Should sharingan users be able to use gentle fist?

[slashestranged]

Anybody can emit chakra through their hands but the reason the byakugan users do it is because they can see chakra points. When obito awakened his sharingan he said he could now see their flow of chakra. also in the movie bonds, sasuke hit some dude in his chakra points and cut off their chakra.

i think they can learn it. only problem is that no hyuga is going to teach anyone outside the clan how to use it

 

[Killeya]

yeah give that to sharingan users...and also add some laser pistols for them

 

[House]

Anybody can emit chakra through their hands but the reason the byakugan users do it is because they can see chakra points. When obito awakened his sharingan he said he could now see their flow of chakra. also in the movie bonds, sasuke hit some dude in his chakra points and cut off their chakra.

i think they can learn it. only problem is that no hyuga is going to teach anyone outside the clan how to use it

Troll detected. No, uchihas wouldn't be able to exert chakra from their fingertips and exert chakra bursts from their palm.

 

[White Zetsu]

Ya I always thought about this.It could be possible, it really depends on how well the sharingan can detect chakra points.It may be able to see the chakra flow but not the actual points which emit the chakra making it more difficult to use techniques like gentle first but they would also have to be skilled at controlling chakra (like a medic type ninja)

 

[Naruto the wind]

Dude. Anbu, tracker ninjas have special kind of traing abt chakra points and all those things.

 

[slashestranged]

Troll detected. No, uchihas wouldn't be able to exert chakra from their fingertips and exert chakra bursts from their palm.

why not? its not their kekkei genkai to exert chakra out of their hand. im pretty sure anyone with chakra control can emit chakra out of their hand. maybe they need some training but its not some unique trait that they have to emit chakra from their hands

 

[Hipster Madara]

they cant see chakra points... apparently only byakugan can?
i think that's what it said.

 

[Zoro..]

Troll detected. No, uchihas wouldn't be able to exert chakra from their fingertips and exert chakra bursts from their palm.

Agreed U_U

why not? its not their kekkei genkai to exert chakra out of their hand. im pretty sure anyone with chakra control can emit chakra out of their hand. maybe they need some training but its not some unique trait that they have to emit chakra from their hands

The problem is they cannot see chakra points nor create bursts aimed at internal organs. Uchihas are uncapable of doing that nor do they know all the locations of their own chakra points thus wont be able to use Rotation. So lets see Gentle Fist is based in three aspects.
Palm strikes: They cant see inside someone nor can release a powerful amount of chakra from their hand with such skill and precision unless you are a Hyuuga with special training. Nor can they actually exert raw chakra from their palms.
Finger strikes: They cant see chakra points so that is a no no. Nor can they exert chakra into someone out of their fingers.
Rotations: They do not know the location of their chakra points so this is also not possible.

 

[Braveknight]

yeah give that to sharingan users...and also add some laser pistols for them

+rep.

 

[al3xsmith13]

yeah give that to sharingan users...and also add some laser pistols for them

hahahaha that was funny

 

[The Sage Of 6 Paths]

no thats gay....

 

[Sageofthepath]

Troll detected. No, uchihas wouldn't be able to exert chakra from their fingertips and exert chakra bursts from their palm.

yes they could...


sharigan doesn't allow to see chakra point and chakra system

it shows a general flow of chakra with a colored aura... as see in the Sasuke/deidara fight


However as neurological system in the real life, chakra point in the system must be pretty much at the same place from everyone. So they could probably learn where to hit to close chakra point with some precision, nerver as byakugan could thought

 

[slashestranged]

but sasuke has hit someone in their chakra points with chidori senbon. he couldnt have just got lucky and hit them there

 

[Zoro..]

yes they could...


sharigan doesn't allow to see chakra point and chakra system

it shows a general flow of chakra with a colored aura... as see in the Sasuke/deidara fight


However as neurological system in the real life, chakra point in the system must be pretty much at the same place from everyone. So they could probably learn where to hit to close chakra point with some precision, nerver as byakugan could thought

Actually this is wrong. Everyone has different chakra points just like everyone looks different. Also Sharingan can see chakra flow and predict movements but they cannot see the chakra points themselves it would just be guess work and hoping to get lucky. Also exerting raw chakra from their hands or fingers would require more training then mastering 3T itself so I doubt any Uchiha would go for that and since they wouldn't even get special training it would be impossible. A Uchiha learning Hyuuga techniques is like a Hyuuga learning Nara techniques or other secret clan techniques... They are incapable of it.

