Shouldn't Edo Tensei Madara be banned from top 10s?

[Prestonyoko]

When you over think it, Everybody puts Madara at top because he has Rinnegan, Wood Release, Perfect Susano'o, and Meteors, but when you think about it hard enough

Madara unlocked Rinnegan when he was an extremely old man and close to death, and if Kabuto never enhanced his body and made it better than his old man body, Old Man Edo Tensei Madara Maybe would of lost to the 5 Kage, And the abilities current Edo Tensei Madara shows now is better than he ever could when he was an old man on Gedo Mazo life support.

You must be registered for see images

People are putting Edo Tensei Madara at the top 10 of their lists because of what he was shown to do in his enhanced body with Edo Tensei Chakra. And with quick body repairing regeneration, he brings an unfair advantage to the competition he faces below the list.

When tier-ing Madara on top 10 list then you should input

Old Man Madara- Rinnegan, Wood Release, Meteorite Technique

Or

Prime Madara- Perfect Susano'o, Kurama, Katon.

Because Edo Tensei Enhanced Body Madara is practically impossible to solo unless your Edo Tensei Hashirama or Edo Tensei Itachi.

Top 10s should be based on the power people had when they were Alive.

So the Top 10 should be

1: Kabuto Yukashi- Dragon Sage Mode, DNA from various ninja, and Edo Tensei

2: Orochimaru- Eight Branches Technique, Summoning Jutsu, and Edo Tensei.

3: Obito Uchiha- Wood Release, Mangekyo Sharingan, Rinnegan, and Gedo Mazo

I put Obito over the the two God Shinobi because neither one of them can face Obito using the "Six Paths Of Pain" and Using 6 Tailed Beast and Gedo Mazo all at once, even for Hashirama thats too much to handle

4: Hashirama Senju- Wood Release, Sage Mode, Summoning Jutsu, Sealing Jutsu, Bringer of Darkness, and is a Battle-Hardened-Ninja.

5: Madara Uchiha (Prime)- Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan, Katon, Kurama, and is a Battle-Hardedned-Ninja.

6: Naruto Uzamaki- Kurama (Perfect Jinchuuriki), Sage Mode, Rasengan, and Summoning Jutsu

7: Nagato- Rinnegan

8: Itachi Uchiha- Mangekyo Sharingan, Totsuka Blade, Yata Mirror, and Katon.

I hate to do it but i put Itachi over Sasuke just becasue Itachi had Totsuka Blade to pierce and seal Sasuke.

9: Sasuke Uchiha- Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan, Lighting Release, Katon, Kirin, Summoning Jutsu, and Blaze Release.

10: Mū- Dust Release, Fission Technique, and Hiding with Camouflage Technique.

Don't give me the "Well this is your list so were not entitled to change your opinion bs" this is the Top 10 Powerful Shinobi List.

But more importantly to conquer, Madara's Rank should drop to 5 because he should be based on the powerhe had when he was alive, not dead.

Thoughts?

 

[Zuru]

In a legit top 10 list, edo's usually are not used.

 

[Ōkami]

Yes, Only non Edos should be allowed in any lists.

 

[Yuffosan]

When you over think it, Everybody puts Madara at top because he has Rinnegan, Wood Release, Perfect Susano'o, and Meteors, but when you think about it hard enough

Madara unlocked Rinnegan when he was an extremely old man and close to death, and if Kabuto never enhanced his body and made it better than his old man body, Old Man Edo Tensei Madara Maybe would of lost to the 5 Kage, And the abilities current Edo Tensei Madara shows now is better than he ever could when he was an old man on Gedo Mazo life support.

You must be registered for see images

People are putting Edo Tensei Madara at the top 10 of their lists because of what he was shown to do in his enhanced body with Edo Tensei Chakra. And with quick body repairing regeneration, he brings an unfair advantage to the competition he faces below the list.

When tier-ing Madara on top 10 list then you should input

Old Man Madara- Rinnegan, Wood Release, Meteorite Technique

Or

Prime Madara- Perfect Susano'o, Kurama, Katon.

Because Edo Tensei Enhanced Body Madara is practically impossible to solo unless your Edo Tensei Hashirama or Edo Tensei Itachi.

Top 10s should be based on the power people had when they were Alive.

So the Top 10 should be

1: Kabuto Yukashi- Dragon Sage Mode, DNA from various ninja, and Edo Tensei

2: Orochimaru- Eight Branches Technique, Summoning Jutsu, and Edo Tensei.

