Shikaku And Inoichi May Not Be Dead

[saaaaaadpanda]

Gnarly theory. But it did say on the last page of one those chapters that they're dead. I doubt they'll return.

Well, we were all under the impression that Obito was dead, but look how that turned out.

 

[Chatte]

Well, Katsuyu only has endurance properties, the Healing is done only by chakra transfer jutsu from Tsunade. Tsunade's chakra has the healing properties.
And the thing is, Katsuyu was summoned back at the Kages location when the HQ thing happened.

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Well, (1) Katsuyu only has endurance properties, the Healing is done only by chakra transfer jutsu from Tsunade. Tsunade's chakra has the healing properties.
And the thing is, (2) Katsuyu was summoned back at the Kages location when the HQ thing happened.

(1) I wasn't aware of that.

(2) Post the page that shows that? I'm not saying you're wrong, but I don't recall that. Even if that were the case, Katsuya can split apart several times and likely would've left part of herself at HQ.

 

[TheWillofFire]

No instead of preparing to teleport they used their last breaths on their kids
Also shikaku and inochi cant survive teleportation

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

No instead of preparing to teleport they used their last breaths on their kids
Also shikaku and inochi cant survive teleportation

You clearly didn't read through the thread.

 

[TheWillofFire]

Shikakus idea of katsuyu was meant for tsunade only
Then the impossible was made more impossible by raikage making mabui teleport for two people instead of one

I doubt shikaku and inoichi did the impossible again even if they had katsuyu

 

[Chatte]

(1) I wasn't aware of that.

(2) Post the page that shows that? I'm not saying you're wrong, but I don't recall that. Even if that were the case, Katsuya can split apart several times and likely would've left part of herself at HQ.

1. Look at Pein arc and see. Tsunade sends Katsuyu her own chakra in order to heal. So from this, the deduction is she only has offensive and endurance properties. At least, until now. I am quite interested in that part with sticking Tsunade's body back... Sounds quite interesting.

2.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

To clear things up,

You must be registered for see links

Katsuyu is still present at the HQ and on Tsunade's back. Most probably, for communication purposes.
However, after Tsunade gets back, there is

You must be registered for see links

So most probably, Tsunade unsummoned her.

Hope it helped the clearing.

 

[TheWillofFire]

Besides what about the rest if HQ?
Ao mabui, etc

Its not just shikaku and inoichi that died, but why should those 2 get to survive over people like ao?

 

[Chatte]

Besides what about the rest if HQ?
Ao mabui, etc

Its not just shikaku and inoichi that died, but why should those 2 get to survive over people like ao?

I am sure no one at the HQ survived. I think the Juubi's TBB took out the whole village.

 

[Tec]

Honestly hope there are dead tbh. To few deaths have actually happened to Characters that we've seen throughout the series in this war. would be a major let down if any of the ones killed come back to life.

 

[WhistleBlower]

WOW, thats.....wow!!

This is very plausible. Great work noticing/figuring this out!!

 

[~Zonta~]

I am sure no one at the HQ survived. I think the Juubi's TBB took out the whole village.

Tsunade did mention something here in this chapter

You must be registered for see links

so just may before TBB hit HQ Katsuya might have saved the day for people at HQ may be reverse summoning or some other jutsu....... since katsuya is medical type she might not let people die so easily IMO

 

[Chatte]

Tsunade did mention something here in this chapter

You must be registered for see links

so just may before TBB hit HQ Katsuya might have saved the day for people at HQ may be reverse summoning or some other jutsu....... since katsuya is medical type she might not let people die so easily IMO

There was no one at the HQ to reverse summon her. Tsunade said to Katsuyu to bring the Kages to her in order to heal, that was before the TBB thing. And I am sure that while the TBB scenario happened, Tsunade was healing the Kages.

 

[HiraishinFTG]

Nice theory but I hope for the sake of the story that they're not alive

 

[Frankenstein]

It's really strange how no one gives a damn about Mabui

 

[~Zonta~]

There was no one at the HQ to reverse summon her. Tsunade said to Katsuyu to bring the Kages to her in order to heal, that was before the TBB thing. And I am sure that while the TBB scenario happened, Tsunade was healing the Kages.

its just a speculation on my part but either way this will have great impact on the story-line...

yeah may be time line in naruto far different than we imagine since K11 took ages to appear to battlefied as compared to sasuke who went to Konoha faster.......

it just might be me expecting some heroic performances from other characters aside from Naruto, Sasuke, Madara.....

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Shikakus idea of katsuyu was meant for tsunade only
Then the impossible was made more impossible by raikage making mabui teleport for two people instead of one

I doubt shikaku and inoichi did the impossible again even if they had katsuyu

He's an intelligent man capable of applying and adapting one solution to many problems. I wouldn't discount this theory merely for that reason.

1. Look at Pein arc and see. Tsunade sends Katsuyu her own chakra in order to heal. So from this, the deduction is she only has offensive and endurance properties. At least, until now. I am quite interested in that part with sticking Tsunade's body back... Sounds quite interesting.

2.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

To clear things up,

You must be registered for see links

Katsuyu is still present at the HQ and on Tsunade's back. Most probably, for communication purposes.
However, after Tsunade gets back, there is

You must be registered for see links

So most probably, Tsunade unsummoned her.

Hope it helped the clearing.

1. I buy that, but I don't think it definitively discounts Katsuya from healing. More so, it suggests that Tsunade may have better healing capabilities.

2. I see that, but that single page doesn't show every single action from when she appeared at HQ to when she left. She could have easily summoned Katsuya off panel, so to speak.

Again, I don't really believe my own theory, I'm just playing devil's advocate.

Besides what about the rest if HQ?
Ao mabui, etc

Its not just shikaku and inoichi that died, but why should those 2 get to survive over people like ao?

I mentioned Mabui by name and all the others indirectly. I wasn't going to unnecessarily put everyone's name in the title and it was irrelevant to the purpose of the theory to include all the names. Shikaku and Inoichi just happen to be the most notable, developed characters that were at HQ.

Honestly hope there are dead tbh. To few deaths have actually happened to Characters that we've seen throughout the series in this war. would be a major let down if any of the ones killed come back to life.

You honestly hope they are dead to be honest?

You must be registered for see images

It's really strange how no one gives a damn about Mabui

You, several others, and I all mentioned Mabui. Despite that, she's an undeveloped character that has very little impact on the overall story. Get over it, dude.

its just a speculation on my part but either way this will have great impact on the story-line...

yeah may be time line in naruto far different than we imagine since K11 took ages to appear to battlefied as compared to sasuke who went to Konoha faster.......

it just might be me expecting some heroic performances from other characters aside from Naruto, Sasuke, Madara.....

I doubt the timeline is that significantly different, but sure. It's possible.

 

[Frankenstein]

Oh sorry then, to be honest I didn't read the first post...or any other post

Mabui ftw lol

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Oh sorry then, to be honest I didn't read the first post...or any other post

Mabui ftw lol

Well, take that as a lesson. Always read ****.

 

[TheWillofFire]

I mentioned Mabui by name and all the others indirectly. I wasn't going to unnecessarily put everyone's name in the title and it was irrelevant to the purpose of the theory to include all the names. Shikaku and Inoichi just happen to be the most notable, developed characters that were at HQ.

So now you are suggesting Mabui saved all of HQ?
Now I really am inclined to not believe, but It wasn't bad theory

Also the katsuyu they have is as tiny as Naruto had with Pain, you think that tiny katsuyu can cover everyone?