[Signature Battle] Elmage vs LitzSabr

[LitzSabr]

This was to be done quite sometime ago, buttt better late than never

1. Elmage

You must be registered for see images

2. LitzSabr

You must be registered for see images

Render

Spoiler

You must be registered for see links

-Vote for the entry which you think is the better one
-Do tell below why you voted for that particular entry ​

 

[Valhorus]

Mmmm both D: .

 

[Wanheda]

Your not supposed to show the names >.> its supposed to be anonymous.

 

[Frikid]

litzsabr
it looks cool

 

[Phobos]

I voted Elmage: background and overal atmosphere creates a feeling of western which goes well with the border.

I was, however, deciding for some time. The text on Elmage's one is imo bad, I really don't like the yellow skript text and the glow under "gun". On the other hand, LitzSabr's text is imo well done and goes well with the "western" theme.

I don't like the border on Elmage's sig much, it's better suited for avatars. (Edit: changed my mind, it looks ok)
Effects on LitzSabr's sig are cool, though the magma and flames thing would fit better for some anime character (Akainu stuff).

It was a pretty close call, if I was looking at the text for a bit longer, I might change the decision

 

[Senjuubi Sage]

first has better lighting. The second has better background and blending. Dont like either text

 

[LitzSabr]

Your not supposed to show the names >.> its supposed to be anonymous.

Well that's not always the case. It can be done in this way too.

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Well pardon my rustinessxd i haven't designed a sig for over a year>_> so there's bound to be setbacks

 

[rockalex]

LitzSabr gmv. I like the flow, the focal point is good, the colors blend very well and the text suits the theme of the render and thus the sig. For the record, it was the hard choice.

 

[Horus]

I like Litz's better. It has a better feel to it IMO and the effects are good. Not the mention the smudging skills that Litz possesses are ridiculously good.

I like the western feel that Elmage's sig has though but the text and border sort of takes away from the whole tag.

But truly, Elmage in his prime would wipe the floor with most of the Design Hall's GFX'ers xD

 

[Hei]

Both signatures are nice,although i think LitzSabr's signature is slightly better.


The lightning and color balance is really good on the second signature,but the 1st one has really nice atmosphere but Elmage's signature has some sort of emptiness,too much empty space left that could be used to creat more drive in the tag.
The problems with text was already mentioned so...that's it.

Good job guys !

 

[Sirius Black]

It's hard to vote because with all my honesty I cannot chose Both are good

 

[Alkadeias]

litzi GMV

 

[- J AV -]

Both did nice job.

but My vote goes to Litzsabr

 

[LitzSabr]

A Big Thanks to everyone who voted.
Winner of this battle: LitzSabr

 

[Dãrth1]

The second one