Some questions for Game of thrones fans and book readers too.

Mad Titan Thanos

Banned
Elite
Joined
Feb 23, 2015
Messages
5,062
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. What you expect from the upcoming battle against Jon Snow and Ramsay army ?
Would Petyr Baelish army come and give Jon victory. Or would someone betray Ramsay.

2. Stannis is alive in books and he is attacking Boltons . So what do you think are there high chance that battle of Bastards (Jon vs Ramsay) would never happen in actual books and that we would only see Stannis against Boltons ?

3. Can we expect Benjen Stark and Sandor Clegane return in books too ?

4. Are you like me disappointed with white walkers origin. I expected some evil God or extremely powerfull demon created them.
 

Uzumaki Menma

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
1,648
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. What you expect from the upcoming battle against Jon Snow and Ramsay army ?
Would Petyr Baelish army come and give Jon victory. Or would someone betray Ramsay.

2. Stannis is alive in books and he is attacking Boltons . So what do you think are there high chance that battle of Bastards (Jon vs Ramsay) would never happen in actual books and that we would only see Stannis against Boltons ?

3. Can we expect Benjen Stark and Sandor Clegane return in books too ?

4. Are you like me disappointed with white walkers origin. I expected some evil God or extremely powerfull demon created them.
1. I expect the fight to be epic, hopefully as good of an episode as Hardhome. Also, Baelish army will ride in when it looks too grim for Jon's army.

2. Stannis is dead and never returning in the show. In the books, I'm not sure what George has planned for the bastards.

3. Sandor Clegane has basically already been confirmed back in the books. Have you read them? He's the graveyard keeper. Whereas Benjen was Coldhands in the show, I believe George said Benjen Stark is not the identity of Cold Hands in the book so I don't know where he is.

4. There's definitely much more to the White Walkers than what was shown. I like the idea that the Children used them to combat the humans. It seems so modern and correct. Imagine of Native Americans could've used their tribal magic to create some weapon to equally fight back against Colonist. It would surely happen.
 

Trúth

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
12,292
Kin
4💸
Kumi
2,711💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
No doubt the battle will be one of the best we've seen. I'm expecting Littlefinger to come help of course, but I doubt it'll be without cost. Someone is probably dying for his help. I'm cool with anything so long as by the end of it I see Jon put a sword through Ramsay's skull. On some Arya Stark shit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Flakez

Flakez

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
70,977
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It might go similar to braveheart, where at the end a large portion of the army had made a secret deal to lay down weapons. So here part of Ramsay's army might do that, since Jon's army is outnumbered. Plus Littlefinger will most likely show up too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trúth

Caliburn

Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,771
Kin
2,805💸
Kumi
525💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. What you expect from the upcoming battle against Jon Snow and Ramsay army ?
Would Petyr Baelish army come and give Jon victory. Or would someone betray Ramsay.

2. Stannis is alive in books and he is attacking Boltons . So what do you think are there high chance that battle of Bastards (Jon vs Ramsay) would never happen in actual books and that we would only see Stannis against Boltons ?

3. Can we expect Benjen Stark and Sandor Clegane return in books too ?

4. Are you like me disappointed with white walkers origin. I expected some evil God or extremely powerfull demon created them.
1) If the episode is as good as the trailers, the choreography will be outstanding. As much as I would like to see the face of Ramsey when someone backstabs him, at this point I don't see either the Umbers nor the Karstarks rebel. They need someone's support. The Vale of course is the most logical and the most likely, however I do not trust Littlefinger. Anything good has never come from a Stark trusting him. So I'm hoping for either a huge pack of wolves led by Nymeria (wolves can't really do much against an army of trained soldiers, however they can give their horses a good scare, which could cause pandemonium and even make them trample their own riders), house Manderly or a combined force of house Manderly and other smaller houses. You also have the Crannogmen, but those are small in number and not suited for open combat.

2) According to Ramsey's letter in the books Stannis was beaten. Now a confirmation still has to happen, but I don't really see Ramsey lying about something like that. In response Jon was able to rally the Wildlings to march with him to Winterfel to retake it from Ramsey and it was on that moment he was stabbed.

