Suigetsu vs. Jūgo! Who would win?

[Hatsumomo]

They already begun to fight once, only stopped by Sasuke who threatened them with killing them both, but what if would Sasuke didn't interfere?

 

[Curse Mark]

Juugo could win. Depends on distance, intel, whether or not they're in character etc etc

 

[Transcendence]

Probably Suigetsu because of the variation of his techniques and his clans derived abilities (Liquification for example). We haven't seen much from Juugo combat wise and his berserk outbreaks are easily countered when Suigetsu decides to liquify. That same ability (albeit when he was merged with water) allowed him to tank Hachibi's Bijuudama. Juugo pales in comparison.

 

[Curse Mark]

Probably Suigetsu because of the variation of his techniques and his clans derived abilities (Liquification for example). We haven't seen much from Juugo combat wise and his berserk outbreaks are easily countered when Suigetsu decides to liquify. That same ability (albeit when he was merged with water) allowed him to tank Hachibi's Bijuudama. Juugo pales in comparison.

He didn't tank shit. He was near death.

 

[Draegod]

Suigetsu already defeated and almost killed Juugo. Its a bad match up