Should Sasuke be executed? Yay or Nay?

[natssuu]

All i know is thing won't be like before again. Imagine a international criminal(e.g osama) living in your state or country? The best is to be an outcast or end in jail.

Don't compare real life and imaginative life, it's stupid.

 

[warlee]

it seems like you aren't understanding where I'm coming from, but let me say it like this.

Gaara, killed a few innocent people, he almost killed Lee/Was never going to be a Ninja again (Konoha Nin), he attacked Konoha, a long with Oro, him and his village are a little responsible for the third's death, put Sasuke in the hospital. He yet, gets away because he changed? And Sasuke can't for killing Danzou? or just saying he wil destroy Konoha which he has yet to touch it?

My main point why he isn't exactly there yet (100% criminal), if Gaara was ok, why can't Sasuke be? At the end IF he helps the alliance, why can't he be forgiven?




Where'd you read that? If Itachi agreed he would have tried taking the third out or even stuck with Danzou instead of Akatsuki. He blackmailed Danzou before leaving. The 3rd tried talking to Uchiha's. When Itachi told him everything he wasn't happy with it, but he had a 13 year old kid who killed his clan in order to protect the village, to top it off a kid who was going to let his younger brother kill him, in order to restore the Uchiha's name. Danzou didn't like the 1st, 3rd, and 4th Hokages ways of teaching yet the 3rd agreed with Danzou? 3rd closed down Danzou ANBU after this, and he (Danzou) operated in the shadow, after the 3rd death they came out.

Therefore neither did the 3rd or Itachi agree with Danzou's method.

i never said they agreed to danzo methods but 3rd hokage and itachi agreed to kill the uchiha when every attempt to bring peace fail. And itachi join akatsuki as a spy to keep tobi from attackin konoha. That is a tounament either you surrender,your teacher stop the match or you die you might want to read that place again.

 

[Nave184]

Anyone in Konoha is licensed to kill. Naruto/Kakashi killed Kakuzu...Shika killed Hidan (this was out of revenge also)...The sound ninja were killed by Neji, Shika, Chouji and so forth. Gaara killed people (innocent) for pleasure and he did it during those exams. He attacked Konoha. These are all forgiven, but Sasuke killing Danzou won't be?

The difference they are members of a village and Sasuke isn't. Sasuke only killed Danzou, a man that was a criminal and responsibly for the massacre, and he is after the other two, If Sasuke kills someone in the war or attacks Konoha, than yes, he has gone too far that is when Naruto will make his decision, as Naruto and Gaara know Sasuke still can come back.

As of now Sasuke is not a 100% criminal in my eyes, as he can still be saved, Kakashi, Tsunade, Gaara, and even Itachi know this.

The difference was they were all on missions. Sasuke is not he is rogue and and internationally wanted. Yes, nobody liked Danzo he was a scumbag too that still makes him a criminal. Think about it, if you killed someone in the government because he was a scumbag what would happen? Its the exact same with sasuke.

 

[warlee]

Don't compare real life and imaginative life, it's stupid.

it is not stupid @ all. So you xpect every1 to like sasuke like before? You xpect every1 to relate w/ sasuke an ex-criminal who kill like ppl are nothing like before? Cool story bro.

 

[~Yubel~]

Don't compare real life and imaginative life, it's stupid.

You just want to avoid admitting he´s right + don´t take his imagination from him, the world is nothing without it.

 

[Hydro Spiral]

it is not stupid @ all. So you xpect every1 to like sasuke like before? You xpect every1 to relate w/ sasuke an ex-criminal who kill like ppl are nothing like before? Cool story bro.

*coughcough*Gaara*coughcough*

 

[~Yubel~]

*coughcough*Gaara*coughcough*

Gaara is a different situation, he was a jinchuriki who had shinobi trying to kill him 6 times by none other than his father, he killed them all, even though he was a psycho, it´s not an excuse to say that he was allowed to kill in the chunnin exam and the attack on the leaf village was a collective work, not something gaara planned, their alliance was brought back and everything was good again and gaara learned about love and wanted to mean something to people, not as a weapon but as kazekage, he did his best and after 3 years everyone loved him except for a few elders who still saw him as a monster.

Bottom line, Gaaras situation was entirely circumstantial while sasuke made all his decisions himself.

 

[Roy]

He shouldn't be executed, he got manipulated.

