[Discussion] Sasuke wants communism and Naruto wants democracy

[Frikid]

You must be registered for see images

From what i have read, i think Sasuke wants communism and Naruto wants democracy.

In real life, Example of a communist government would be China and Example of a democracy would be India.

There are merits and demerits of both of them.

Now, this is NOT the real world, but NINJA WORLD.
So KEEP IN MIND, you CANNOT use real world approach as it is.

This is a world where ninjas get missions to kill each other, even the ninja from the same country kill each other.
Here, a mass murderer can get the highest rank in the village [Gaara became tsuchikage].

Clearly killing is not seen as a crime and the idea of "an eye for an eye" works in this world.

While there are many similarities between real world and ninja world, it still have its differences, enough differences to go for a different approach.

Now keeping ALL THIS IN MIND, Whose approach do you think is better?
Sasuke's approach of communism or Naruto's approach of democracy?

OR do you think neither of that will work and you have a better suggestion?

Note : Please keep fanboyism to the minimum. Stupid Posts will be reported.

---

Also, i think i have to think about this a little before i put forth my opinion since this will involve a lot of factors.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

No, Sasuke's would be more like Stalin's brand of communism aka dictatorship.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Pumpkin Ninja]

Agreed. People are dumb.

 

[Mellow]

Sasukes wants a world without power hungry bafoons even tho he is one himself

 

[Senpou]

Easy: Naruto.
Sasuke's way will never be acknowledged completely neither naruto's. But people always prefer peaceful life. Sasuke's way is cruel and it may end up taking away the freedom from people. Not going too much into it for now, i'm lazy as hell today lol.

 

[Jennifer Lawrence]

Good thread and I agree, but Gaara became Kazekage not Tsuchikage xD

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

TC says you cannot use real world approaches to this but relates sasuke and naruto's ideals to real world governments seems legit, on a serious note there are many forms of each government there's direct and representative democracy and for communism you have oligarchy, theocracy's, dictators, etc. The best choice is obviously Naruto's from a moral perspective but from a realistic perspective sasuke's is better, personally people will say Naruto cause it will bring true peace I fall into the crowd of naruto's ideal. One could argue sasuke because he is trying to get rid of the main problem causes of the ninja world. He's trying to fix the past and remove negative influences of them and make a system where everyone can have peace and live happy but not without getting rid of some factors first, among other things.

You can't really get right answers as this is a hindsight bias everyone grew up with a different background so asking them which is better is ambiguous but morally Naruto is right just realistically sasuke is right.

 

[Filo]

Sasukes wants a world without power hungry bafoons even tho he is one himself

will he be the only one with any power

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

In the Naruto verse or real life? If you know anything about humanity we are not as a whole naturally peaceful though we want peace innately we also desire violence to add spice to our lives, if life was completely peaceful people would try to find a way to entertain themselves with violence it's a sad but true statement not all humans are like this but most. Same goes for the Narutoverse I mean when you look at people like in the akatsuki, danzo, or even Naruto shows some excitement in fighting sasuke.

 

[ShinjuMadara]

True Communism relies on Democracy

A Dictatorship is not communism

 

[MysticLeviathan]

Not quite. Naruto doesn't want democracy, but to be a benevolent dictator chosen by the people. Sasuke wants more of a Stalinist government where he pretends to be for the people, but oppresses the ****ing shit out of them.

It's really not as simple as democracy vs. communism or democracy vs. dictatorship.