[Discussion] The Heart that Ceaser stabbed

[Sherlock.]

After reading a few Theories on the base I think Monet is alive.... But Oda Sensei showed us Ceaser stabbing a heart which Ceaser thought was Law's but Law said it was Monet's heart.... Now this leads to the question that if indeed Monet is alive then whose heart was it that Law stabbed.... I think it was Vergo's heart....

Of course I'm assuming this -
1.Monet was working with Law from the start.
2.Vergo had a kind of forgetful nature.... I think Law and Monet took advantage of this weakness of his and at some point of time Law gave back Monet her heart and placed Vergo's heart in place of his own....

Sry I'm being too lazy right now as to not put Manga pages and all....

I just wanted to discuss this possibility with those who already are conviced by the idea of Monet being alive from various Threads we have seen in all past months.... Monet most probably dropped unconscious due to her injuries.... =D =D

So what do you guys say..?? Could it be his heart..?? I think it was his heart.... =D =D

EDIT - Also Law said something like - "Those who do good things will get good things in return" when he and Smoker were talking about her....

If she really is the kind of vamp she was potrayed to be till now.... Then Law could have said something like - "She got what she deserved." :dunno: :dunno:

 

[Punk Hazard]

It was Monet's. She was about to blow up herself for Joker, and when Caesar stabbed it, she bled from her mouth and collapsed. It would be interesting for her to be Law's ally, but it wouldn't make sense. Law has been too close to death for the comfort of an ally.

 

[Anduril]

Monet is dead. Get over it.

 

[Sherlock.]

Monet is dead. Get over it.

I used to think the same.... But have a look at this Thread Bro.... It's kinda interesting....

You must be registered for see links

 

[ziggyZ]

Monet is dead. Get over it.

Not confirmed. Get over it.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

It was Monets heart. But Pell survived an explosion on a similar scale to the atom bomb. So who's to say Monet isn't alive?

 

[Sherlock.]

It was Monets heart. But Pell survived an explosion on a similar scale to the atom bomb. So who's to say Monet isn't alive?

May be.... But it would be cool even if it wasn't hers but Vergo's.... =D =D

 

[Punk Hazard]

Monet can't be Law's ally. She just let Vergo assault him.

She was also about to blow herself up for Joker.

She showed no concern when Law was about to killed by Shinokuni.

She was about to legit kill Nami, Robin and the kids.

While Oda could make a very very interesting plot point involving Monet being Law's ally because of that last one, it isn't likely she's ally with Law.

 

[Aertes]

I used to think the same.... But have a look at this Thread Bro.... It's kinda interesting....

You must be registered for see links

That panel with the attack on the ocean doesn't make much sense to me.
Monet is a DF user, even for foreshadowing it creates a contrast. How can an DF attack work on the ocean??

OT: It won't be weird if Monet managed to survive, I mean Pell...He survived a direct explosion, I just haven't seen anything very convincing to believe in her survival.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Idk.
I do think she was alive.
But if your theory was what happened why would Law lie to Smoker and say it was Monets?
Why didn't he just say it was Vergos?

 

[Sherlock.]

Idk.
I do think she was alive.
But if your theory was what happened why would Law lie to Smoker and say it was Monets?
Why didn't he just say it was Vergos?

He probably didn't want anybody to know of his affiliation to her.... I mean she had been fighting with SHs and If he would have told Smoker it wouldn't do any good.... Cause if Smoker might have mentioned her as an ally of Law and SH's in his report.... Knowing Doffy and his contacts Doffy would have got the info and Law's plan might have been spoiled....

 

[Dr Strangelove]

He probably didn't want anybody to know of his affiliation to her.... I mean she had been fighting with SHs and If he would have told Smoker it wouldn't do any good.... Cause if Smoker might have mentioned her as an ally of Law and SH's in his report.... Knowing Doffy and his contacts Doffy would have got the info and Law's plan might have been spoiled....

Ye. That is possible.
Just seems like a weird thing for Oda to do. I doubt they are allied. They might be allied later but they definitely weren't on PH.

 

[Sherlock.]

Ye. That is possible.
Just seems like a weird thing for Oda to do. I doubt they are allied. They might be allied later but they definitely weren't on PH.

Who knows.... But she mostly is alive cause if not those rabbits around Thousand Sunny wouldn't make any sense.... =D =D

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Who knows.... But she mostly is alive cause if not those rabbits around Thousand Sunny wouldn't make any sense.... =D =D

Indeed.
Plus when Oda was asked about them in an SBS he didn't answer the question.

 

[Sherlock.]

Indeed.
Plus when Oda was asked about them in an SBS he didn't answer the question.

Yea I remember reading that.... He completely went off track and joked about something else.... =D =D

 

[Hexuze]

Monet can't be Law's ally. She just let Vergo assault him.

She was also about to blow herself up for Joker.

She showed no concern when Law was about to killed by Shinokuni.

She was about to legit kill Nami, Robin and the kids.

While Oda could make a very very interesting plot point involving Monet being Law's ally because of that last one, it isn't likely she's ally with Law.

Don't forget Mihawk's words...
[video=youtube;g7RQVSbxezA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7RQVSbxezA[/video]

I think she might join the SH's later on, probably when Enel/the whole moon thing is introduced.

but yeah she may not be Law's ally

 

[Punk Hazard]

Don't forget Mihawk's words...
[video=youtube;g7RQVSbxezA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7RQVSbxezA[/video]

I think she might join the SH's later on, probably when Enel/the whole moon thing is introduced.

but yeah she may not be Law's ally

Ok, what does that have to do with me saying she can't be Law's ally.

 

[ziggyZ]

Monet can't be Law's ally. She just let Vergo assault him.

She was also about to blow herself up for Joker.

She showed no concern when Law was about to killed by Shinokuni.

She was about to legit kill Nami, Robin and the kids.

While Oda could make a very very interesting plot point involving Monet being Law's ally because of that last one, it isn't likely she's ally with Law.

Hence I theorized long ago that she will be the next nakama of the SH's.


Why?:
-She is a female (Oda said the next one of the two nakama will be a female).
-She is am impressive user of a strong Logia fruit (SH's need a Logia-user).
-She has knowledge in astronomy (this is key 'cause logically speaking, space will play a huge role later in the story).
-She is unique.
-She doesn't look remotely similar to any of the two SH girls.

Now, how will she become their next nakama?:
>She has shown to be very, very loyal to her captain (something all SH's posses deep within themselves).
>Luffy will realize this aspect of her.
>During an event on Dressrosa, she will see the immense loyalty the crew has for their captain.
>Something happens and Luffy will subconsciously use his greatest attribute to persuade her into becoming a SH.