Sticky Thread Suggestion for New Ideas

[Sterling Malory Archer]

So basically, my newest suggestion is that a sticky thread to be made somewhere (Don't know where actually lol). In the thread would consist of the opening post of suggestions made by members which would be implemented in the future. This way good suggestions won't be drowned and forgotten.

Examples of threads to be in stickied

• You must be registered for see links
• You must be registered for see links
• You must be registered for see links
• You must be registered for see links

It's a pretty simple idea to implement. And extremely useful
​

 

[-S-]

meh, I prefer viewing them in this section

suggestion would easily get lost in a thread considering there would be discussion going on

 

[Uchiha Paulsama]

meh, I prefer viewing them in this section

suggestion would easily get lost in a thread considering there would be discussion going on

whaT he said

 

[Sterling Malory Archer]

meh, I prefer viewing them in this section

suggestion would easily get lost in a thread considering there would be discussion going on

whaT he said

You don't understand what I'm sayingU_U

What I'm saying is...Suggestions that the mods deem fit to be implemented in the future will be put in the thread. We still post in this section...Just if the suggestion is a very good suggestion, then a Scorps/GMod would copy the opening post of the thread in the sticky thread...Do you understand now?

 

[-S-]

You don't understand what I'm sayingU_U

What I'm saying is...Suggestions that the mods deem fit to be implemented in the future will be put in the thread. We still post in this section...Just if the suggestion is a very good suggestion, then a Scorps/GMod would copy the opening post of the thread in the sticky thread...Do you understand now?

I see, but the thread would have to be locked, otherwise there would be too much discussion and the suggestions would be lost

good idea then bro

 

[Sterling Malory Archer]

I see, but the thread would have to be locked, otherwise there would be too much discussion and the suggestions would be lost

good idea then bro

That's why Scorps/GMod would have to do it. It's mainly for Admin's Reference also. So they don't have to dig for a certain idea that was suggested or something like that since it will be right there.

 

[Drizzy]

I partially agree with this, there are some good suggestions that haven't been seen as yet, they would need to be placed somewhere.
Probably a stickied thread in this section called "Suggestions". Everytime a suggestion is made, if it gets majority of the votes to agree within 3 days, it has the right to be posted in the stickied thread for Administrators and Moderators (in some cases) to view and post in the thread their feedback. On that stickied thread, the only persons allowed to post is the member who posts the link to his suggestion, and staff would later edit that post with "checked" etc. That would prevent spam and discussion in there.

Overall, it's a good suggestion.

 

[Sanzen]

I agree.

 

[Sterling Malory Archer]

I partially agree with this, there are some good suggestions that haven't been seen as yet, they would need to be placed somewhere.
Probably a stickied thread in this section called "Suggestions". Everytime a suggestion is made, if it gets majority of the votes to agree within 3 days, it has the right to be posted in the stickied thread for Administrators and Moderators (in some cases) to view and post in the thread their feedback. On that stickied thread, the only persons allowed to post is the member who posts the link to his suggestion, and staff would later edit that post with "checked" etc. That would prevent spam and discussion in there.

Overall, it's a good suggestion.

Thanks

I agree.

Thanks

 

[Izzy..]

Sounds like a lot of work to me. o_o

 

[Sterling Malory Archer]

Sounds like a lot of work to me. o_o

Not really. It's just one new thread with a couple of "posts" in it.

 

[Avani]

I partially agree with this, there are some good suggestions that haven't been seen as yet, they would need to be placed somewhere.
Probably a stickied thread in this section called "Suggestions". Everytime a suggestion is made, if it gets majority of the votes to agree within 3 days, it has the right to be posted in the stickied thread for Administrators and Moderators (in some cases) to view and post in the thread their feedback. On that stickied thread, the only persons allowed to post is the member who posts the link to his suggestion, and staff would later edit that post with "checked" etc. That would prevent spam and discussion in there.

Overall, it's a good suggestion.

I am not sure exactly about the purpose of the sticky. Do you want it for the admins etc?

The suggestions are seen. If a good and feasible suggestion is made, it is forwarded to developers/admins of the site by mods/Gmods. Rest is upto them to decide and implement.

 

[Nova.]

heres one of mine

You must be registered for see links

 

[Vincent]

The admins know what is going on, there are staff only forum sections of this site where all this is discussed.

 

[Drizzy]

I am not sure exactly about the purpose of the sticky. Do you want it for the admins etc?

The suggestions are seen. If a good and feasible suggestion is made, it is forwarded to developers/admins of the site by mods/Gmods. Rest is upto them to decide and implement.

Yeah.
If they are seen, it would be nice if the admin can give feedback to it so the member(s) know what's happening instead of leaving the thread unattended.

 

[Avani]

Yeah.
If they are seen, it would be nice if the admin can give feedback to it so the member(s) know what's happening instead of leaving the thread unattended.

If there is such a thread which was left unattended you can ask a mod/gmod about it.

 

[shadedcrow]

Seems pretty pointless... and redundant the question and suggestions forum is basically your idea already implemented.

 

[Scorps]

Yeah.
If they are seen, it would be nice if the admin can give feedback to it so the member(s) know what's happening instead of leaving the thread unattended.

If there is such a thread which was left unattended you can ask a mod/gmod about it.

Listen to Tsuchi. When we check suggestions that are doable, useful or that could be implemented, we forward it to the ones in charge of it to either evaluate or implement. Now, if a thread doesn't have a post from one of the admins, most probably that suggestion doesn't make sense for the admins to implement. Simple as that.

Remember that the admins (only 4 of them, might you remember) can't be going around giving feedback of everything they do and evaluate. They look at it and if it doesn't matter, they move on. This suggestion is just a way to make the stickies clustered and unorganized and basically a mess.

Belived me, when we see something worth applying to the site, we forward it to the ones in charge or apply it ourselves if we are able to do so.