[Game] SK - League Of Legends Mafia Game Thread! Fight Or Be Forgotten!! #15
- Thread starter SoulKiller
- Start date
- Status
SoulKiller
Active member
Awards
Only if people allowed such confusion to affect their play. As I said before forget that the mod kill ever happened and continue playing normally.
I don’t want to see any more talks about it anymore.
kc5181 role claim
I don't think @XDDDDD was role fishing, I thought it was a sensible question when I read it, but then I am not used to claimless/hintless games, so maybe I would be more careful if I played like that more often? If you say something without giving a reason, I defintiely WILL consider asking you about it. If you don't answer, I will draw my conclusions (scum or power role).
I read @mothbomb as noting that kc has displayed TMI here, this is ok if pressuring for scum, but could also be role fishing here ("tell me your role or I will think you are scum"). But nobody talked about this, instead mothbomb is quick to accuse XD of role fishing.
And then there is
so, going to mothballs's read list:
how is Corazon mech clear if godfathers exist? Rej would have been town to a cop.
You are all voting XD right now because kc5181 voted XD? Even though you can't know what information he actually had? Someone please help me out here, I'm lost.
At this point, I believe SoulKiller must modkill kc5181 because kc5181 has essentially claimed that his post reflects his role knowledge. ( I can't make any sense of anything kc said after that, no idea where @Naomi_Rose gets that "shield" thing from)
I don't think @XDDDDD was role fishing, I thought it was a sensible question when I read it, but then I am not used to claimless/hintless games, so maybe I would be more careful if I played like that more often? If you say something without giving a reason, I defintiely WILL consider asking you about it. If you don't answer, I will draw my conclusions (scum or power role).
I read @mothbomb as noting that kc has displayed TMI here, this is ok if pressuring for scum, but could also be role fishing here ("tell me your role or I will think you are scum"). But nobody talked about this, instead mothbomb is quick to accuse XD of role fishing.
And then there is
Kyte forgets alignment cops exist? ah, but they couldn't clear the godfather
so, going to mothballs's read list:
how is Corazon mech clear if kc5181 is only "likely" town?
how is Corazon mech clear if godfathers exist? Rej would have been town to a cop.
Can anyone (because Ansa left) explain this to me?
You are all voting XD right now because kc5181 voted XD? Even though you can't know what information he actually had? Someone please help me out here, I'm lost.
I agree with the decision to only reveal the role after the game, because it means that sending information to town at the risk of a ban is not rewarded (plus kc may get temp-banned?). I know you don't like it because you expect (or try to make us think) that this information would help you defend XD. You have defended @XDDDDD ever since @All_Red attacked him on D1, but he's only "slight town" in your 1208 read list. What's your strategy?
(Also, ty for posting the reads list, I said "bet you won't" earlier, but you did post one.)
SoulKiller
Active member
Awards
Will have vote logbook. But it’s too early for that. Will be working on it in the last few hours. From what I saw so far only very few votes been issued.
ScarletCelestial
Active member
About
Although a lot of content was my own opinions yesterDay, a lot of it was me conversing or questioning. If I want to speak to someone, I try to add a question in, no matter how basic it is and try to question further in from there, like I did with you. Anything can be telling of Mafia, even if the content does not yet look useful, in my belief.
In my experience there is always at least one scum in the non-voters. With what happened yesterday with the wagons, I'm thinking that scum weren't around EoD, or if they were provided little influence on the outcome and were passive. This makes me believe there may be two. So it's more a pattern supplemented by an educational guess. Since I'm currently only working with a single VC, I will likely have a clearer idea of where scum are when there is a second VC, and more flips.
first, I think role reveal was better after DP cuz we will know what Kc alignment was which can confirm few things. It's pretty simple to see that Mothbomb and Kyte is getting too into xD 'why' and I don't really consider that normal why a way to fish someone's role
I don't think I have ever defended xD beside now, before that all I said, he's town because I was town reading him. Slight read cuz he still hasn't done anything which gives me the doubts, that's all
ScarletCelestial
Active member
ScarletCelestial
Active member
I think Mendel's Town: the way he spoke to me yesterday was that of someone who was trying to understand where the player they're questioning is coming from. They seem like a high effort player, which tends to be harder to catch as scum, but how he was questioning me was supplemented by the effort, instead of trying to make the effort look like the main point imo.
ScarletCelestial
Active member
ScarletCelestial
Active member
ScarletCelestial
Active member
I was confused by his last statement too.
We need to close this case. I'll explain what I think from a personal point of view. XD might have potentially acted on Corazon, and Kc could have either watched Corazon or tracked XD. He thought XD targeted Corazon last night to kill him, and was role-blocked, but Corazon could be a Cop for all he knows.
I don't want any replies on this part of the post, and any further dive into the roles now, especially from XD.
Yes, Mendel, even if it's not the Godfather, any action could still be intercepted by a redirect of the actor, or a transport of the target. And at any rate, I don't really like cutting all doubt in one's result like Kc did, or for anyone following his footsteps after he'd mod-killed just because he's extremely likely to be Town. The situation could very much be misleading, so i'd rather not build any assumptions based on it, especially since the host has advised to not dive much into it. I don't imagine he'd be deviating us from the right investigation track. LOL
ScarletCelestial
Active member
The thing about Houtarou is his final post before the Day ended. Vote: Houtarou I don't think he had an awareness of the no self-voting thing, and in the context of that particular EoD, moving his vote from Rej to himself would either cause:
1. A tie or
2. His own lynch.
Either option I believe is very against a scum mindset in the instance of this game, and as stated before is the reason why I'm leaving him alone this phase.
@mothbomb @Mendel
1. A tie or
2. His own lynch.
Either option I believe is very against a scum mindset in the instance of this game, and as stated before is the reason why I'm leaving him alone this phase.
@mothbomb @Mendel
- Status