Smartest : Hashirama or Madara

[The Necromancer]

Wars in star wars take strategy until someone like Darth Revan comes in..... Or someone like the Exile.... I'm assuming you haven't played KOTOR 2 yet.... Naruto soloed the current war due to Shikaku providing the strategy..

Revan WAS the strategy. Unlike in naruto, revan can't fight on all fronts against everyone himself. And don't presume to know what i know about star wars. I've yet to meet someone who knows more than me on this site.

 

[KingHashirama]

Revan WAS the strategy. Unlike in naruto, revan can't fight on all fronts against everyone himself. And don't presume to know what i know about star wars. I've yet to meet someone who knows more than me on this site.

Hashirama was the strategy to stop the whole war conflicted world.. Your not realizing that. The war Hashirama faced REQUIRED strategy.. not just spaming OP jutsu. Hashirama's war was not simply Uchiha vs Senju..... it was Senju vs the rest of the world.

And I simply made a analysis.. If you have played Kotor then you wouldn't have made the point you made about Star war wars requires strategies.. when someone like the Exile won the war with just her brute power.

Revan himself could've took on the mandalore easily and assassinated him, but he chose not to.. he chose to annihialate the army with his strategies and so on.

Revan is too much like Hashirama mate.

 

[The Necromancer]

Hashirama was the strategy to stop the whole war conflicted world.. Your not realizing that. The war Hashirama faced REQUIRED strategy.. not just spaming OP jutsu. Hashirama's war was not simply Uchiha vs Senju..... it was Senju vs the rest of the world.

And I simply made a analysis.. If you have played Kotor then you wouldn't have made the point you made about Star war wars requires strategies.. when someone like the Exile won the war with just her brute power.

Revan himself could've took on the mandalore easily and assassinated him, but he chose not to.. he chose to annihialate the army with his strategies and so on.

Revan is too much like Hashirama mate.

Actually revan DID fight mandalore and beat him, ending the war while the battle of malacore was still going on. And Meetra, or the exile as you prefer to call her, was not in a war, she was in the middle of a regime of assassination against the jedi led by the sith triumvirate. She didn't need a strategy and in fact, participated in many battle in which others created the strategy. While this is true, she was revan's third in command second only to malak whom he entrusted with the detonation of the mass shadow generator, suggesting she had high military intelligence as well.

Not saying hashi isn't smart, but wars in naruto don't work the same way as wars in star wars or the real world even. The current war is near its end and has been going on a total of 2 days. Secondly in hashirama's time, clans were hired to fight one another in battles, it was not a time of absolute warfare of every clan vs. every other clan. The senju and uchiha were not fighting for a country, or for land, or for ideals. They fought only in single battles chosen by those who hired them.

Again. Not saying that madara and hashirama aren't smart, but comparing them to star wars tactics is nearly impossible.

 

[KingHashirama]

Actually revan DID fight mandalore and beat him, ending the war while the battle of malacore was still going on. And Meetra, or the exile as you prefer to call her, was not in a war, she was in the middle of a regime of assassination against the jedi led by the sith triumvirate. She didn't need a strategy and in fact, participated in many battle in which others created the strategy. While this is true, she was revan's third in command second only to malak whom he entrusted with the detonation of the mass shadow generator, suggesting she had high military intelligence as well.

Not saying hashi isn't smart, but wars in naruto don't work the same way as wars in star wars or the real world even. The current war is near its end and has been going on a total of 2 days. Secondly in hashirama's time, clans were hired to fight one another in battles, it was not a time of absolute warfare of every clan vs. every other clan. The senju and uchiha were not fighting for a country, or for land, or for ideals. They fought only in single battles chosen by those who hired them.

Again. Not saying that madara and hashirama aren't smart, but comparing them to star wars tactics is nearly impossible.

current Naruto war = Civil war


War during Hashirama's war = World War with no stop.

Reread I said Revan could've assassinated the Mandalore and ended it all. He could've easily overpowered them. But did he do that? no. Did Hashirama go out there and assassinate Madara or other enemy leaders? no. Why did they not do this? Simply because that is not how it works, you need strategy. Killing Mandalore wouldn't have affected the Mandalorians in the starting of the war.. but it would if they were already loosing the war. Same for Hashirama, he never "overpowered" anyone in the war. He simply started to over power other clans with his army. Just like what Revan did.


The Exile my friend is Naruto. When Nihlius started attacking and etc the Exile first followed strategies just like Naruto has been doing.. and then took charge. The Nihlius invasion is basically how the current war in Naruto is set up. Besides the whole "declaration".


The Clans actually did fight without being hired. Hashirama said " the war is now spreading here" , when the one ninja dropped into the river while Hashi and Madara were skipping stones. It my friend was a Era of warring states. Those states made hatred get into the clans.. its the common cycle.. The cycle that Hashirama got punched by his father for speaking against that cycle.

I mean I find it really childish when people claim Minato or Itachi are superior to Madara and Hashirama in smarts.. So this should've been a better battle of strength then "who is smarter: Minato or Itachi?".

Wars are almost basically the same mate, You just have to look at the right ones.

 

[BloodSeed]

hashirama is dumber than madara

 

[Bronze]

hashirama is smarter when it comes to: controlling village' business, ruling the government and creating ninja village system.

madara is smarter when it comes to: creating plans, science knowledge, jutsus and battle tactical strategies.