Sharingan and Byakugan equal?

[Kira Vs L]

Sharingan is better and for byakugan

I think you mean than the byakugan but why show a clear winner?

 

[L Lawliet]

Wow your the first to say there is a clear winner, would you mind explaining a bit?

I don't mind at all. I even made a thread about it. Take a look.

You must be registered for see links

 

[svladcjelli42]

Byakugan can detect jutsu, Sharingan can see past genjutsu. Point Sharingan.
Byakugan can perceive very long distances, Sharingan can perceive high speed movement. Tie.
Byakugan can perceive tenketsu, Sharingan can perceive chakra flow. Point Byakugan.
Byakugan enables Jyuuken. Sharingan enables advanced shuriken jutsu. Point Byakugan.

Even though the Sharingan allowed Kakashi to copy jutsu, I don't count that among Sharingan's powers. Being 'the copy ninja' was unique to Kakashi - it required his combination of extreme intelligence, skill, and access to four elemental styles. We saw Sasuke learn some of Rock Lee's moves with the Sharingan, but he didn't do that instantly on the spot - it was months later. It would be valid to say Sharingan allows users to learn jutsu they've seen, barring physical impossibilities such as other Kekkei Genkai.

Byakugan allows 357 degree vision.

Someone pointed out that Sharingan has Izanagi, but that requires Hashirama's DNA and loss of the eye.

Since we are ignoring the fact that Sharingan can evolve into Mangekyou, I'd say Byakugan are the superior doujutsu.

 

[Kira Vs L]

You're wrong. Sharingan cant copy Kekkei Genkai.

He was referring to the fact the the gentle fist is the fighting style of the hyuga in which a sharingan user would not be able to copy. Well actually they would be able to copy the movements of it but without the byakugan the fighting style is pretty pointless.

 

[sulanis]

I don't think that is a fair question to ask! The reason i say that is because the Byakugan has got almost no spot light since neji fought Naruto and Kidomaru. The Sharingan is used so much that i think poeple don't actually know how the Byakugan actually works and the full extent of its abilities.

All poeple have see for the most part is nothing but the Sharingan, and we've never actually seen a Byakugan vs Sharingan fight.


People say that the Sharingan can predict movement of the user, this is correct it can, but the Byakugan can see in an 360 degree vision which allows the user to see and react to the attack almost instantly. These are the words ofKkidoumaru. The Byakugan also has far better insight then the Sharingan(stated by Kakashi), which if used correctly will allow the Byakugan user to effectively predict what an opponent will do. As effective as Sharingan, probably not.

Both can see the chakra within the Body, Byakugan Also excels in this because not only can they see the chakra, but they can also see the chakra network system. And with proper discipline, the Byakugan can watch and see where the chakra is being molded and effectively counter where, and how powerful the attack will be.

Sharingan main advantage, is its ability to copy non kekkai genkai jutsu and use it for themselves. This is an amazing ability, but like all humans, Chakra is limited and can make copying useless if you don't have the Chakra to support it. (Kakashi is the perfect example)

Sharingan can be countered, but two different skilled opponents, but is not possible with a Byakugan User as they have 360 degree vision. Oh and let us not forget that the Byakugan can also see miles ahead if necessary to do some recon.

I don't think its fair to say Sharingan is best because its my favourite.

No, it all depends on skill of the tool used by the shinobi. Byakugan and Sharingan, both kick ass.

But in my personal opinion Byakugan is better then 3 Tomoe Sharigan!

 

[L Lawliet]

He was referring to the fact the the gentle fist is the fighting style of the hyuga in which a sharingan user would not be able to copy. Well actually they would be able to copy the movements of it but without the byakugan the fighting style is pretty pointless.

It's not just that. The Hyuuga are very proficient in extracting and throwing chakra from any single part of their bodies, whereas the Uchiha focus in the basic points only. You remember Neji owning a Zetsu clone in the war without using his arms or his legs? An Uchiha with only 3 tomoe Sharingan wouldn't have been able to do that. Tsunade, Shizune and Sakura are proof of how hard it is to control chakra while not being a Hyuuga.

 

[The Western Wheel]

Hmmmmm, the Sharingan can read all of the Byakugan user's movements and copy them.... but the Byukugan user has the ultimate defense against any attack... Also, a Sharingan user wouldn't be able to copy ''gentle fist'' so if the Byakugan user manages to hit him once then the Sharingan user would be K.O'd immediately. I dunno, I think they're pretty much on an equal level.

Yup... this... so it depends on the fighter.

I'd chose Byukugan above Sharingan any day, considering I can see almost 360 degrees. Taijutsu is rendered useless.. most ninjutsu useless, Genjutsu useless to any intelligent Byakugan user.