 

[ReLax -]

i never said they agreed to danzo methods but 3rd hokage and itachi agreed to kill the uchiha when every attempt to bring peace fail. And itachi join akatsuki as a spy to keep tobi from attackin konoha. That is a tounament either you surrender,your teacher stop the match or you die you might want to read that place again.

The 3rd didn't agree with the Uchiha massacre. The 3rd didn't even know till, itachi killed them all and told the 3rd himself.

The difference was they were all on missions. Sasuke is not he is rogue and and internationally wanted. Yes, nobody liked Danzo he was a scumbag too that still makes him a criminal. Think about it, if you killed someone in the government because he was a scumbag what would happen? Its the exact same with sasuke.

it depends on how you approach it. It's a anime, so anything is possible, I can also bring in real life factors in assisting me with my opinion. If someone from the government behind the governments back without no reason killed off an entire family, and than you killed him, Yes, they will take action, but once the truth comes out, others will stand by that person to give him justice, this kind of stuff has happened in the past.

I will say this, if Naruto killed Danzou it would be excused for him, even when he wanted to go, Kakashi stopped him because Danzou was in charge, and without Tsunade around he knew Danzou would have done something to Naruto. It was also Danzou who declared Sasuke a mission-nin/international criminal of obvious reasons. Even now you don't hear anyone actually speaking of Danzou death.

Gaara is a different situation, he was a jinchuriki who had shinobi trying to kill him 6 times by none other than his father, he killed them all, even though he was a psycho, it´s not an excuse to say that he was allowed to kill in the chunnin exam and the attack on the leaf village was a collective work, not something gaara planned, their alliance was brought back and everything was good again and gaara learned about love and wanted to mean something to people, not as a weapon but as kazekage, he did his best and after 3 years everyone loved him except for a few elders who still saw him as a monster.

Bottom line, Gaaras situation was entirely circumstantial while sasuke made all his decisions himself.

So, Sasuke as a 7-8 years old saw his entire clan laying there dead. He than finds out his brother was responsible and gets tormented by him. He after long and hard, even when he wasn't considered a missing-nin fights Itachi. He than discovers after itachi's death that he was good all a long and Konoha (Danzou/elders) were responsible for the massacre and the life that Itachi lived. He is now on that path, but only has taken Danzou out, were as Gaara killed innocent, nearly killed Lee, but manage to cripple him, his village was manipulated by Oro (As Sasuke is by Tobi) to take out Konoho. Gaara could have chosen his own path as Sasuke could Naruto is the perfect example. It took a crazy battle to straighten Gaara out, and it may take a even crazier battle to straighten Sasuke.

 

[Nave184]

He shouldn't be executed, he got manipulated.

Manipulated by Who?!!!

 

[warlee]

*coughcough*Gaara*coughcough*

unless sasuke become a kage it won't be like b4, which is not happening and last time i check gaara is not a criminal he is a citizen of a country.

 

[warlee]

He shouldn't be executed, he got manipulated.

:rofl: i'm the only 1 that find this comment funny? Yeah cool story bro.

 

[Nave184]

Yes what Danzo did was wrong and he deserved to die, but thats still murder, whichever way you look at it.And why would naruto kill Danzo, naruto has never killed anyone. At the end of the day unless sasuke actually changes and really helps the allied forces, theres no chance for him.

 

[siyo]

I have no sympathy for Sasuke, I don't think he should be forgiven for his crimes. Naruto's perception on the situation is irrelivent to the actual "justice" of the whole thing. I voted for the death. Sasuke should be executed, that would be the logical thing to do, and it would be realistic considering all the crimes he's comitted against the Great Nations.

Lol,you put it blunty but i agree with your sentiment.I just don't think kishi will do it.

it seems like you aren't understanding where I'm coming from, but let me say it like this.

Gaara, killed a few innocent people, he almost killed Lee/Was never going to be a Ninja again (Konoha Nin), he attacked Konoha, a long with Oro, him and his village are a little responsible for the third's death, put Sasuke in the hospital. He yet, gets away because he changed? And Sasuke can't for killing Danzou? or just saying he wil destroy Konoha which he has yet to touch it?

My main point why he isn't exactly there yet (100% criminal), if Gaara was ok, why can't Sasuke be? At the end IF he helps the alliance, why can't he be forgiven?

