The 2nd & Tobi respectively~

[ccm30]

So like, I got to thinking: what if Tobi were an edo from the Second, from when he died; as we are told that if the edo summoner dies - the edo puppet is too forever walk the land of the living...

But let's he's not, and change the topic with:

we've been neglected being shown who the second edo'd... (doubt he edo'd the first, but that'd be the best bet, as no other ninja of that era were no doubt worth edo'ing, lol) No ninja come to mind may have been worth edo'ing at least that comes to mind... o.o; Could explain why Tobi isn't all decrepit since he's been around for some decades... (Unless someone of intelligence can enlighten us as to how old he *may* be; in the realms of between 40-50...?

I am sure Tobi's not the 2nd's edo, as my disclaimer

 

[Photon]

the second labeled edo tensei a kinjutsu so he did not use it.

 

[hiitz]

i don't really believe what people say about tobi until it's revealed in the manga
+repp anyways

 

[PaperHERO]

When Tobi was striked by the 4th, his arm did not deteriorate like an Edo and didn't regenerate on spot like an Edo would have.

 

[2pops]

When Tobi was striked by the 4th, his arm did not deteriorate like an Edo and didn't regenerate on spot like an Edo would have.

cuz maybe it was not perfect. even oro's aint perfect as kabutos.

 

[ccm30]

When Tobi was striked by the 4th, his arm did not deteriorate like an Edo and didn't regenerate on spot like an Edo would have.

Good eye! +rep for useful intel.

@Hiitz: Moot point now we got intel from PaperHERO, (tho I wasn't suggesting whom he could be; just that WHAT he could be )titter

@Photon: tensei a Kinjutsu you say... hm... Wonder what the point was to create a Jutsu never to use it... Sounds suspicious to me... (leads one to believe Kishi will eventually get around to a back story about the Second now, doesn't it) :3

Edit:

cuz maybe it was not perfect. even oro's aint perfect as kabutos.

This makes sense to me.. I don't recall Oro's Edo version regen... Stands to reason that the Second's was less-than-Oro's version...

Hm! +rep!

 

[Ngylle]

yeah