Sharingan VS Rinnegan confusion

[AMJ89]

I 1st off just want to say that I'm kind of new to this whole forum thing so I'm sorry if this has been asked before or if it's in the wrong spot.

My question is this. If the rinnegan is such a powerful eye technique, then why does it seem like the people with MS or EMS can kick the asses of those with the rinnegan. (Example: EMS Sasuke/Itachi VS Pain) I keep seeing people say the former would win this battle.

Is EMS stronger than the rinnegan? Does it depend on the user? or are the people saying Itachi or Sasuke could own Pain just crazy. Also how is Madara/Tobi > Sasuke/Itachi if they have mostly the same sharingan abilities? I know he has one of each eye, but if they could beat a rinnegan user anyway how does that really give Madara/Tobi any advantage? Could any of you please help me understand this. Again sorry if this is not posted correctly.

 

[Alphaqindyas]

Rinnegan is stronger because EMS evolves into Rinnegan. Welcome btw. ^_^

 

[opthomasprime]

itachi/sasuke couldnt beat pain...did you see what madara did with his rinnegan!!did you see what pain did to the leaf!!!!!!rinnegan>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>MS/EMS

 

[Hipster Madara]

Rinnegan>Sharingan
However,contrary to what many fanboys have said, that does not mean that the ninja with the rinnegan is better than the ninja with sharingan.
It is just one of the factors you must consider when deciding which character would win.

Btw imo pain would win but not only because he has rinnegan, its how well he utilizes it and can defend against the enemy's attacks

 

[AMJ89]

I'm not arguing with anyone or trying to start a debate I just wanted someone to explain some stuff to me is all.

 

[AMJ89]

So it is pretty much the user of the techniques when it comes down to it. Thats what I was looking for thank you

 

[minato the 4th]

it depends on the user but usualy everyone with the rinnegon is wayyyyy stronger then the ones with ms or ems but there is exeptions in everything

 

[Hipster Madara]

I'm not arguing with anyone or trying to start a debate I just wanted someone to explain some stuff to me is all.

Ok.
welcome to nb btw xd

 

[Lankeysob]

I 1st off just want to say that I'm kind of new to this whole forum thing so I'm sorry if this has been asked before or if it's in the wrong spot.

My question is this. If the rinnegan is such a powerful eye technique, then why does it seem like the people with MS or EMS can kick the asses of those with the rinnegan. (Example: EMS Sasuke/Itachi VS Pain) I keep seeing people say the former would win this battle.

Is EMS stronger than the rinnegan? Does it depend on the user? or are the people saying Itachi or Sasuke could own Pain just crazy. Also how is Madara/Tobi > Sasuke/Itachi if they have mostly the same sharingan abilities? I know he has one of each eye, but if they could beat a rinnegan user anyway how does that really give Madara/Tobi any advantage? Could any of you please help me understand this. Again sorry if this is not posted correctly.

Rinnegan is the stronger eye and yes for the most part Rinnegan users are stronger than the Sharigan users. It took Itachi, Naruto and Bee to defeat Nagato, 5 Kages to face Madara, and the two strongest Jinnchurikki + Kakashi & Guy to fight Tobi. Itachi however seems to be an exception, while I don't think he is stronger than Nagato, his sacred weapons and intelligence put him a notch above other Sharingan users and make him a formidable opponent for even Rinnegan users.

 

[minato the 4th]

Rinnegan is the stronger eye and yes for the most part Rinnegan users are stronger than the Sharigan users. It took Itachi, Naruto and Bee to defeat Nagato, 5 Kages to face Madara, and the two strongest Jinnchurikki + Kakashi & Guy to fight Tobi. Itachi however seems to be an exception, while I don't think he is stronger than Nagato, his sacred weapons and intelligence put him a notch above other Sharingan users and make him a formidable opponent for even Rinnegan users.

amen. i totaly agree

 

[Myno0on]

Rinnegan is the strongest eye.....the eye itself is just a tool they use in a fight,how u use it along with u other tools scales how strong u are.

pain has Rinnegan but he got owned by itachi who has a shirangen in 3 seconds using a sealing sword
yet pain was able to destroy a whole village with one of them had a sharingan called kakshi


Summary: Generally ppl will say pain is the strongest because of his eyes but thats not true.Each person is strong against some and weak against others.

Proof:Shakmaru always beats stronger opponents.

 

[Raito]

Strength is defined differently. The Rinnegan is good in doing miracle things, the Sharingan is a perfect shinobi weapon. The Rinnegan smashes, during the Sharingan is associated with precision. In fights, the Sharingan is the stronger weapon - even the Mangekyou with his divine techniques isn't the highest form of the Sharingan.

The eternal Mangekyo Sharingan is the highest form of the Sharingan, not the Rinnegan. The Rinnegan is an other form of Doujutsu, Madara awoke it additional to his EMS and shortly before his death - maybe because he obtained Senju Hashiramas genes before.

 

[AMJ89]

Rinnegan is the stronger eye and yes for the most part Rinnegan users are stronger than the Sharigan users. It took Itachi, Naruto and Bee to defeat Nagato, 5 Kages to face Madara, and the two strongest Jinnchurikki + Kakashi & Guy to fight Tobi. Itachi however seems to be an exception, while I don't think he is stronger than Nagato, his sacred weapons and intelligence put him a notch above other Sharingan users and make him a formidable opponent for even Rinnegan users.

Thank you, I just needed some clarification.

 

[Joon]

1. Is the EMS stronger than the Rinnegan?
Anwser: No

2. Does it depends on the User?
Anwser: Yes

3. Are the people that is saying "Itachi or Sasuke could own Pain," just crazy?
Answer: It's their own opinion and mostly do to the abilities (MS: Sasunoo/Amatersu/Tsukuyomi) utilize by Itachi.

4. How is Madara/Tobi > Sasuke/Itachi, if they have mostly the same Sharingan abilities?
Answer: Madara and Tobi has more battle experience and far superior skill with their Sharingan.

5. I know he has one of each eye, but if they could beat a rinnegan user anyway how does that really give Madara/Tobi any advantage?
Anwser: IDK, and be more specific

 

[Vayne]

Rinnegan>Sharingan
However,contrary to what many fanboys have said, that does not mean that the ninja with the rinnegan is better than the ninja with sharingan.
It is just one of the factors you must consider when deciding which character would win.

Btw imo pain would win but not only because he has rinnegan, its how well he utilizes it and can defend against the enemy's attacks

this and welcome to base

 

[Lankeysob]

Thank you, I just needed some clarification.

No probelmo Also, welcome to NB!

 

[Raito]

2. Does it depends on the User?
Anwser: Yes

Not at all. The techniques of the Sharingan are the basics of each one, so copy and see through abilities, also strong genjutsus and controls. The three techniques of the Mangekyo - Tsukuyomi, Amaterasu and Susanoo - are the basics of this stage of the Sharingan too.

As I already said, strength is defined differently, especially for fights the Sharingan is the more effective weapon.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

This thread is gonna be full of fanboys.

 

[Illyasviel]

rinnengan is stronger than the sharingan

 

[itachiEMS]

WElcome ^_^
And well you got your answer