The family theme of Gaiden will not be ruined if Sakura is Salada's mom

[Natsu Shazneel]

So all the lessons you learned applied to you?, you learn not to steal, does that mean you attempted to steal before?

Yes all the lessons I learned applied to me. If I learn not to steal I won't learn to steal in the future. Rather I did it before or not is not of any of my concern. But your example of this is very poor. It has nothing to do with Sarada.

 

[Sasuke tyeezy]

Not every lesson you learn applies to you, that's the point

That is obviously not the point…:|.

Also I believe Kishi purposely did this to serve SasuKari & SasuSaku, so if she was Sakura's child he would lose revenue, however slight that might be, its still money.

 

[Sasuke tyeezy]

Not every lesson you learn applies to you, that's the point

That is obviously not the point…:|.

Also I believe Kishi purposely did this to serve SasuKari & SasuSaku, so if she was Sakura's child he would lose revenue, however slight that might be, its still money.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Yes all the lessons I learned applied to me. If I learn not to steal I won't learn to steal in the future. Rather I did it before or not is not of any of my concern. But your example of this is very poor. It has nothing to do with Sarada.

Um there's some stuff that you already know or will not happen to you in your life that someone might be trying to teach you, salada learned a lesson about genetics not being a factor about being a parent, even if Sakura turns out to be her blood mother, she still learned the lesson regardless

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

Um there's some stuff that you already know or will not happen to you in your life that someone might be trying to teach you, salada learned a lesson about genetics not being a factor about being a parent, even if Sakura turns out to be her blood mother, she still learned the lesson regardless

Why would she need to learn this lesson if Sakura is really the blood related mother? Does she have anyone else raising her besides Sakura? How does this have anything to do with her life?

 

[Endles Waltz]

Why would she need to learn this lesson if Sakura is really the blood related mother? Does she have anyone else raising her besides Sakura? How does this have anything to do with her life?

Because through this lesson she will announce her dream of becoming Hokage, and having the whole village as her family to protect, especially those who actually need it.

 

[senjusana]

After all this drama, if Kishi says blood>bond, then its ruined.

 

[Endles Waltz]

After all this drama, if Kishi says blood>bond, then its ruined.

Kishi could have Sakura be the mother, and still maintain his bond>blood theme. Chapters 8 and 9 will not be erased from existence just because of that. :lol

 

[Legendary Saiyan]

It actually will ruin for us since it's supposed to be about said genetics.

 

[senjusana]

Kishi could have Sakura be the mother, and still maintain his bond>blood theme. Chapters 8 and 9 will not be erased from existence just because of that. :lol

What is the point of bringing Karin and Dna test into the picture when Sakura is the actual mother? In a short series like Gaiden, its a waste of panel if the issue isn't resolved. Also if Sarada needs to understand that bond>blood, there are plenty of other ways to show it than bringing Karin into the picture.

I also believe that even if Sakura isn't the blood mother, she has done everything that an actual mother does. So if Sarada is Karin's, I would still consider her as Sakura's daughter. Since she is what that an actual mother is.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Why would she need to learn this lesson if Sakura is really the blood related mother? Does she have anyone else raising her besides Sakura? How does this have anything to do with her life?

It's just like when you learn about stuff in school, you might use that knowledge later in life or it might not apply to you, either way you still learned it, the same with salada, Sakura might be her blood mother, she'll still learn about an important life lesson and like endless said it could help her with her hokage dream

 

[SPIRTofleo]

What is the point of bringing Karin and Dna test into the picture when Sakura is the actual mother? In a short series like Gaiden, its a waste of panel if the issue isn't resolved. Also if Sarada needs to understand that bond>blood, there are plenty of other ways to show it than bringing Karin into the picture.

I also believe that even if Sakura isn't the blood mother, she has done everything that an actual mother does. So if Sarada is Karin's, I would still consider her as Sakura's.

What was the point of Sasuke being evil, if he was just gonna turn good in the end?

 

[Endles Waltz]

What is the point of bringing Karin and Dna test into the picture when Sakura is the actual mother? In a short series like Gaiden, its a waste of panel if the issue isn't resolved. Also if Sarada needs to understand that bond>blood, there are plenty of other ways to show it than bringing Karin into the picture.

I also believe that even if Sakura isn't the blood mother, she has done everything that an actual mother does. So if Sarada is Karin's, I would still consider her as Sakura's.

How else would you have Sarada understand that bonds>blood?

It was a great set up, having her suspicions climax with the DNA test and getting angry about it, only to accept it and prove her maturity and portray the lesson, then ultimately reveal the truth that will make her happy.

 

[SasuKushiDP]

Because through this lesson she will announce her dream of becoming Hokage, and having the whole village as her family to protect, especially those who actually need it.

^ This

 

[senjusana]

What was the point of Sasuke being evil, if he was just gonna turn good in the end?

Sasuke wasn't evil as long as his dream was to kill Itachi. Since it was a genuine intention to take revenge after all he has gone through. But after he learnt the truth about his brother, he wanted to question this system of being a shinobi.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Sasuke wasn't evil as long as his dream was to kill Itachi. Since it was a genuine intention to take revenge after all he has gone through. But after he learnt the truth about his brother, he wanted to question this system of being a shinobi.

Lol I kno, I was just giving an example about what you said about "what was the point of brining up karin and Dna"

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

It's just like when you learn about stuff in school, you might use that knowledge later in life or it might not apply to you, either way you still learned it, the same with salada, Sakura might be her blood mother, she'll still learn about an important life lesson and like endless said it could help her with her hokage dream

Dude that Hokage dream never even came into fruition yet, so don't even bother with that. What we are discussing is what happen up until now. You have a point in that we do tend to learn some things that may apply to us later in our lives. But you still need to take into consideration that this was used as a main plot device to move the plot forward. We are not talking about real life. We are talking about fiction. How does a main point of bond>dna stand, when in the end you will say dna was indeed the most important thing that determines a parent?

So in other words Kishi was only going to defend this point in order to go against it in the end.

 

[YoDiggetySam]

Not every lesson you learn applies to you, that's the point

[video=youtube;gZ8w4vVaOL8]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZ8w4vVaOL8[/video]

 

[Gein]

It was ruined when Kishi decided to troll with the DNA test.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Dude that Hokage dream never even came into fruition yet, so don't even bother with that. What we are discussing is what happen up until now. You have a point in that we do tend to learn some things that may apply to us later in our lives. But you still need to take into consideration that this was used as a main plot device to move the plot forward. We are not talking about real life. We are talking about fiction. How does a main point of bond>dna stand, when in the end you will say dna was indeed the most important thing that determines a parent?

So in other words Kishi was only going to defend this point in order to go against it in the end.

The same could be said about Naruto starting from the bottom, when truth be told, he was the reincarnation of a really powerful ninja, which was ashura, people say kishimoto ruined the theme of Naruto with that, others have a different agruement, it's a matter of opinion I guess