[Discussion] Straw hats vs The Whitebeard Commanders

[Tomato God]

Luffy VS Marco

Zoro VS Vista

Sanji VS Jozu

Robin vs Blamenco

Franky Vs Curiel

brook Vs Speed Jiru

Chopper Vs Atmos

Nami Vs Haruta

Usopp vs Izo

 

[loj]

Mugiwara no ichimi wins.

 

[Zavage10]

Whitebeard commanders easily... It is far to early for this kind of comparison.

 

[Souji]

The Straw Hats aren't Yonko crew level. I see no matchup here where the Straw Hats win, although Vista vs. Zoro would be pretty close.

 

[ANiMUS]

Marco seems invincible Lol Luffy might be able to handle him, but I don't know for how long because of the constant regeneration.
Zoro might be able to handle Vista (possibly), but the rest of this stuff is ridiculous.

 

[I'm stupid real stupid]

I feel Marco alone is enough to solo the Crew

 

[Olorin]

Marco is imo stronger than Flamingo and tbh I think now that he is the captain he prob powered up a bit as well

 

[chopstickchakra]

Marco seems invincible Lol Luffy might be able to handle him, but I don't know for how long because of the constant regeneration.
Zoro might be able to handle Vista (possibly), but the rest of this stuff is ridiculous.

I know OP said Luffy vs Marco but Usopp carries Karioseki handcuffs.

 

[YellowFang]

Zoro V Vista, the only competitive battle...

 

[Hexuze]

Marco wins mid diff.

Vista wins mid diff.

Jozu wins highest level of low diff. to maybe mid diff.

As for the rest, I'm quite certain that the rest of the WB commanders win.

 

[Bogard]

Marco wins mid diff.

Vista wins mid diff.

Jozu wins highest level of low diff. to maybe mid diff.

As for the rest, I'm quite certain that the rest of the WB commanders win.

Basically this except i see Sanji giving solid low diff to Jozu

 

[MickNerks]

Luffy VS Marco [Marco Mid Diff]

Zoro VS Vista [Vista was able to go toe to toe with Mihawk and easily hold his own. Vista > Zoro]

Sanji VS Jozu [Sanji isnt beating a Armandment Haki Diamond]

Robin vs Blamenco [His physically is stronger, so her clutches wouldnt work]

Franky Vs Curiel [Curiel tanks a direct magma fist from Akainu with no damage, so franky definately isnt hurting him]

brook Vs Speed Jiru [Jiru is tiers faster than Brook, able to easily react to kizaru]

Chopper Vs Atmos [From what we have seen Monster Point Chopper could win]

Nami Vs Haruta

Usopp vs Izo [Has a CQC advantage]

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Luffy VS Marco

Marco wins with mid diff at worst for him.

Zoro VS Vista

Zoro got pretty strong during time skip, but I doubt he would be able to win against person who was able to hold his own against Mihawk. Zoro has way to go before that.

Sanji VS Jozu

Jozu wins.

Robin vs Blamenco
Franky Vs Curiel
brook Vs Speed Jiru
Chopper Vs Atmos
Nami Vs Haruta
Usopp vs Izo

There are little to on information about these commanders, but I am pretty sure that they beat Straw Hats.

SH crew is strong, and probably one of the strongest non Yonko crew out there, but WB pirates are likely strongest non Yonko crew. I estimate that guys like Blamento, Curiel, Speed Jiru, Atmost, Haruta, Izo and etc would be as strong as Pica, and other top executives, against which anyone outside Monster trio wouldn't had a chance. Not to mention that guys like Jozu and Vista seems to be a lot stronger and on top of them Marco.

 

[TRE MERCER]

Marco and Ace are the most overrated OP chars.​

 

[VongolaX]

I don't see the straw hats beating WB commanders easily anytime soon.

 

[saw2097]

This question is best left until much later on in the story.

 

[ssjelf]

Marco and Ace are the most overrated OP chars.​

I dont think marco is overrated lol ace might be but marco proved himself to be quite capable in his fight vs kizaru.