Sasukes "Revolution" Was a Bad Idea

[Itachi The L Giver]

Is see a lot of messages like," Sasukes revolution is better than what Naruto did," or ,"His revolution would have worked, Naruto is too optimistic."

Lol, no

Sasuke wanted to MURDER the Gokage and TAKE the Bijuu in order to unify the world and eliminate factions by force. Simply put it's a childish idea. You would think,"well yeah if he eliminates factions by force then no more war yayyy." It's similar to what Indra and Kaguya believed. Probably similar to what someone like Fidel Castro or Kim Jong Un would believe.

This is selfish, very very optimistic, and just plain dictatorish. I don't believe NV would just submit to his will, even if he were able to

1) Beat Naruto and be Strong enough after to undo IT and take over the world
2) Kill the Gokage
3) Somehow make every Village in this vast Ninja World submit to his will

What kind of world would this be exactly?

Naruto believes that relationships and bonds with other people and other nations is attainable. At that point in the story, the Ninja World was ready for that.

Sasuke had his heart in the right place and it works well on paper but Naruto's ideals were better. Sasuke tried to take what Itachi taught him and contorted it into something borderline evil.

 

[Reboryushon]

He was in the need for some therapy with Doctor Naruto.

 

[UCHIHAKUNOICHI]

His Revolution is the extreme of Indra's will in my opinion. Everything would go back to Kaguya's era, where the ruler is seen as a monster or even worse, in this case, Sasuke. That's why his saving by Naruto was so special and important.

 

[Itachi The L Giver]

His Revolution is the extreme of Indra's will in my opinion. Everything would go back to Kaguya's era, where the ruler is seen as a monster or even worse, in this case, Sasuke. That's why his saving by Naruto was so special and important.

I can agree with this. I take back what I said about him twisting Itachi's ideals.

 

[Jiren]

Sasukes plan just needed a slight revision but overall great plan. Just needed a fail safe

 

[Itachi The L Giver]

Sasukes plan just needed a slight revision but overall great plan. Just needed a fail safe

It wasn't necessarily stupid or anything, I just think it was much harder than he thought. It's part Kishimoto's fault because Sasuke is known for his spot on analyses and his intellect. He could have came up with a much better plan.

 

[Narutobase Police]

Thing is, Sasuke's ideal was neither bad nor good. He wanted to create a autocracy. Ruling as the almighty, and most powerful, silencing anyone who would speak against his judgement. This is one way to create peace, through fear, and submission.

His decision like I previously stated was neither good, nor bad because that can only be determined by the outlook of others. On one hand, you could have a society that greatly approved of being under the rule of an almighty ruler, who would defeat any problem to disrupting his well-established peace.

On the other hand, you could have a society that greatly disapproves, wanting a democracy (Naruto's ideal).

So no. Sasuke's revolution wasn't a bad idea.

 

[Melanin]

He was going the wrong way about things. He wanted to fix the shinobi world by rebuilding it, killing the Kages (worlds leadership) would've helped him achieve that if you think about it because killing them removes them from power and influence. Sasuke planed on duplicating Indra's path of forcing peace on everyone through his near unstoppable power.

So is it bad morally? Yes but it would've worked.

 

[Jokule67]

Sasukes plan just needed a slight revision but overall great plan. Just needed a fail safe

Lelouches plan from Code Geass was 100% better. He fused BOTH Narutos and Sasukes plans.

 

[lndra]

I can't but help at laugh at his revolution plan. Dude was being completely retarded.

"Let me cast away all the things in the past, but, I believe Itachi was the true Hokage despite thinking that I should cast him away"

Sasuke's plan was completely retarded. The only fail safe was the dictatorship, outside of that, he would of just murdered everyone. Good luck killing all the Village's Kage's, and not expecting people to revolt.

He'll just end up scaring people to death and they'll live based on that fear. He'd create a world built on the exact opposite of what Itachi wanted him to grow up as. Hilariously stupid.

I can't even comment on how he wanted to kill the people who had absolutely nothing to do with the Leaf Village's failed past. Like what the **** does Tsunade out of all people have to be murdered because of failed leadership of the leaf, and the Uchiha Clan?

I could go on with this, but it was just bad writing overall.

 

[Mellow]

He was in the need for some therapy with Doctor Naruto.

too bad Dentist Sasuke knocked his teeth out

 

[Itachi The L Giver]

He was going the wrong way about things. He wanted to fix the shinobi world by rebuilding it, killing the Kages (worlds leadership) would've helped him achieve that if you think about it because killing them removes them from power and influence. Sasuke planed on duplicating Indra's path of forcing peace on everyone through his near unstoppable power.

