Strongest Shinobi under the same circumstances

[Narutobirama]

Assuming all characters were placed in bodies that are completely the same, they all had equal speed, strength, amount of chakra and stamina, which character would be the strongest? They don't have any Jutsu and they can't learn any. The same goes for muscle memory, chakra control and other abilities that rely on body memorizing techniques and training by repeating some moves, they don't keep it.

Assume the only thing they would have left is themselves, but in a different body.

They all start alone equally far from each other. Their goal is to survive and kill as many other Shinobi. They don't have any goals for revenge against any person. Since they are in bodies that are the same, they can't recognize each other.

The area is a huge forest.

In my opinion, the list of strongest Shinobi in no order would be

Tobirama
Madara
Minato
Obito
Itachi
Naruto
Sasuke
Hashirama

Which Shinobi would do the best in your opinion?

 

[Banisher]

They would be equal.

 

[Madara the Solo King]

Madara would solo everyone in that forest.

 

[Sasori]

Does this even make sense.

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

How would they beat each other if they're equal? As this also counts as intelligence, besides even when one would rate the character they would make preconceived notions about whom is stronger making this thread about equality bias to the core.

 

[LuckyMan]

I don't think you know what you're talking about.

 

[Narutobirama]

How would they beat each other if they're equal? As this also counts as intelligence, besides even when one would rate the character they would make preconceived notions about whom is stronger making this thread about equality bias to the core.

They keep their intelligence, knowledge, experience, will, memories and other things. Just not physical abilities.

 

[Lyke]

itachi neg diff

 

[Sasuke tyeezy]

If they don't have any memory of any techniques and identical chakra pool, speed, & strength they are all equal, nothing separates them into tiers.

 

[-immortal-]

Madara itachi sasuke and tobirama come to farest for sure

 

[Narutobirama]

If they don't have any memory of any techniques and identical chakra pool, speed, & strength they are all equal, nothing separates them into tiers.

Well, they still keep their intelligence, knowledge, will and personality. They just don't have any advantage in terms of physical abilities.

 

[dark legion]

Does this even make sense.

Nope. how can someone be stronger if both have same capacity, they have no goals or intentions? it would be like which of 2 exact Robots with same abilities and same material is better.

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

They keep their intelligence, knowledge, experience, will, memories and other things. Just not physical abilities.

Then you'd logically have to include muscle memory, how can they even retain experience if they don't even retain their abilities nor do they remotely have jutsus????? And wouldn't that obscure the entire equality notion? Then it's not a battle of strength but a battle of wits, the thread is still bias as this is a battle of pure intelligence and wots, and the fact that they retain will is ludicrous, will would actually ostracize the whole equality physically thing. And memories of what? Last I check they don't know each other, have no jutsu, nor do they retain muscle memory sooooooooo.....

 

[Math42]

The intelligent individuals will prevail.... However, all the individuals that thou hast listed are intelligent.

 

[LuckyMan]

Then you'd logically have to include muscle memory, how can they even retain experience if they don't even retain their abilities nor do they remotely have jutsus????? And wouldn't that obscure the entire equality notion? Then it's not a battle of strength but a battle of wits, the thread is still bias as this is a battle of pure intelligence and wots, and the fact that they retain will is ludicrous, will would actually ostracize the whole equality physically thing. And memories of what? Last I check they don't know each other, have no jutsu, nor do they retain muscle memory sooooooooo.....

Like I said, not even the OP knows what the heck he's talking about.

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

Nope. how can someone be stronger if both have same capacity, they have no goals or intentions? it would be like which of 2 exact Robots with same abilities and same material is better.

Terminator 3 disagrees with this

 

[Megax Rocker7]

Where's gai? he is basically the most skilled tajutsu user he should be up there, even the strongest maybe.

 

[Narutobirama]

Nope. how can someone be stronger if both have same capacity, they have no goals or intentions? it would be like which of 2 exact Robots with same abilities and same material is better.

But they are not exactly the same. Some characters will still be arrogant, some will be loud, some will kill quietly from behind, some will attack directly, some will hide,...

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

Where's gai? he is basically the most skilled tajutsu user he should be up there, even the strongest maybe.

They're all "equal" physically remember? Also they retain no muscle memory so...

 

[King of the Heavens]

if everything was the same then they'd be the same as well!