Three tomoe sharingan is only good if you are good with genjutsu(or better than your opponent) or copying.. so pretty useless to stronger, or KK users.

 

[Kira Vs L]

I don't mind at all. I even made a thread about it. Take a look.

You must be registered for see links

Really nice thread man even going into ms abilities I wasn't trying to do that I figured people would just start hating so I didn't get into it

 

[UchihaInza]

it would come down to a level of skill i think..but the sharingan is stronger than byakugan..but you can actually see chakra flow with the byakugan..so it does have its advantages ...but if it came down to it wich one would you have??i pick sharingan Uchiha Inza

 

[Kira Vs L]

Byakugan can detect jutsu, Sharingan can see past genjutsu. Point Sharingan.
Byakugan can perceive very long distances, Sharingan can perceive high speed movement. Tie.
Byakugan can perceive tenketsu, Sharingan can perceive chakra flow. Point Byakugan.
Byakugan enables Jyuuken. Sharingan enables advanced shuriken jutsu. Point Byakugan.

Even though the Sharingan allowed Kakashi to copy jutsu, I don't count that among Sharingan's powers. Being 'the copy ninja' was unique to Kakashi - it required his combination of extreme intelligence, skill, and access to four elemental styles. We saw Sasuke learn some of Rock Lee's moves with the Sharingan, but he didn't do that instantly on the spot - it was months later. It would be valid to say Sharingan allows users to learn jutsu they've seen, barring physical impossibilities such as other Kekkei Genkai.

Byakugan allows 357 degree vision.

Someone pointed out that Sharingan has Izanagi, but that requires Hashirama's DNA and loss of the eye.

Since we are ignoring the fact that Sharingan can evolve into Mangekyou, I'd say Byakugan are the superior doujutsu.

That's one way of comparing them really good an unbiased I liked it.

 

[Kira Vs L]

it would come down to a level of skill i think..but the sharingan is stronger than byakugan..but you can actually see chakra flow with the byakugan..so it does have its advantages ...but if it came down to it wich one would you have??i pick sharingan Uchiha Inza

Lol if I'd pick one I'd be byakugan but it's more about in a fight a against each other who'd win and I think they are pretty even an the skill of the individual is more important no one has a clear advantage but that's just me

 

[sulanis]

I don't mind at all. I even made a thread about it. Take a look.

You must be registered for see links

I read your thread and it was really well done, i didn't comment however, but its basically the same way i think about it the byakugan(hyuga as well). You looked at all points very well so in my opinion plus rep.

 

[Kira Vs L]

I don't think that is a fair question to ask! The reason i say that is because the Byakugan has got almost no spot light since neji fought Naruto and Kidomaru. The Sharingan is used so much that i think poeple don't actually know how the Byakugan actually works and the full extent of its abilities.

All poeple have see for the most part is nothing but the Sharingan, and we've never actually seen a Byakugan vs Sharingan fight.


People say that the Sharingan can predict movement of the user, this is correct it can, but the Byakugan can see in an 360 degree vision which allows the user to see and react to the attack almost instantly. These are the words ofKkidoumaru. The Byakugan also has far better insight then the Sharingan(stated by Kakashi), which if used correctly will allow the Byakugan user to effectively predict what an opponent will do. As effective as Sharingan, probably not.

Both can see the chakra within the Body, Byakugan Also excels in this because not only can they see the chakra, but they can also see the chakra network system. And with proper discipline, the Byakugan can watch and see where the chakra is being molded and effectively counter where, and how powerful the attack will be.

Sharingan main advantage, is its ability to copy non kekkai genkai jutsu and use it for themselves. This is an amazing ability, but like all humans, Chakra is limited and can make copying useless if you don't have the Chakra to support it. (Kakashi is the perfect example)

Sharingan can be countered, but two different skilled opponents, but is not possible with a Byakugan User as they have 360 degree vision. Oh and let us not forget that the Byakugan can also see miles ahead if necessary to do some recon.

I don't think its fair to say Sharingan is best because its my favourite.

No, it all depends on skill of the tool used by the shinobi. Byakugan and Sharingan, both kick ass.

But in my personal opinion Byakugan is better then 3 Tomoe Sharigan!

Yea that's true we really haven't seen the full extent of the byakugan, and I agree they are both amazing.

 

[TheCCV]

If a no name from each clan fought each other, first stage Sharingan, the Hyuga would win.
But the Uchiha clan has more famous shinobi.

 

[Kira Vs L]

If a no name from each clan fought each other, first stage Sharingan, the Hyuga would win.
But the Uchiha clan has more famous shinobi.

Well they are more famous because of ms or just regular sharingan? And I think it'd be a tough fight for both and just skill rather than their kks.