 

[House]

why not? its not their kekkei genkai to exert chakra out of their hand. im pretty sure anyone with chakra control can emit chakra out of their hand. maybe they need some training but its not some unique trait that they have to emit chakra from their hands

=/ Anyone can emit a chakra burst from their hands/fingertips. Care to provide a proof?

If you don't understand gentle fist, why do you try to argue? Gentle Fist is more like shutting down your enemies chakra flow, disturbing the actual flow of chakra. When using gentle fist, hyuuga takes several finger strikes at the enemy, closing multiple chakra points with their own chakra. Could an uchiha see every chakra point and make finger strikes? Also, its very rare to master even the heavenly rotation for even hyuugas. I'd doubt an uchiha could master gentle fist, but more over imitate hyuugas.

Oh yea, and answer my question on the top.

 

[Sageofthepath]

Actually this is wrong. Everyone has different chakra points just like everyone looks different. Also Sharingan can see chakra flow and predict movements but they cannot see the chakra points themselves it would just be guess work and hoping to get lucky. Also exerting raw chakra from their hands or fingers would require more training then mastering 3T itself so I doubt any Uchiha would go for that and since they wouldn't even get special training it would be impossible. A Uchiha learning Hyuuga techniques is like a Hyuuga learning Nara techniques or other secret clan techniques... They are incapable of it.

Proof please

have you ever ear about pressure point??? surely not

 

[Zoro..]

=/ Anyone can emit a chakra burst from their hands/fingertips. Care to provide a proof?

If you don't understand gentle fist, why do you try to argue? Gentle Fist is more like shutting down your enemies chakra flow, disturbing the actual flow of chakra. When using gentle fist, hyuuga takes several finger strikes at the enemy, closing multiple chakra points with their own chakra. Could an uchiha see every chakra point and make finger strikes? Also, its very rare to master even the heavenly rotation for even hyuugas. I'd doubt an uchiha could master gentle fist, but more over imitate hyuugas.

Oh yea, and answer my question on the top.

^_^
To everyone reading this I suggest you don't argue with Dr. House about Hyuugas since he knows them aswell as anyone. I honestly doubt any of you could argue anything with him about Hyuuga techniques. But if you insist good luck in a hopeless argument :scorps:

 

[UzumakiNaruto20]

Anybody can emit chakra through their hands but the reason the byakugan users do it is because they can see chakra points. When obito awakened his sharingan he said he could now see their flow of chakra. also in the movie bonds, sasuke hit some dude in his chakra points and cut off their chakra.

i think they can learn it. only problem is that no hyuga is going to teach anyone outside the clan how to use it

You know what why not? Tobi and Madara are already happy with stealing eyes and DNA from other clans so I wouldn't put it past them to steal that too!

 

[House]

yes they could...


sharigan doesn't allow to see chakra point and chakra system

it shows a general flow of chakra with a colored aura... as see in the Sasuke/deidara fight


However as neurological system in the real life, chakra point in the system must be pretty much at the same place from everyone. So they could probably learn where to hit to close chakra point with some precision, nerver as byakugan could thought

By this logic, I can pretty much make an argument of having a normal shinobi posess the abilities of all these clans by him having mere chakra control: Aburame, Akimichi, Amagiri, Fūma, Hirasaka, Hōzuki, Inuzuka, Kaguya, Nara, and much other. There's me going destroying your weak argument.

 

[Sageofthepath]

^_^
To everyone reading this I suggest you don't argue with Dr. House about Hyuugas since he knows them aswell as anyone. I honestly doubt any of you could argue anything with him about Hyuuga techniques. But if you insist good luck in a hopeless argument :scorps:

What about chakra scalpel???