Smartest fighter in NV?

[Avinash012]

Minato takes this he's the only one the has both power only intellect

itachi has low chakra reserves

shikamru has low chakra reserves

Itachi had alot of chakra compared to Minato(without kcm) since he is a decendent of sage and he blessed with a remarkable chakra like all other Uchiha's....

 

[Troyg39]

Shikamaru did it after a lot of thinking and alot of plot ,wat if Shikamaru would have faced Hidan for the first time like Asuma did,

Considering that Shikamaru is a lot smarter and more analytical than Asuma? I can't say for sure. Two different ninja dude.

I'm just saying that fact that he beat someone who couldn't be killed and the only thing special about him is "shadow possession jutsu", that's something to be admired. And most ninja wouldn't have thought of chopping Hidan up and burying him alive no matter how much time they were given, and to make it even better, not many ninja with Shikamaru's fodder level skill set would've been able to actually get the job done. Give credit where it's due

Itachi had alot of chakra compared to Minato(without kcm) since he is a decendent of sage and he blessed with a remarkable chakra like all other Uchiha's....

The point he was trying to make was that Itachi had low stamina. Since he was a descendant of the older son, he didn't get the strong body, so that use of remarkable chakra sped up his death

 

[Avinash012]

You completely missed the entire point of the concept of what intelligence is. You threw in "power", then used that against Shikamaru to then determine that he lost. Please re-evaluate your post.

ya ur right may be some one like sasuke or Neji would replace Shikamaru

 

[Avinash012]

Minato...IMO

His skills revolve around his smarts...
He doesn't attack with power but with intellect...

For Itachi, he needs his prowess to testify his theories or analyses... Kakashi is same as Itachi
For Shikamaru, he can't use his brains in a fast going battle...

ya i compltly agree wit this,,,,,,,,,,,

 

[kakashi ms]

kakashi is the smartest

 

[Troyg39]

i know what the hell i said lol, most intelligent FIGHTER, what good is his intellect if his fighting skills dont match lol! reevaluate your comment...

You must be registered for see images

[/URL][/IMG]

END OF THREAD LOL

Well actually your last words were "who is the most cerebral fighter" which isn't the same thing as most intelligent fighter.

Most intelligent fighter would be the strongest fighter with the most smarts to back it up.

Most cerebral fighter would be the fighter who simply thinks the most and trys to beat you not by brute strength, but wittiness. Like a cerebral assassin. They attack you cerebrally more so than with power

 

[YellowFang]

ya i compltly agree wit this,,,,,,,,,,,

Thanks... Buddy!!!

 

[YellowFang]

kakashi is the smartest

LOOL, Agreed...

 

[Miyata]

Well actually your last words were "who is the most cerebral fighter" which isn't the same thing as most intelligent fighter.

Most intelligent fighter would be the strongest fighter with the most smarts to back it up.

Most cerebral fighter would be the fighter who simply thinks the most and trys to beat you not by brute strength, but wittiness. Like a cerebral assassin. They attack you cerebrally more so than with power

Are you arguing minato isnt after that proof?

 

[Avinash012]

Considering that Shikamaru is a lot smarter and more analytical than Asuma? I can't say for sure. Two different ninja dude.

I'm just saying that fact that he beat someone who couldn't be killed and the only thing special about him is "shadow possession jutsu", that's something to be admired. And most ninja wouldn't have thought of chopping Hidan up and burying him alive no matter how much time they were given, and to make it even better, not many ninja with Shikamaru's fodder level skill set would've been able to actually get the job done. Give credit where it's due



The point he was trying to make was that Itachi had low stamina. Since he was a descendant of the older son, he didn't get the strong body, so that use of remarkable chakra sped up his death

Yes I admited that Shikamaru is Super smart ,,but im just sayng that when it come's to a battle like Minato vs Obito even someone like Shikamaru would loose no matter how smart he is..

 

[XxLotusxX]

Minato is a bad match for anyone

 

[Troyg39]

Yes I admited that Shikamaru is Super smart ,,but im just sayng that when it come's to a battle like Minato vs Obito even someone like Shikamaru would loose no matter how smart he is..

That my friend is due to his lack of power, not his lack of intelligence. Losing to Minato does not make Minato smarter than Shikamaru. It makes him more powerful. The problem is that the OP threw in the stipulation of "power" even though it plays little into what truly makes up a "smart" fighter. It's just like saying if you gave Minato Shikamaru's powers instead of having the powers Minato is accustomed to, would he have beaten Obito? Probably not. Power does not equate to smarts. And sometimes being smart isn't enough to win a battle, but that doesn't mean the winner is always the smarter one

 

[Troyg39]

Are you arguing minato isnt after that proof?

1. You proved nothing. This is an opinion thread so don't get too arrogant

2. No, I'm saying that by your stipulations, Minato is the smartest fighter, but that's only because you threw in the stipulation of power, which in reality doesn't play into how smart you are. Naruto has defeated ninja who were smarter than him. He won those battles because he was superior in power. Power and intellect aren't the same thing. In other words you are saying "smartest" fighter but you are putting too much emphasis on power thus taking away from intelligence

And also, a "cerebral" fighter is not the same as a smart fighter. A cerebral fighter will try to defeat you WITHOUT the use of power and sheer force. So by you including power in your own version of what a "smart" fighter is, you can't say that Minato is the most "cerebral", because you yourself have spent a good amount of time on this thread trying to convince us that his power plays a major role in his smarts, which is not true for a cerebral fighter.

 

[Nakamazi Itchigo]

Itachi or Minato..too hard to decide