should we count edos in versus threads or just living bodies?

[accept pain]

I prefer living bodies should be there for versus thread.
what do you think?

 

[TheSages456]

it doesnt matter.

 

[ballerjordan]

Same. I don't really care tho

 

[hixa kuogame]

not really imo

 

[Invsblphntm]

Madara, at the moment, is an Edo uncontrolled by anyone. How are we going to gauge Madara's true strength when he didn't have the Rinnegan or Mokuton during his prime?

 

[Minaruto]

It does matter.

Living against living. This is what they are actually capable of.

Edo against Edo. This affords them to be arrogant, make mistakes, do more jutsus, "die" several times, etc.

 

[accept pain]

Madara, at the moment, is an Edo uncontrolled by anyone. How are we going to gauge Madara's true strength when he didn't have the Rinnegan or Mokuton during his prime?

I say, edo madara does not exist.

 

[accept pain]

It does matter.

Living against living. This is what they are actually capable of.

Edo against Edo. This affords them to be arrogant, make mistakes, do more jutsus, "die" several times, etc.

yes,living should be tested against each other.

fanboys do this edo vs living or edp vs edo.

 

[Cursed Prince]

I say we judge Edo's as if they weren't edos. For exp. Madara still has rinnegan and hashi cells, but if you kill him, he's dead

 

[Strawberry]

If specified by op then y not
also Edo is a jutsu and like all others should be counted

 

[accept pain]

If specified by op then y not
also Edo is a jutsu and like all others should be counted

edo are part of kabuto's power.

 

[Invsblphntm]

I say, edo madara does not exist.

That's just lying to yourself. Kabuto is subdued and Madara is still around. Obviously saying Madara is the same as Edo Madara is a bit inaccurate but saying Edo Madara doesn't exist is just as ridiculous.

 

[accept pain]

If specified by op then y not
also Edo is a jutsu and like all others should be counted

That's just lying to yourself. Kabuto is subdued and Madara is still around. Obviously saying Madara is the same as Edo Madara is a bit inaccurate but saying Edo Madara doesn't exist is just as ridiculous.

and if kabuto did not revive him? then what?
one more thing,edo madara is alive because of itachi otherwise he has no space in this world.