First off, no such thing as a 100% criminal.You either are one or your aren't, sure there are grey areas, but sasuke crossed those years ago.

Secondly, I made the poll so i can't see what people thought, and i won't flame you for thinking that he will be forgiven(nothing wrong with that).I just happened to disagree,and corrected some factual mistakes.

Lastly, you can't just say look at gaara He got away with murder so obviously sasuke should too.You have to look at what sasuke did at judge him from that.Sasuke did far worse things than gaara, and unlike gaara sasuke had everybody's support, but he still not only left konoha, but he did stuff that(in my opinion) he can't take back like the whole kage summit fiasco.It was his choice to not listen anybody.If he had returned after "killing" itachi i think he would have been forgiven.

 

[Hydro Spiral]

Bottom line, Gaaras situation was entirely circumstantial while sasuke made all his decisions himself.

My point was that people accept and love Gaara now, despite hating and fearing him as a monster before.

Nagato leveled the village, and killed several people throughout his life. Naruto hated him with a passion, but he bothered to understand him and his situation instead of acting out of spite. And they're like brothers now..

So..Why can't the same thing/something similar happen to Sasuke later on?

People with tragic lives end up doing bad things and they change for the better later on..That's just how this manga works :/

 

[Nave184]

Lol,you put it blunty but i agree with your sentiment.I just don't think kishi will do it.



First off, no such thing as a 100% criminal.You either are one or your aren't, sure there are grey areas, but sasuke crossed those years ago.

Secondly, I made the poll so i can't see what people thought, and i won't flame you for thinking that he will be forgiven(nothing wrong with that).I just happened to disagree,and corrected some factual mistakes.

Lastly, you can't just say look at gaara He got away with murder so obviously sasuke should too.You have to look at what sasuke did at judge him from that.Sasuke did far worse things than gaara, and unlike gaara sasuke had everybody's support, but he still not only left konoha, but he did stuff that(in my opinion) he can't take back like the whole kage summit fiasco.It was his choice to not listen anybody.If he had returned after "killing" itachi i think he would have been forgiven.

Hmmmm..... Well put.... I agree! U_U

 

[siyo]

He shouldn't be executed, he got manipulated.

lol, are you saying that if I convinced you to rob a bank you shouldn't do the time?

 

[FlareBlitz]

i think he should atleast be put in jail to pay for some of what he's done but killed....no...hes basically whats pushed naruto so far to become as strong as he is think about it....

 

[zombiejesus]

he should be killed for sure treason is death worthy and now during war he will fight agianst them oh yea kill him and quick

 

[~Yubel~]

So, Sasuke as a 7-8 years old saw his entire clan laying there dead. He than finds out his brother was responsible and gets tormented by him. He after long and hard, even when he wasn't considered a missing-nin fights Itachi. He than discovers after itachi's death that he was good all a long and Konoha (Danzou/elders) were responsible for the massacre and the life that Itachi lived. He is now on that path, but only has taken Danzou out, were as Gaara killed innocent, nearly killed Lee, but manage to cripple him, his village was manipulated by Oro (As Sasuke is by Tobi) to take out Konoho. Gaara could have chosen his own path as Sasuke could Naruto is the perfect example. It took a crazy battle to straighten Gaara out, and it may take a even crazier battle to straighten Sasuke.

To answer the bolded part, Gaara didn´t kill innocent, at the forest of the chunnin exam, he killed the 3 rain village ninjas but they were trying to kill him and his team, that was a normal ninja battle where Gaara won.
Who cares if he nearly killed Lee ,that´s what the fight was for, a fight to the death unless the referee steps in but Gai couldn´t stand his student dying so he stepped in.
Gaara did choose his path, after the only person he trusted tried to assasinate him, he realized that he should only love himself,that he existed for himself and should kill untill there is no one left, he became the monster everyone treated him as, that is the path he walked and the only path that was left for him obviously.

Unlike him, Sasuke wants to cause problem and destruction, he had alot of opportunities to live a happy life, he could have chosen forgivness,he could stop his own hatred from taking over and make him abandon his new group of friends suigetsu,jugo and karin, not to mention he stabbed her!
The same group of friends that all 4 risked their lives for each other maybe a week ago?
WTF is wrong with him? I´m still asking even though i don´t give a **** at this point, he developed very differently from what i expected after the failed attempt.