Ok... These are pretty good, a better improvement then the other ones. but here are things you should improve on:
1. See, the Zoro render has got some lighter shades on the right side. Putting a darker background ruins the flow of the sig as the render's lighting doesn't even match the background's expression. So choose wisely of what kinda BG is going to be placed and what kinda effects are going to be placed to allow the BG and render to blend.
2. Reduce opacity of scan lines that are placed on lighter places. For instance, there is very clear scan lines on madara's attack-fan (or whatever you call it) which doesn't look very inviting, so reducing the opacity will keep the fan clear ^^
Anyway keep on practicing
