of the WG
She was a slave in Mariejois and knows all to well of the discrimination of the fishman to give some example
She obviously joined the Revs because she believes they can change those things, she aint just going to abandon all that and go on some adventure

thats what everyone says till luffy make them
plus she is jimbie's student and that bond usurps the bond with the revs. And Jimbe would die for Luffy. Infact he might die.
Plus The straw hats break things all the time. Death ships. Dictators. Whole governments. And I am sure by the end of the series that luffy will have broken the slave caste system. Cause ya know he's luffy
So if you really want a dream to come true join luffy's dream crew... Damn that rhymed so it has to be factual/

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

thats what everyone says till luffy make them
plus she is jimbie's student and that bond usurps the bond with the revs. And Jimbe would die for Luffy. Infact he might die.
Plus The straw hats break things all the time. Death ships. Dictators. Whole governments. And I am sure by the end of the series that luffy will have broken the slave caste system. Cause ya know he's luffy
So if you really want a dream to come true join luffy's dream crew... Damn that rhymed so it has to be factual/

1. She isn't Jinbei's student
2. The arc will end very soon after the fights end so that doesn't give him much time to get to know Koala.