So is it bad morally? Yes but it would've worked.

Nope, it would have just led to a revolt + more death and war.

Paradoxically it would have just backfired in his face

 

[Melanin]

Nope, it would have just led to a revolt + more death and war.

Paradoxically it would have just backfired in his face

There wouldn't be revolt because Sasuke squash rebellion before it's even an option. Your forgetting Sasukes power would be 100% absolute and in order for their to be war there would have to opposing sides. All of the shinobi in the world would be no match for 1/4 of his power with Naruto out of the way.

Either you bend or break!

 

[lndra]

Nope, it would have just led to a revolt + more death and war.

Paradoxically it would have just backfired in his face

Yeah I don't get why people just say they'll just live happily ever after. Even in Naruto's set goal, that didn't end well. If Naruto out of all people was taken out by the progress of the world, how would Sasuke, who is as strong as Naruto, would not face the same backlash of the people who would hate him?

It makes no sense. Sasuke would just make himself a target in the long run, and he would just have to destroy everyone and everything in his path. What kind of 'peace' is built up from the ashes of the past failures ... When Sasuke himself is still committing acts of hatred?

In the end Sasuke would just have to murder innocent civilians/shinobi who completely disagree with his plan regardless. Good-luck killing Kage's and expecting the people to just idly sit by while they await this reborn society.

He'd make a place where children would be born and raised to fear an Almighty God who is Law. Every plan at 'peace' backfires some way or another because there's just way too many obstacles at stake for reaching a goal which really has no solution. Even Madara's IT plan was retarded in the end because instead of placing the world under sleep, they would all turn to Zetsu's and die, plus humanity wouldn't come back since they would all be dead.

I'm pretty sure Naruto's plan backfired because of the constant state of cooperation, the World was able to progress to a point where even regular humans can achieve the power of a shinobi, through a shinobi of course (Boruto Movie). In that stance, it's not impossible for someone to reach the power of a God as they discover new tools, new sources of power. So when some like 'Kawaki' who hates the shinobi world for what-ever reason can rise to power thanks to the World's efforts, he can bring chaos to everything Naruto established.

Sasuke killing every little person who gets in his way isn't peace, anyone who thinks so is literally deranged. Bet none of them can name one dictatorship in the today's world that actually worked.

 

[Itachi The L Giver]

There wouldn't be revolt because Sasuke squash rebellion before it's even an option. Sasukes power would 100% absolute and there would be no match for 1/4 of his power with Naruto out of the way. Either you bend or break!

Que? I'm pretty sure I outlined it in the OP.

If he beat Naruto and undid IT he would be powerless too defeat the Gokage + Ninja World.

If he waited to recover then undo IT everyone would be dead.

Theoretically speaking if he did accomplish this how could he squash a rebellion in Konoha and every other village at the same time? If so, how? Would he kill the villagers he wants to protect, or create war despite his original ideals? There lies the paradox and bad reasoning/ideal. I can assume the NV wouldn't just give up and live in a dictatorship especially after hearing he killed the Gokage and Naruto.

@Indra said it well. It's just a bad plan overall.

 

[Reboryushon]

too bad Dentist Sasuke knocked his teeth out

Part of the therapy process.

 

[Jokule67]

too bad Dentist Sasuke knocked his teeth out

Same happened to Sasuke if you remember

 

[Jiren]

Lelouches plan from Code Geass was 100% better. He fused BOTH Narutos and Sasukes plans.

Best anime ever

 

[Kanino]

His had no business in doing that after all that happened, there was no reason to do it anymore or to even fight Naruto. You seriously think that after, Kabuto, Obito, Madara and Kaguya this Nig was going to win? be a threat? No! lol Imo his revolution felt like nothing at all.

 

[Nagi]

Wrong. Sasuke clearly said he will be controlling everything from the shadow meaning. He will not come out in the open like Kaguya.

His plan is the same as Lelouch's plan and it worked out well for Lelouch!

His had no business in doing that after all that happened, there was no reason to do it anymore or to even fight Naruto. You seriously think that after, Kabuto, Obito, Madara and Kaguya this Nig was going to win? be a threat? No! lol Imo his revolution felt like nothing at all.

Very true! But It is plot no jutsu. The creator wants Naruto to save everybody. Like Honestly. Sasuke shouldn't have been dealing with the Shinobi world after killing Danzo. He should've taken the rurouni Kenshin path.

Same for Madara! Your family is gone. So who are you doing this for?

Leave the shinobi world and live your life in peace up in the mountain