The biggest plot hole in Naruto - Revealed

[Flakez]

Yes clones are weaker, i never said otherwise. But they ARE CONTROLLED BY THE USER, and the DO SEE WHAT THE CASTER SEES!

Post me a scan to prove this.

When the clone is killed/released the original user learns the info they learned. There's no shared vision and the original caster cannot control them.

 

[Melania]

I could say the same about Limbo and Inner Sakura. lol

 

[mr opportunist]

clones are duplications of the caster, the paths are more of one person being split up into individual bodies

 

[bottlewave]

Wrong wrong wrong! Read the manga again!

reread the chapter when Kakashi played rock, paper, sissor with Naruto's clone.

 

[NukaCola]

I could say the same about Limbo and Inner Sakura. lol

It's pretty obvious that inner Sakura it's just a mental disorder Lol

 

[Melania]

It's pretty obvious that inner Sakura it's just a mental disorder Lol

Oh I know that, but he's taking things so seriously. He needs to lighten up. And for all we know it could have been Kishi's inspiration for that later on.

 

[SageOfTheTenPaths]

Post me a scan to prove this.

When the clone is killed/released the original user learns the info they learned. There's no shared vision and the original caster cannot control them.

"A characteristic that is unique to the Shadow Clone Technique is that any experience the clones gain during their existence is transferred to the user once they are dispersed. This makes the technique ideal for spying, since the user can simply send a clone to spy on a target, then have the clone disperse itself without returning, to pass the information back to the user.[5] Similarly, because they are clones of the original, any chakra that the clone possesses will return to the original after being dispelled.[6] Conversely, the reverse is also true and the original is still able to manipulate the chakra of the clones.[7]"

 

[holtaa]

Lol no, you are forgetting something. Remember when he was training towards rasenshuriken? Kakashi took naruto's clone into the forest, scissors paper rocked him (winner had to shout food or something) and naruto found out he owed Kakashi AFTER the clone disappeared. Thats how he trained so fast, he gained the experience and knowledge AFTER his clones popped. Sorry

 

[Stacks]

- Naruto can't see what his clones see.
- Naruto cannot control his clones. He can only formulate a plan in his before he creates them. Since the clones are copies of him they execute his plan.

This right here completely makes your thread useless.

 

[holtaa]

Also, the paths were made up of individuals being manipulated by his chakra through those black bolts.

A shadow clone is a complete copy of an individual that to some extent, acts on its own

 

[Flakez]

Conversely, the reverse is also true and the original is still able to manipulate the chakra of the clones.[7]"

This quote refers to this scan.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

He controls the chakra distribution, not the clones' movements.

 

[NukaCola]

he's taking things so seriously. He needs to lighten up.

I agree, he seems really hostile today.

 

[Melania]

I agree, he seems really hostile today.

Cant say I blame him, I'm more composed but I'm in a really bad mood today, like volcano ready to erupt sort of mood.

 

[Vapid]

This isn't a plot hole...

 

[Ultimateone]

pain is able to link the vision of his paths, naruto cannot look through the eye's of his clones. it is not until they are dispersed that he experienced what they did. also he does not control them. what happens is he already has a plan then makes the clones. the clones are essentially him and thus will do his plan as he would. the downside is they are easily dispersed and thus the advantage of the paths come in. the chakra within said clones are also limited by how much the user distributes between them.

 

[NukaCola]

Cant say I blame him, I'm more composed but I'm in a really bad mood today, like volcano ready to erupt sort of mood.

Kudos to you for keeping your mood in line.
It's really sad to watch somebody lash out just because someone disagrees with you. I think he snap from yesterday Hiruzen treads

 

[Melania]

Kudos to you for keeping your mood in line.
It's really sad to watch somebody lash out just because someone disagrees with you. I think he snap from yesterday Hiruzen treads

That had me near breaking too. Way too many threads like that lately.

 

[ShiroT]

Naruto doesn't control them and he can't see what they see.

this

/thread

lmao nice try

 

[DoubleKamui]

You must be registered for see images

 

[ShiroT]

Yes clones are weaker, i never said otherwise. But they ARE CONTROLLED BY THE USER, and the DO SEE WHAT THE CASTER SEES!

no they even explained it that when the clone dies naruto gets all the info it had. they did a whole experiment where his and kakashi's clone went into the forest and played rock paper scissors. naruto did not know who won until after his clone disappeared. had he been seeing what he clone was doing he would already have known. . . .