3) Benjen Stark was always the most likeliest candidate for Coldhands. One of the directors even referred to Benjen as Coldhands Benjen in their comments on the episode this season where he was introduced. I don't think the books will be different on this matter. Same thing for Sandor Clegane as there was a character described in the books of whom people theorize it was in fact Clegane. This seems to be conform with the series as there Clegane befriends a somewhat odd pious guy who has a past as a soldier and leads a community and in the books the theorized Clegane is part of a community that a guy named the Elder Brother leads and that Brother also used to be a knight.

4) I didn't like it either as it pretty much comes down to that mankind's mortal enemy originates from themselves, though them being created by evil demons isn't any better. I simply wanted them to be a different species independently from humans. There's hope though that it will be different in the books as according to Westerosi history the Children of the Forest and the First Men fought against each other for generations, but eventually made a pact that lasted several millenia till the White Walkers appeared and both their existences were threatened. It doesn't really make sense that the Children made the Walkers while they lived peacefully for thousands of years. If course the history could be wrong as it's not absolute.
 

Mad Titan Thanos

Banned
Elite
Joined
Feb 23, 2015
Messages
5,062
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1) If the episode is as good as the trailers, the choreography will be outstanding. As much as I would like to see the face of Ramsey when someone backstabs him, at this point I don't see either the Umbers nor the Karstarks rebel. They need someone's support. The Vale of course is the most logical and the most likely, however I do not trust Littlefinger. Anything good has never come from a Stark trusting him. So I'm hoping for either a huge pack of wolves led by Nymeria (wolves can't really do much against an army of trained soldiers, however they can give their horses a good scare, which could cause pandemonium and even make them trample their own riders), house Manderly or a combined force of house Manderly and other smaller houses. You also have the Crannogmen, but those are small in number and not suited for open combat.

2) According to Ramsey's letter in the books Stannis was beaten. Now a confirmation still has to happen, but I don't really see Ramsey lying about something like that. In response Jon was able to rally the Wildlings to march with him to Winterfel to retake it from Ramsey and it was on that moment he was stabbed.

3) Benjen Stark was always the most likeliest candidate for Coldhands. One of the directors even referred to Benjen as Coldhands Benjen in their comments on the episode this season where he was introduced. I don't think the books will be different on this matter. Same thing for Sandor Clegane as there was a character described in the books of whom people theorize it was in fact Clegane. This seems to be conform with the series as there Clegane befriends a somewhat odd pious guy who has a past as a soldier and leads a community and in the books the theorized Clegane is part of a community that a guy named the Elder Brother leads and that Brother also used to be a knight.

4) I didn't like it either as it pretty much comes down to that mankind's mortal enemy originates from themselves, though them being created by evil demons isn't any better. I simply wanted them to be a different species independently from humans. There's hope though that it will be different in the books as according to Westerosi history the Children of the Forest and the First Men fought against each other for generations, but eventually made a pact that lasted several millenia till the White Walkers appeared and both their existences were threatened. It doesn't really make sense that the Children made the Walkers while they lived peacefully for thousands of years. If course the history could be wrong as it's not absolute.
I must reply to number 2 and 3.

Stannis is alive that is confirmed by Martin himself in interview. Also there is winds of winter chapter released I wont spoil you much but Stannis is alive and its about to offer Theon to red god and march to winterfell.

Benjen Stark is not Coldhands Martin answered that to some fan.

Yeah in books white walkers probably have different origin.
 

Caliburn

Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,771
Kin
2,805💸
Kumi
525💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I must reply to number 2 and 3.

Stannis is alive that is confirmed by Martin himself in interview. Also there is winds of winter chapter released I wont spoil you much but Stannis is alive and its about to offer Theon to red god and march to winterfell.

Benjen Stark is not Coldhands Martin answered that to some fan.

Yeah in books white walkers probably have different origin.
I read that chapter and that doesn't really mean anything as he could still die in a following chapter. I also find it questionable that Martin is randomly giving out information to fans about his books. He did once stated in an original manuscript that Benjen isn't Coldhands, which can be translated as much that the script got edited afterwards.
 
Top