3: Obito Uchiha- Wood Release, Mangekyo Sharingan, Rinnegan, and Gedo Mazo

I put Obito over the the two God Shinobi because neither one of them can face Obito using the "Six Paths Of Pain" and Using 6 Tailed Beast and Gedo Mazo all at once, even for Hashirama thats too much to handle

4: Hashirama Senju- Wood Release, Sage Mode, Summoning Jutsu, Sealing Jutsu, Bringer of Darkness, and is a Battle-Hardened-Ninja.

5: Madara Uchiha (Prime)- Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan, Katon, Kurama, and is a Battle-Hardedned-Ninja.

6: Naruto Uzamaki- Kurama (Perfect Jinchuuriki), Sage Mode, Rasengan, and Summoning Jutsu

7: Nagato- Rinnegan

8: Itachi Uchiha- Mangekyo Sharingan, Totsuka Blade, Yata Mirror, and Katon.

I hate to do it but i put Itachi over Sasuke just becasue Itachi had Totsuka Blade to pierce and seal Sasuke.

9: Sasuke Uchiha- Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan, Lighting Release, Katon, Kirin, Summoning Jutsu, and Blaze Release.

10: Mū- Dust Release, Fission Technique, and Hiding with Camouflage Technique.

Don't give me the "Well this is your list so were not entitled to change your opinion bs" this is the Top 10 Powerful Shinobi List.

But more importantly to conquer, Madara's Rank should drop to 5 because he should be based on the powerhe had when he was alive, not dead.

Thoughts?

I agree. Good job buddy!~

 

[omarsen]

Didn't read, no he is back, as edo or not. doesn't matter, we have to see the power of so6p which madara got.

 

[theRPGdude]

Why no Edo Itachi and Nagato in 10 ten but Edo Madara is?

 

[Tormound]

I agree, also the meteorite jutsu(think it's called shattered heavens) is a suicide jutsu so old man Madara can't even use it.
I don't consider edo tensei a legitimate part of someone's power level.

 

[hixa kuogame]

no top ten list is accurate
just sayin

 

[UchihaKira]

As far as Im concerned when he took advantage of the situation and broke the Edo tensei he became valid for Top 10 lists.

 

[Purekiller]

***** awesome theory i agree madara edo is much stronger than the normal madara.
Taking Oro on 2nd and Itachi 8nd???!! Let the Itachi fan boys unleach

 

[Meee]

If you going to restrict Edo's from being in the list Why are Oro/Kabuto and Obito allowed to have their Edo's/Paths? Thats unfair IMO

 

[Prestonyoko]

Didn't read, no he is back, as edo or not. doesn't matter, we have to see the power of so6p which madara got.

So your saying Madara should be based on the power he has when he's a zombie? Or are you agreeing with me? Sorry I can't tell

 

[UchihaKira]

Why no Edo Itachi and Nagato in 10 ten but Edo Madara is?

Because Itachi has essentially the same jutsu edo or not while Madara has jutsu as an edo he never had in life. Nagato never broke the edo tensei like Madara and Itachi did.

 

[CobaltThe17th]

Yes, Only non Edos should be allowed in any lists.

^ pretty much sums it up

 

[Prestonyoko]

If you going to restrict Edo's from being in the list Why are Oro/Kabuto and Obito allowed to have their Edo's/Paths? Thats unfair IMO

Its fair because the characters themselves aren't edo tensei, only the techniques their using

 

[SIGFOR]

Edo's are not even fair to use on a Top Ten. Living shinobi only

 

[Punk Hazard]

No he shouldn't. Unlike other Edos, he broke free and became his own character, so he counts.

 

[Prestonyoko]

Why no Edo Itachi and Nagato in 10 ten but Edo Madara is?

Nobody is Edo Tensei in the list, When i say Nagato, I meant when he was alive and used "The Six Paths Of Pain"

 

[Tormound]

Its fair because the characters themselves aren't edo tensei, only the techniques their using

The battle might as well be an edo vs whoever since the caster can just run and hide while the edo stays on the opponent not giving them any room to attack the caster. Heck, it wouldn't matter if they attack the caster the edo would keep going. That's why it's unfair.

 

[UchihaKira]

To those saying he shouldnt be allowed on top 10 lists I dont see why not? He is not under the control of anyone, he took advantage of the situation he was in to gain more power, just like many other characters. I agree most Edos should not, considering they were under Kabutos control. As far as those who broke his control though they should be allowed.